I did not mean to imply it was an argument either way. I meant it more as a way of demonstrating that we need to be careful to be precise about the actual relat

I did not mean to imply it was an argument either way. I meant it more as a way of demonstrating that we need to be careful to be precise about the actual relative impacts of each option, since they each have non-linear side-effects (including rates of compliance). So we should not get caught making absolute statements that something is always better or that it never works in this case, but instead look at the Pareto optimality frontier for each particular region when making policy recommendations and analysis.