4 ms·
> Singapore is a one-party police state with zero press freedom and a poor track record of respecting human rights (being gay is still illegal). Singapore is a
by rayiner 5y ago
> Singapore is a one-party police state with zero press freedom and a poor track record of respecting human rights (being gay is still illegal).
Singapore is a real, functioning democracy. It’s a city-state not much bigger than Chicago. Is Chicago a “one party” state? When was the last time San Francisco voted for a Republican mayor? Singapore is an Asian country with a significant Muslim population. How they exercise their democratic self determination to structure their society is none of our business.
Frankly, bringing up individual rights in every discussion of Singapore strikes me as a very privileged take. As someone from Bangladesh, I wish Americans and others in the international community would focus more on understanding how Singapore turned itself from a poor third world country into an affluent one in a single generation. How it managed to crack down on the corruption and political instability that plagues fledging democracies. Studying those lessons would pay far greater dividends in terms of improving the human condition in Africa and Asia than imposing western notions of individual rights.
For folks who do care about this issue, reading Lee Kuan Yew’s thoughts is fascinating. https://paulbacon.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/zakaria_lee.pdf https://paulbacon.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/zakaria_lee.pd.... This interview, in particular, is great. The interviewer. CNN’s Fareed Zakaria, is one of the most insightful observers of international politics in America.
- zenithd 5y ago
- ValentineC 5y ago> Singapore is a real, functioning democracy. Singapore is a "democracy" where the system is heavily stacked against opposition parties, and where supposedly apolitical institutions funded with public money like the "grassroots" People's Association [1][2][3] are heavily biased towards the dominant People's Action Party. [1] https://www.todayonline.com/singapore/explainer-perennial-issue-public-funding-upgrading-works-opposition-wards https://www.todayonline.com/singapore/explainer-perennial-is... [2] https://theindependent.sg/wps-sylvia-lim-has-to-use-void-deck-while-paps-chan-hui-yuh-uses-beautiful-serangoon-cc/ https://theindependent.sg/wps-sylvia-lim-has-to-use-void-dec... [3] https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/jamus-lim-reiterates-how-opposition-mps-do-not-get-to-give-out-edusave-awards https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/jamus-lim-reiterates-...
- yes_really 5y agoSo it's like in the US, where tech companies and mainstream media censors conservative views and where the FBI, universities and NGOs funded with public money are heavily biased towards the left?
- jhanschoo 5y agoIndeed; you, the comment you're responding to, and the comment it's responding to are valid points. In my opinion SG and US are both very flawed democracies for different reasons.
- lostlogin 5y ago> bringing up individual rights in every discussion of Singapore strikes me as a very privileged take. As someone from Bangladesh, I wish Americans and others in the international community would focus more on understanding how Singapore turned itself from a poor third world country into an affluent one in a single generation. I sort of agree, but both should occur. Letting transgressions slide because economic progress is made should not occur. Letting the bad happen and excusing it as ‘growing pain’, ‘we are bringing them to the table’ etc has all occurred in the past. The next thing you know, they are big and powerful and don’t want to change. It doesn’t take much reading about Singapore to be fairly alarmed at the state of human rights and government control. They are listening, recording and require you to register for things like public speaking. This is apart from issues like gay rights, workers rights, flogging of criminals and executions. Government opposition parties are under active surveillance and quickly sanctioned should they push too far. I’m surprised anyone argues for it, however those I know from Singapore strongly defend it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Singapore https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Singapore
- rayiner 5y ago> I sort of agree, but both should occur. Letting transgressions slide because economic progress is made should not occur. That assumes that these things are uncorrelated, and I don’t think you can make that assumption without proof. For example, Singapore is a multi-ethnic, multi-religious society with a delicate balance between Chinese (Confucian), Malays (Muslim), and Indians (Hindu). This is a mix that in many countries could devolve into perpetual ethnic conflict. Indeed, Singapore separated from Malaysia due to conflict between the Chinese and the Malay. Part of that grand bargain is that the culture of government is Anglo and Confucian, but the government otherwise avoids intruding on the culture of the other two groups. Homosexuality is simply not accepted in Islam and among Indians. So a push to legalize it would be seen as an attack by westernized English-speaking Chinese upon the two other cultural groups. Lee Kuan Yew was, in fact, extremely westernized (he spoke English as his first language), and opposed the law against homosexuality. But he was not about to upset social stability and unity in the country over that issue: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-singapore-homosexuality-idUSSIN33351020070423 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-singapore-homosexuality-i... In America, we take social stability for granted. Imposing social change without broad public consensus creates social strife and more than a little dysfunction even in America. In a developing country, such conflict could be fatal. The calculus of individual welfare versus collective welfare is simply different in a developing country. Singapore’s infant mortality dropped from 35 per 1,000 to 2.5 per 1,000 from 1960 to 2000. Anything that sets back economic development, no matter how well intentioned the goal, means literally tens of thousands of dead children. That’s the cold hard reality people in wealthy countries don’t have to deal with.