3 ms·
A straw man is a statement that is trivially disprovable. Just because you stood them up without knocking them down does not stop them from being straw men. Th
by mindslight 5y ago
A straw man is a statement that is trivially disprovable. Just because you stood them up without knocking them down does not stop them from being straw men.
That money comes from premiums for Medicare and money saved from private "insurance". The correct comparison is not simply your current tax rate, but rather your tax rate plus the amount you're currently paying for "insurance".
Medicare is not some free thing for the elderly, but rather is paid into by monthly social security payments. Adjust the premium amount to remove any retirement subsidy, and allow non-retired people to buy into the existing system. This would add a well-established competitor to a market currently dominated by the health "insurance" cartel.
The "free" healthcare is Medicaid which is available to everyone, but only after they're rendered unemployable and bankrupted due to medical problems. Doesn't it make more sense to allow people to buy into a healthcare plan and keep working rather than making them stay destitute so they can quality for medical care?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI am a big proponent for an at-cost public option medicare, and always disappointed that it is rarely taken seriously. That said, only a minority of Medicare funds come from payroll taxes. The biggest contribution is from other taxes. See page 7: https://files.kff.org/attachment/Issue-Brief-Facts-on-Medicaid-Spending-and-Financing#:~:text=In%202018%2C%20Medicare%20spending%20(net,federal%20budget%20(Figure%201) https://files.kff.org/attachment/Issue-Brief-Facts-on-Medica....
- mindslight 5y agoTaking page 7's 85% figure for high earners, the $578.30 Part B premium figure for high earners, the $77.90 Part D premium for high earners, and the $499 Part A premium for people who didn't pay in, creates a total monthly premium of $1271. This is for old people or disabled people who have many more chronic health problems. Surely this figure can be drastically reduced for younger people without chronic health problems, and can likely beat what the governmentesque "private" companies charge for non-employer plans. Furthermore, there is probably no better solution to paying for bankruptcy-level chronic health problems than public funds, despite the cost. The prevailing fiction is that such expensive individuals will be part of some non-correlated social "group" and paid for by other members. But the incentives are completely wrong, in that an insurer or employer doesn't want to pay for that market-inefficient burden, and will look for every reason to deny claims or remove from group. So considering those extreme expenses a fixed cost (which are being paid by the public now regardless, through Medicare, Medicaid, or unpaid debt), implies that average individual premiums would be even less.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoLike I said, I'm a huge proponent of a an at cost Medicare option. I don't understand why this is a poison pill for so many people on the left especially. In my mind it is the way the government should operate: provide a non coercive option that helps people. It can be easily separated from the economic redistributive function of government and stand alone. If at a later date, the Feds decide to Levy a tax to cover people that can't afford it, they always can. Seems like a perfect test case to see if the gov can compete with the private market on cost and satisfaction.
- mindslight 5y agoI agree with where you're coming from. I think there's a huge desire to solve everything in one fell swoop in some imagined perfect plan. I'll get similar pushback when talking about common sense market based reforms for the healthcare industry, completely orthogonal to who's paying. A predictable response is always "yeah, so when you fly through your windshield you can whip out your phone in the air and search for which hospital has the best rates", completely ignoring that most healthcare is non emergency and even in many emergency situations people still make decisions to avoid being financially screwed. There's so much low hanging fruit of things that patently do not make sense and would be politically-neutral for people, yet fixing them would disempower some middleman and no new pockets would get filled, and so there is no political support.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoyeah, I guess it could have to do with big flashy ideas that capture the imagination. More cynically, I guess there is a perverse incentive in that marginal improvements reduce the pressure for major reform. My favorite simple reform that everyone hates: encourage the training of more doctors and nurses. Wages are a major driver of healthcare costs, and there are a number of constraints on the supply. Another is to bar hospital price discrimination between different insurance providers and cash payers. The idea that hospitals milk some customers to subsidize others is absurd
- colechristensen 5y agoIndeed, that is not at all what a straw man argument is, go look it up. Medicare is not at all comparable to the coverage you get with private health insurance. Single payer healthcare systems have zero or very very low costs to the patient, nothing at all like the deductibles, coinsurance, and out of pocket maximums you find in private health insurance. You don't really know what you're talking about on several points and it doesn't seem to be worth correcting each one of your misconceptions.
- mindslight 5y agoI said "straw men", not "straw man arguments". Each of my following sentences was a quick refutation of the fallacies you based your argument on. It's almost like they were talking points with no bearing in reality - for example, Medicare is decidedly distinct from the VA. It's difficult to have a discussion with someone who is drawing assertions from an alternate reality. It's also funny you said I don't know anything about Medicare given that I handled my father's healthcare for several years. There were definitely deductibles, "coinsurance" (aka percentage-based deductibles), and out of pocket maximums for Parts A, B, and D. I straight up said I'd prefer market based solutions, to actually address the administrative cancer that is responsible for ballooning healthcare costs - in what other industry are vendors allowed to keep prices secret and then send arbitrary bills afterwards based on how they feel? But I have seen no credible attempts for reform by the other Party, instead deferring to the absolutely insane status quo. And no, a few executive orders to publish fictitious chargemasters don't count - I'm talking real reform like requiring providers to set a single price schedule regardless of who is paying. Until there is a credible alternative plan for industry reform, then unfortunately M4A is the only plan addressing the insanity of the current system.