4 ms·
It is quite certain that a 2-dimensional polymer cannot be recycled like metal, glass or a thermoplastic material, i.e. by remelting or by plastic deformation a
by adrian_b 5y ago
It is quite certain that a 2-dimensional polymer cannot be recycled like metal, glass or a thermoplastic material, i.e. by remelting or by plastic deformation at high temperatures, because a 2-dimensional polymer cannot be deformed without breaking covalent bonds and it cannot flow in a liquid state.
So this new material might behave like the existing cured polymeric resins, e.g. epoxy resins, which form a 3-dimensional network of covalent bonds after curing, so they cannot be melted, and which when heated decompose before melting. Such materials can usually be recycled only by burning.
Nonetheless, there might be a more complex way to recycle the new materials, if the new materials would decompose in monomer molecules when heated or if there would exist some solvent able to break the bonds between monomer molecules, transforming the solid 2-dimensional polymer into a solution of the monomer molecules.
If such a method to depolymerize the 2-dimensional polymer would exist, the obtained monomer could be reused to synthesize again 2-dimensional polymers.
If the depolymerization is impossible then these materials would be used in the same way like the already existing and widely used insoluble and infusible polymeric resins.
More important for their success is what processing methods will be applicable for them. After the 2-dimensional sheets are formed, they cannot be processed by any of the popular methods, e.g. injection in a mold. The thermoset polymers behave similarly after curing, but they are produced in a state where they are only partially polymerized in 1-dimensional molecules, so they can be molded in the final shape and the complete polymerization happens later.
For now, it seems that these new 2-dimensional polymers can be made only as sheets, and then you must cut them in the shapes that you need, which will waste material in comparison with making the same shape from a thermoplastic or thermoset material.
Another problem not mentioned is that of the fracture toughness. They have made some tensile strength measurements and there is no doubt that the 2-dimensional polymers will have outstanding tensile strength. However the problem is which will be their fracture toughness for bending. Graphite has a similar structure and it also has excellent tensile strength in the direction parallel with the sheets, but it is also extremely fragile when you bend it.
An advantage of the 1-dimensional polymers is that they, like metals, can be deformed without breaking covalent bonds, which results in high fracture toughness for metals and 1-dimensional polymers, unlike the substances with 2-dimensional networks of covalent bonds (e.g. graphite) or 3-dimensional networks of covalent bonds (e.g. diamond), which are fragile.
So more research is needed to determine how useful these 2-dimensional polymers can really be.
In any case, just achieving their synthesis is already a very impressive result.
- cellis 5y agoYour answer illustrates why, after all these years, HN is still one of the best places to lurk. As someone who forgot most of what he learned in HS chemistry, and didn’t take any collegiate courses, what material would you recommend to learn about this stuff?
- adrian_b 5y agoI am sorry but I cannot give a good recommendation as some years have passed since I have last searched for chemistry books in this domain. If you go to Amazon and you search, e.g., for "Polymer Chemistry" and for "Materials Chemistry", you will find much more than 100 books. However I do not know which are the best among the recent books. A less risky way than ordering such a book, and finding after paying for it that it is a dud, would be to go to an online site like Library Genesis, search there for such books (there are plenty), browse through them and maybe, if you find what you need, choose one or more to buy in printed form. Alternatively, you can read the Amazon reviews for such books, to determine which would be worthy. The Amazon reviews for such specialized items as a science book are usually more trustworthy than for items of general interest.
- toss1 5y agoThx for the Library Genesis pointer - looks like a fantastic resource!
- user_7832 5y agoNot the person you're replying to but William D Callister's Material Science and Engineering is a pretty standard engineering book I've seen used in my different universities across 2 continents (and have studied from too), so I'm going to say that it's a good starting point.
- webmaven 5y agoYou seem to be assuming that the 2D polymers extend indefinitely. If instead their growth is limited such that the molecules tile, overlap, and layer, they may be more amenable to manipulation such as thermoforming, thermosetting, etc.