3 ms·
> I wonder if the people using that language naturally and spontaneously evolved it This doesn't make sense. You can't spontaneously evolve your own language;
by pessimizer 5y ago
> I wonder if the people using that language naturally and spontaneously evolved it
This doesn't make sense. You can't spontaneously evolve your own language; it's not a language until you've explained it to someone, and to do that, you'll have to use another language (whether verbal or physical.) "Tribe" is a shorthand that points at a few common meanings and a few less common ones, in at least English, and probably a few other languages. If you're confused about the meaning of the speaker, you ask specific questions in order to clarify it. If the speaker starts to get squirrelly about the meaning of the words they're using, suspect that they're repeating something they heard somewhere. When the same words in the same context shift meaning, that's called equivocation.
I, myself, proudly declare alliances to particular "tribes." Talking about tribal thinking doesn't imply that you think you're above it. Implying in sarcastic passive voice that people who talk about "tribes" are actually members of tribes is a self-own that I don't understand the point of.
It's only because we're both members of the English-speaking community that we have any means of communicating over the web.
- tomlockwood 5y ago> Implying in sarcastic passive voice that people who talk about "tribes" are actually members of tribes is a self-own that I don't understand the point of. Have you actually been on the internet recently? Holy hell. Its rife with people who think they're rising above everyone who isn't a free thinker! And the articles about rising above these petty allegiances are wildly upvoted!!! You're really demonstrating a lack of awareness about the culture of this website and many others. I can't believe you read the comment I was responding to and thought "hey, this person doesn't think they're rising above 'tribal' thinking". And yeah, I'm not sure about whether they precisely think they're in that position or not, so I used passive voice. I will become sued by you. Passive voice can be good, actually.