3 ms·

It would be great if this material could help with brain damage in contact sports by making helmets better.

• abeppu 5y ago
  That's a very specific application. Isn't there a bound on the efficacy of a helmet based on its size / thickness? I.e. your head's initial velocity and the thickness of the helmet constrain the distance over which your head's velocity must drop to zero, so there's some minimum force that must be applied to your head no matter what the helmet's material is?
  • MarcoZavala 5y ago
  • deleted 5y ago
    [deleted]
  • kbelder 5y ago
    Conclusion: The helmets must be bigger, much bigger. I don't know their current thickness; maybe 2 cm? If we expand that to a cushioned 10-20cm all the way around their head, the force would be reduced by a factor of five to ten. I'd imagine they could head-butt all day long without damage, and football games would be much more entertaining.
    • deleted 5y ago
      [deleted]
• eointierney 5y ago
  Helmets have an interesting correlation with concussion. They can help a lot in cycling, hurling, and f1, but can encourage reckless collision seeking in american football for example. Contact sports are intrinsically dangerous and introducing protection from one type of damage can allow increase in other damage forms. Avoid collisions I reckon rugby must change the most, which is a real shame because rugby at the highest level is amazing Though ice hockey is pretty daft
• copperwater69 5y ago
  There is a strong correlation between neck weakness and brain damage in contact sports Search "NFL neck" in a search engine and look at the images
• xhevahir 5y ago
  Apparently people have been experimenting with magnets in football helmets for several years now, albeit much larger ones: https://leaps.org/this-brain-doc-has-a-repulsive-idea-to-make-football-safer/particle-3 https://leaps.org/this-brain-doc-has-a-repulsive-idea-to-mak...