3 ms·
Does anyone find frivolous company perks to be insulting?
- paul 19y agoDefine "frivolous"
- amichail 19y agoAnything that is not directly related to your work. For example, who cares if you get free soft drinks or not? What really matters is what the work is like.
- SwellJoe 19y agoPerks don't make a soul-stealing job less soul-stealing...but if I have a choice between gourmet food three meals a day (Google) and a coffee maker that no one ever cleans (several companies I've consulted for--at $125/hour) I'm picking the gourmet food every time. It shows a lack of respect for your employees to treat them poorly. It also shows a lack of foresight to not realize that if you don't feed your people, they will go out to lunch most days. Have you ever been out to lunch with people who don't LOVE their job? It's an hour, with drinks, much loudness, etc. and they all come back a bit dazed and don't get anything done for the rest of the day. Anyway, free snacks and drinks (healthy ones please) is the minimum I'd tolerate. I'm cantankerous, of course, and don't play well with others--I've worked for myself starting businesses since I was about 22 and don't have any plans to ever work for anyone else (except in the event of a nice acquisition, but even that isn't high on my list of desires), but I think a lot of nerds feel the same way. We can make good money doing all sorts of things, including working from home in our underpants, why would we put up with a work environment that is any less enjoyable?
- jward 19y agoTaking your definition of frivolous to be anything not directly related to my work, no, I don't find it insulting. Being happy at work makes you more productive. For me this comes first from having a sense of purpose and importance. After that, the little things start to matter. I'd be happier working for a company that had an on site gym, free food/beverages, and weekly draw for some gizmo like an iPod. Some things may strike me as a waste of money on occasion, but never insulting. It's not like they're holding a can of jolt over your head asking you to sit. They're trying to make you happier at work and carve one more notch to differentiate them from another employer.
- amichail 19y agoIt's almost never the case that you would have two companies that would give you similar sense of purpose and importance. There's always one that's better in that regard and that's the one you should pick regardless of perks. And so the perks are irrelevant, and indeed, insulting.
- paul 19y agoNonsense. The "perks" have a lot to do with improving the culture and atmosphere of a place. I've worked at a number of companies with different "perks" (MS, Sun, Intel, and Google), and I can tell you that it is very important. At this point, I would say that any tech company that _doesn't_ offer things like free on-site food is stupidly shortsighted.
- amichail 19y agoYou would need to perform a controlled experiment. It may be that some places were better simply because they had smarter employees or more interesting work irrespective of the perks. Moreover, you would need to define the sort of "culture and atmosphere" that you would like to obtain and consider its impact on individuality.
- paul 19y agoThe smart employees will go to the places that have a better atmosphere, so those places will have both things. It really isn't that complicated. It's like asking whether you'd rather spend your time in a maximum security prison, or a tropical resort (with good internet access).
- amichail 19y agoI can't really relate to this. I'm pursuing my own startup precisely because the sort of work I do is infinitely more important than atmosphere or any other perk.
- jey 19y agoInsulting? No! I agree that the work should be interesting too, but given two companies that have technically interesting work, I'll pick the one with the better culture/attitudes/perks.
- staunch 19y agoI want my office-office to be as similar to my home-office as possible. Not even the perks at Google get anywhere close to being as nice as my own modest home-office. Technology companies mine mental energy from programmers and perks are the water they use to soften the earth. :D
- davidw 19y agoAt the first place I went to work, they had a masseuse come in once a month for 15 minutes with everyone. That was a nice perk. Free sugary glop isn't really that good for you in the long run, but 15 minutes of good massage was absolutely wonderful after being hunched over the computer all day. The only downside was when on a whim I asked the masseuse if she could do hands - she did, and did such a good job that I couldn't bear to go back to typing and went home a little earlier than usual:-)
- gyro_robo 19y agoSo like a monthly $10-$15 value... Hmm.
- davidw 19y agoThinking about it some... What made that such a good perk was that it was something that worked pretty well "collectively". Everyone, from the boss on down, got their 15 minutes, so it was spread out evenly. Fatty/sugary glop is of more (short term) "benefit" to those who consume more of it. In that case I'd rather just keep the money to spend as I want. Also, a massage isn't something I probably would have gone to the trouble of signing up for, at least for 15 minutes, so that made it sort of a pleasant 'extra'. Also, the rates were probably a bit lower, because the woman had a whole day's worth of work.