3 ms·
Pulling (tensile), which is also the direction steel is unusually strong in (from a materials perspective). Compression wise it’s close to a wet noodle the way
by lazide 5y ago
Pulling (tensile), which is also the direction steel is unusually strong in (from a materials perspective).
Compression wise it’s close to a wet noodle the way it’s manufacturable (though that has more to do with cost/practical production/gathering methods - if we could get a solid chunk of it I imagine it would be pretty strong in compression).
Sliding, it’s a fiber, so very weak in that sense (barring the same scenario above). It actively flexes, so isn’t strong’
- ghaff 5y agoAs I recall my material science, it's not so much that steel is weak in compression but, if you have a rod of steel (i.e. much longer than it is thick), if you compress it, it will buckle and shear. As you suggest--I'd have to look up the numbers--but a large cube of steel probably has similar strength with tensile and compressive loads. ADDED: In fact, if you deform a supported I-beam you get similar amounts of tension and compression on the bottom and top respectively at the mid-point of the beam (given a variety of assumptions).
- user_7832 5y ago> but a large cube of steel probably has similar strength with tensile and compressive loads. Not just similar, but pretty much identical from what I recalled from my uni classes. Wikipedia for structural materials (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structural_material https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structural_material) also has this bit - >Steel is equally strong in tension and compression.
- ghaff 5y agoAs I wrote in another comment, my material science and mechanical engineering is very rusty at this point. :-) But, yeah, I-beams basically wouldn't work if steel were weak in compression because, assuming a straightforward loading of a supported beam you're basically putting one flange of the beam in tension and the other flange in the equivalent amount of compression. So the fact that one part of the I-beam is strong would be pretty much irrelevant if the other part were weak.
- Infernal 5y agoI read the grandparent the same way you did at first. GP is talking about spider silk in all three of those points.