3 ms·
I never understood why a free-fall from space with a parachute would not work. (I bring this up because I would propose bringing down sections of ISS with extre
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
I never understood why a free-fall from space with a parachute would not work. (I bring this up because I would propose bringing down sections of ISS with extremely large parachutes.)
I get there is no air in space, and how thin it is as you approach the Earth's surface. But it is a gradient after all.
If a falling body begins to heat up, that suggests it has entered a region with some atmosphere — and so some parachute utility.
In my mind the effectiveness of the parachute would track the rise in atmospheric density — just as the rise in atmospheric density became a heat issue. In other words, the parachute would slowly become effective, enough so to keep the falling body from ever attaining a speed that generates too much heat (with regard to the density of the atmosphere it is traversing).
How is the model in my head wrong? Does the parachute effectiveness lag with regard to the rise of the "heat gradient"?
- emiliobumachar 5y agoMy guess is that your idea is right, but the gradient is just not smooth enough.
- richardwhiuk 5y agoSize of parachute for the ISS is prohibitively large. Heating is all concentrated on a single profile.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> I never understood why a free-fall from space with a parachute would not work. It depends what you mean by "from space". The ISS is in space and also _in orbit_, so is moving laterally at about 17,500 mph / 28,000 km/h / 7777 m/s / Mach 22 (1) It's not just about falling, it's about the heat and stress of hitting the air when moving sideways at nearly 8 kilometres per second. The "sub-orbital hop" scenario that Bezos and Branson do involves technically "falling from space" but is very different as they're not moving sideways. 1) https://www.space.com/16748-international-space-station.html https://www.space.com/16748-international-space-station.html
- theandrewbailey 5y ago> How is the model in my head wrong? Does the parachute effectiveness lag with regard to the rise of the "heat gradient"? Consider that landing on Mars is difficult: it has enough of an atmosphere to be a problem (lots of heat on re-entry), but too thin to be useful (limited drag). With that in mind, my guess is that the ISS would heat up faster than the parachute would slow it down.
- rtkwe 5y agoBasically yes things start falling out of the sky faster than you can slow them down to avoid burning up causing them to fall deeper into the atmosphere where the parachute just gets ripped apart or your spacecraft just melts from the friction of slamming through the atmosphere at Mach 20+. Orbiting objects are just going way faster than you can slow down with just a parachute you have to have something in front to protect the craft, so far they're all heat shields of some sort either ablative or extremely insulative so the flimsy spacecraft doesn't become a giant piece of slag. One of the big problems with landing on Mars is related to this. The atmosphere is thick enough to cause heat problems but thin enough that slowing down enough to deploy a parachute is hard so we're limited in the amount of mass we can send until we figure out inflatable heat shields to increase the cross sectional area so we can slow down enough for parachutes to work. Otherwise you have to use a Starship style powered landing all the way down. With that you have to carry all that fuel to Mars which again cuts down on the mass you can actually land.
- yummypaint 5y agoI think part of the problem is that there is a regime where the atmosphere is too sparse to really act like a fluid or carry away heat. The kinetic energy of the falling object ultimately has to get converted to heat, but the balance between the power delivered to the spacecraft and the power dissipated back to the environment changes significantly with altitude. I think that period of only being able to really dissipate heat by radiation is what motivates the use of insulating tiles. That way the hottest surfaces can be allowed to reach high temperatures without harming the sensitive parts, and the power emitted scales as the temperature to the 4th power, so letting a small part get very hot provides better cooling than spreading that energy evenly out over the whole spacecraft.
- spyspy 5y agoYou’d need a parachute designed for very high velocity[1] which does exist but this is still likely unreasonable. Heat goes up much faster than drag relative to speed. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballute
- dgrin91 5y agoThe idea has some theoretical merit to it, but the math doesn't add up at all when you run the numbers. The size and strength of the parachutes you would need would be massive. Much bigger than anything today. Don't forget you also need to bring up the parachutes and somehow attach them to the iss in a way where the stress of the deceleration won't snap the iss in half (hint: not possible). I think this is better demonstrated as a smaller scale thought experiment. Consider the various space capsules over time, from Mercury & Apollo all the way through to dragon. They all use parachutes, but not until late in the landing process. That's because they all use the upper atmosphere as a method of slowing down, and they can't use a parachute up there because, again, the numbers don't work.
- gameswithgo 5y agoThe problem is you are moving on the order of 20,000 mph laterally, you are not just falling straight down. You could make this work with something sufficiently large and light though. Like if the ISS were made of only carbon fiber and emptied of everything, maybe.