5 ms·
I’m an American person, I don’t want it. Just look towards how the VA or operated and how many problems people have it and tell me you want to force that exper
by colechristensen 5y ago
I’m an American person, I don’t want it.
Just look towards how the VA or operated and how many problems people have it and tell me you want to force that experience on everyone.
People want healthcare to be magically free, that’s not how it’ll be. People who now pay almost no taxes and choose not to buy health insurance because they can’t afford it and their other life choices will suddenly be taxed quite a lot for “free” health insurance.
A problem is a lot of American healthcare companies give away medicine and the results of their development to export at low cost, basically whatever they can get and then make up their profit in American markets. There is also a whole lot of waste and inefficiency and not enough pressure to fix it. Many changes need to be made to lower costs and can be made in many ways, but i simply don’t trust the government to do so by giving them all the money to spend, because they already demonstrate they’re bad at administering medical payments.
Not to mention issues many countries have with their social medicine programs, if you’re not just a fan and look objectively, there is definitely a tradeoff.
- KerrAvon 5y agoIf single payer is funded through a payroll tax, it should be a net savings for those of us who do choose not to live dangerously. There’s a lot of pressure to fix the system, and there has been for decades. It’s blunted by politicians responsive to corporations and not to individuals (other than right-wing extremists, who they fear).
- colechristensen 5y agoThe pressure to fix is blunted by the issue's complexity and a public distaste for complexity. There isn't one issue, there are a million issues, and they have to be well understood to be fixed. "Single payer" is easy to rally behind but it is not a complex solution to a complex problem. There's no guarantee that the result wouldn't be similarly expensive helathcare which was now mandatory with taxes and no longer had economic competition as a pressure to fix.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoThe VA is not single payer; it is single provider. Those are two entirely different things.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYou're in the minority. > Among the public overall, 63% of U.S. adults say the government has the responsibility to provide health care coverage for all, up slightly from 59% last year. Roughly a third (37%) say this is not the responsibility of the federal government, according to a Pew Research Center survey conducted July 27 to Aug. 2 among 11,001 adults. [1] If you read the post from Pew, you'll find that Dems overwhelming support this policy, while it is Republicans who do not, Republicans who are overwhelming older [2]. So, over time, there will be more support for this policy as the roughly 1.8 million voters per year over the age of 55 age out of voting cohorts. [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/09/29/increasing-share-of-americans-favor-a-single-government-program-to-provide-health-care-coverage/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/09/29/increasing-... [2] https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2020/06/02/the-changing-composition-of-the-electorate-and-partisan-coalitions/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2020/06/02/the-changing...
- captainredbeard 5y ago> You're in the minority Does that make their opinion irrelevant?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoNo, the data showing Americans spend more on healthcare than every other OECD country with worse outcomes does that. https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2020/05/feature-forum-costliest-health-care https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2020/05/feature-forum-costli... https://www.kff.org/health-costs/issue-brief/americans-challenges-with-health-care-costs/ https://www.kff.org/health-costs/issue-brief/americans-chall... https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/why-is-healthcare-so-expensive https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/why-is-healthcare-so-... Not even the wealthy get better healthcare with their dollars. https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/highlights-from-the-comments-on-health https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/highlights-from-the-co... > GummyBearDoc writes: > I want to push back on the assertion Scott made that "Certainly rich people in America get good health care." After he published this book in June 2020, Ezekiel Emmanuel published an article in JAMA IM (link: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2774561 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullar...) called "Comparing Health Outcomes of Privileged US Citizens With Those of Average Residents of Other Developed Countries." He wanted to test the commonly stated trope that a feature of the US healthcare system is that the rich here get the very best care in the world. To do that, he looked at outcomes across six benchmark diseases (heart attack, colon cancer, breast cancer, infant mortality, maternal mortality, and pediatric acute lymphocytic leukemia). He compared outcomes for white people in the 1% of richest counties in the US, 5% richest counties in the US, and average outcomes in 12 rich countries (i'm not going to type them all out but they're places like Australia, Canada, and Germany). The results were...not so great for rich Americans! > While rich people in the US do better than average people in other rich countries with breast cancer, RICH children in the US have outcomes worse than AVERAGE citizens in 11/12 of this group of rich countries. Rich people in America have about the same outcomes after heart attack that average people in other rich countries have. In other words, in most cases, you're about as well off having a heart attack being the average bozo in France (for example) as you are having one in one of the wealthiest counties in the US. I was pretty shocked when I read this paper. > The reason I think this is important is because I think it's extremely politically useful sometimes to be able to claim that rich people in the US get great healthcare! People like to imagine themselves as more privileged than they are, and think that, if and when they get sick, they'll have access to this incredible care. So we should reframe from "average care in the US is shitty but care for the upper echelons is the envy of the world" to "average care in the US is shitty, and also in the upper echelons we are about the same as the average person in America's peer countries." Emphasis on the last paragraph.
- mindslight 5y agoThat's four straw men in a row. Medicare is not the VA. People who pay no taxes won't suddenly be taxed "quite a lot". Medicine isn't being "given away", but rather paid for at rates set by collective bargaining. The government seems quite alright at handling Medicare payments. I'm a proponent of markets - single payer ultimately feels like giving in to the ever-growing cancer of medical administration. I'd prefer to reform the industry to have functioning market dynamics regardless of who pays. But you're grossly mischaracterizing M4A. If rallying around giving everyone access to Medicare is what it takes to stop a lot of needless administrative suffering and end a significant drag on the labor market, I'm all for it.
- colechristensen 5y agoI don't think you know what a straw man is. The US spent $4 trillion last year on medicine, $670 billion was Medicare spending. I don't know where you think the remaining $3+ trillion dollars are going to come from except through doubling tax revenue. (The US took in $4 trillion last year) You can't just tax high income people double, I already pay 26% in federal taxes with another 8% in state taxes... I don't think raising my income taxes from 34% to 60% is going to go over very well with everybody else (even remotely) similarly effected... money is going to have to come from people who are paying very little in taxes now too.
- mindslight 5y agoA straw man is a statement that is trivially disprovable. Just because you stood them up without knocking them down does not stop them from being straw men. That money comes from premiums for Medicare and money saved from private "insurance". The correct comparison is not simply your current tax rate, but rather your tax rate plus the amount you're currently paying for "insurance". Medicare is not some free thing for the elderly, but rather is paid into by monthly social security payments. Adjust the premium amount to remove any retirement subsidy, and allow non-retired people to buy into the existing system. This would add a well-established competitor to a market currently dominated by the health "insurance" cartel. The "free" healthcare is Medicaid which is available to everyone, but only after they're rendered unemployable and bankrupted due to medical problems. Doesn't it make more sense to allow people to buy into a healthcare plan and keep working rather than making them stay destitute so they can quality for medical care?
- pessimizer 5y agoIf the government isn't going to do it, no one is going to do it, so you're complaining about a system (with good reason) that you're determined to preserve.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> People who now pay almost no taxes and choose not to buy health insurance because they can’t afford it I guess that's one way to phrase "are completely priced out of something guaranteed as a human right in pretty much every civilized country". A good friend of mine is in this situation, and I have a very low tolerance for the attitude of the "fuck poor people because I don't like taxes" crowd.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt's market forces at work. When most people in a certain situation neglect a cost so they can afford everything else in their lives, everything else has a tendency to raise prices to eat up all of their income anyway. It comes down to most people paying a lot of money for rent and not being able to afford other things like healthcare. Well rent is that high because enough people neglected to pay for healthcare that the competition for space made rent go up. I live in a place where low income people have a whole lot of access though the state to get low or zero cost health insurance which is very good. My taxes pay for that and I have no problem with it. A lot of the states that don't have such nice programs are largely run by parties strongly favored by the low income population so I'm not really sure this is my fault now. People don't want these solutions, especially the political parties of the people who would benefit the most from single payer. If tried it will lose elections. The things which could win elections are pragmatic measures to address the biggest cost excesses in medicine individually, but people are pretty dumb and tend not to rally for a large number of incremental improvements instead pretending that one big solution will definitely solve their problems and not just add new, different, and perhaps bigger ones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]