4 ms·
How many drugs, medical devices, etc. were developed in the US and are being sold to all of those OECD countries at a significant discount? If that pricing was
by colechristensen 5y ago
How many drugs, medical devices, etc. were developed in the US and are being sold to all of those OECD countries at a significant discount?
If that pricing was forced on Americans as well, where would the now missing money come from? Is it a bunch of corporate fatcats getting rich or is the richest country in the world subsidizing the healthcare of the rest of the world? (I mean, probably both, but is your intention to nationalize and make nonprofit every aspect of healthcare including drugs and research?)
- actually_a_dog 5y agoWait up. The US develops all these things, and yet, you think they should be given away to the world at a discount, while Americans pay full fare or more? How does that make any sense to you?
- colechristensen 5y agoThe only countries with higher median incomes than the US are Norway, UAE, Luxembourg, and Switzerland. UAE and Norway because oil, Luxembourg and Switzerland because they are tiny and very specialized. The rest of the world can't afford as much, plenty of people will argue for humanitarian reasons that things should be lower cost to those countries which can't pay as much, and in order to sell in those other countries companies simply have to lower prices. A similar thing happens with video games, movies, streaming services, etc. etc. etc. it's called price discrimination. (it is of course not universal, but it is still quite common for companies to lower their prices in markets which can't afford as much)
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI'm sorry, but that still does not make sense to me. The US (meaning really, the American people) is expected both to innovate and subsidize the world? Come on, now. If the US develops it, why shouldn't the US benefit the most? If prices keep going the way they have over the past 40 years, we're not going to be able to afford all these fancy treatments and drugs, anyway. Imagine a corporation developing a product, then marketing it for sale, yet not only not giving its employees a corporate discount, but making them pay more for it. Again, how does that make sense?
- colechristensen 5y agoWelcome to macroeconomics, free trade, globalization, and simple business strategy, topics which can't be adequately conveyed in a forum comment. Almost every product you buy benefits from the lower costs of labor and everything else in foreign economies in one way or another. The flip side is you generally have to lower your own prices to sell in those economies as well. You could try to keep prices constant globally, but in much of the world there would just be 0 sales. The strategy is to make up for a smaller profit margin with larger volume. Buy at a discount from foreign countries, sell at a discount to foreign countries, as a result, pull their economies closer to your own and create new markets for your higher grade products. Everyone on HN is always on about selling your product for what people will pay for it (usually with regards to raising prices) and paying employees market rates. Well it works both ways and you sell your products for what you can get, especially when their is moral pressure all around to not be seen profiting too much from the poorest countries.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoThis is not a sustainable phenomenon, though. Americans can't continue to pay an increasing portion of their income to healthcare while exporting the benefits to everyone else. That's simply absurd. It's all right here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/02/24/this-chart-is-best-explanation-middle-class-finances-you-will-ever-see/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/02/24/this-char... You can't keep squeezing people for more and more and expect to get anywhere in a sustainable fashion. This is the road to collapse. What does macroeconomics say about that?
- colechristensen 5y agoAll economics is cyclical, prices will rise until the pressure causes them to reverse the trend. Pretend any economic trend over a short period will continue forever and they’ll all be unsustainable.
- actually_a_dog 5y ago
- KptMarchewa 5y agoDon't confuse being fleeced with others getting a discount.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAs a point of clarification, The issue is not limited to US based companies and development. Many global healthcare developers also see a disproportionate part of their revenue coming from the US market/sales.