3 ms·
> several other risky groups that most people buying Teslas aren't part of. This is a fallacy. Ask any demographic you like if they're road ragers, drunk driv
by ajross 5y ago
> several other risky groups that most people buying Teslas aren't part of.
This is a fallacy. Ask any demographic you like if they're road ragers, drunk drivers, etc... and they'll deny it. Everyone is sure that rare and terrible outcomes will never happen to them because of their own behavior, including the people to whom it happens!
It's probably true that middle aged premium car owners are safer on average, but you don't get to rule that stuff out by fiat. In fact there have been a few "Autopilot Saves Passed Out Driver" stories over the past few months, where Tesla drivers were clearly impaired.
As for this particular paper: this is just P-hacking folks. You can't take a vague dataset[1] and then "correct" it like this without absolutely huge error bars. Why correct based only these variables? Why did they all push the results in one direction? Why not gender? Why not income? Why not compare vs. like cars?
This isn't good statistics, it's just more statistics. If we want the real answers we should get a better data set (which, I'll agree, would likely involve some regulatory pressure on manufacturers).
[1] And, to be fair: Tesla's safety report is hardly comprehensive and provides no data other than the aggregate numbers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI just think a lot of Tesla drivers see themselves as elite drivers or something when we all know that's not true if you step back away from the situation.
- Majromax 5y ago> You can't take a vague dataset and then "correct" it like this without absolutely huge error bars. That ship has already sailed; Tesla makes active safety claims based on that dataset. To hold research to your standard here would be to say that Tesla can make its claims, but nobody can challenge those claims. > Why did they all push the results in one direction? If you have two correction steps, then a priori you'd expect a 25% chance that they both act in the same direction. I don't think this is very remarkable. > Why not gender? This probably would be a reasonable addition. I doubt it would change the results much, but we have the well-known fact that insurance rates differ for men and women, so it may be relevant. > Why not income? First, is this data even generally available? If the data doesn't exist, then we can't control for it. Second, should we expect crash rates per mile driven to differ greatly by owner/driver income? A priori, I wouldn't think this demographic quality to have a strong impact. > Why not compare vs. like cars? I think "personal vehicle" is a reasonable comparative category. Would we expect collision rates to differ greatly between more specific categorizations? For the sake of the overall conclusion, would we expect Tesla-equivalents to be particularly crash prone in the broad dataset? Any statistical analysis will have its limitations, but when we're talking about life-safety claims from a manufacturer I think we should have wide latitude to look at critical evaluations of the original data.
- ajross 5y ago> That ship has already sailed; Tesla makes active safety claims based on that dataset. To hold research to your standard here would be to say that Tesla can make its claims, but nobody can challenge those claims. I don't follow that logic. Claiming that Tesla's data set is incomplete is fine. That doesn't mean that any junk science that refutes it must be correct. Bad statistics is bad statistics. This kind of "correlate dissimilar data sets by using more dissimilar data" is a terrible way to do science. Quite frankly it's almost guaranteed to be wrong. There are regulatory bodies out there with access to real data. Get them to figure it out.