3 ms·
> Because he is a designer, or a somewhat more technical person, he may love fiddling with settings, but the vast majority of people do not. They do not change
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
> Because he is a designer, or a somewhat more technical person, he may love fiddling with settings, but the vast majority of people do not. They do not change their mouse speed, their background image, their default browser. That's why a meme exists of people thinking the internet is the blue E icon on their desktop.
Just because most users don't use a thing doesn't mean it's not a useful thing to have. Even if almost never called the emergency services doesn't mean I don't want or need the ability to do so. Further, being able to adjust the cursor speed is great for improving accessibility.
> If you have sensible defaults, you can make users do actions that you want them to do
What about what the users want to do? What entitles you to decide what is good for other people? That's just creepy as fuck.
- cercatrova 5y ago> Just because most users don't use a thing doesn't mean it's not a useful thing to have. Even if almost never called the emergency services doesn't mean I don't want or need the ability to do so. Further, being able to adjust the cursor speed is great for improving accessibility. I never said to remove settings entirely, merely to choose sensible defaults. > What about what the users want to do? What entitles you to decide what is good for other people? That's just creepy as fuck. This is a strange comment. It's literally the job of the designer to make sure users can do what they need to do in the application, I'm not sure how that's "creepy as fuck." But also, there's a notion of libertarian paternalism [0], ie give people choices but also have defaults that are defaulted to the better, healthier, more beneficial option so to speak, because the designer would know that most people may not change their settings. You wouldn't want your pointer speed to be excessively fast, that would just be annoying, so set the default at a reasonable level and let people change it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_(book)#Libertarian_paternalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nudge_(book)#Libertarian_pater... > Sunstein and Thaler state that "the libertarian aspect of our strategies lies in the straightforward insistence that, in general, people should be free to do what they like-and to opt out of undesirable arrangements if they want to do so".[18] The paternalistic portion of the term "lies in the claim that it is legitimate for choice architects to try to influence people's behavior in order to make their lives longer, healthier, and better".
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> If you have sensible defaults, you can make users do actions that you want them to do > It's literally the job of the designer to make sure users can do what they need to do in the application, See, this is two entirely different things. The notion of attempting to manipulate the behavior of people without their knowledge or consent is creepy no matter how you twist or turn it.
- cercatrova 5y agoDesign is manipulating people into doing what you want, I don't see how you can get away from that. A designer must make choices on what they want to user to see and do, that's what a default is. Perhaps you're thinking of stuff like r/assholedesign?
- marginalia_nu 5y agoMust it be about manipulating people? Can't it be about bringing utility?
- ovao 5y agoAt a high level, there’s good utility in guiding users down the path of a curated experience when the designers know the weak points of the app, or where some given tool has much more general utility than another (in which case they might hide the other tool under a context menu or something). It’s not necessarily the case that designers guide users down paths that solely benefit the designer, and I think that approach tends to be seen by most as “bad design”. In fact, it might even be bad design by definition.
- Erdromian 5y agoYou can frame it any way you want, but you are manipulating them TO bring utility. You are making a choice, on their behalf, that influences how they experience something without their knowledge or explicit consent. Just because you might intend them only the best, doesn't change that it is a form of unseen manipulation.
- Zak 5y ago> What about what the users want to do? What entitles you to decide what is good for other people? That's just creepy as fuck. It depends. "I want the user to find the useful capabilities of my software" isn't creepy at all. That's just good design. "I want the user to do things that are against their interests but make more money for me" is the core characteristic of a dark pattern.