3 ms·
> When I’ve served as a peer reviewer I’ve read the papers closely and checked all the steps of the proofs, and that means that I have replicated the results.
by gus_massa 5y ago
> When I’ve served as a peer reviewer I’ve read the papers closely and checked all the steps of the proofs, and that means that I have replicated the results.
The side effect is that math papers have an insane long time to publication. Perhaps 6 months, or 1 year or more if you are unlucky.
In physics, the publication time is like 3 month. Something like 1 month for the first review and then two months for making small changes suggested by the referee and discussing with the editor.
As a side^2 effect, some citation index of the journals count only the citations during the first year. But the papers that have the citation are sleeping over the reviewer desk during that year, so the number is lower than the real number.