35 ms·
But what happens if the Chinese recover pieces of it from the ocean and figure out how to waste trillions of dollars to no good effect too? /sarcasm Wouldn't w
by jqpabc123 5y ago
But what happens if the Chinese recover pieces of it from the ocean and figure out how to waste trillions of dollars to no good effect too?
/sarcasm
Wouldn't we have been much better served using all that money to figure out how to manufacture more/better microchips? The StarTrek fantasy will still be there in a century or two.
- jeffwass 5y agoIgnoring your sarcasm and focusing on your second point : One big example is SpaceX. I don’t think they’d be as successful as they are right now if they didn’t have some of that initial funding from NASA to help them bootstrap to where they are today. This is one stellar example of how federal research funding dollars can generate positive societal benefits through the transfer to private industry. Of course there are some companies that just siphon federal dollars without much to show in return, but for SpaceX they have really returned multiples on those initial “investments”.
- ydlr 5y agoI think you just found a mission statement for NASA that congress can get behind: Welfare for Billionaires.
- jqpabc123 5y agoSo we need the ISS so we can use taxpayer money to fund billionaires to develop rockets to launch to the ISS? See here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_reasoning https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_reasoning Where would we be without SpaceX? Pretty much where we are now --- struggling to find enough chips to build cars and Raspberry PIs.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoIt would be nice if we could do both.
- jqpabc123 5y agoYes. But unfortunately, the one being addressed won't have any real impact for generations while more immediate needs are being ignored. NASA has spent trillions studying the effects of weightlessness on people. In comparison, they have spent virtually nothing on protecting the plant from an asteroid strike or mitigating the effects of global warming --- both of which are way more pressing concerns. Studying people in space is about as practical as addressing global warming by funding research on Dyson spheres.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoGlobal warming, I agree, should be everyone's highest priority. Asteroid strike ... hasn't it been a while since the Earth has seen one on a scale that would rival global warming? Worrying about an asteroid strike seems like something that has stirred the public imagination but has a crazy low likelihood.
- jqpabc123 5y agoIt's been a while --- but most scientists consider a significant asteroid strike to be a near certainty --- they just can't say when. Based on *known* asteroids, the probability by 2300 has been calculated at about 1 in 2000. But don't relax just yet, we find previously unknown asteroids all the time. Just last year, one (2021 UA1) flew by Antarctica undetected until after it has passed at a distance of about 1400 miles. But even if we detect one, there is no real working plan in place to try and deflect it. Thanks NASA --- this is why we give you the big bucks! Physicist Stephen Hawking, in his final book, Brief Answers to the Big Questions, considered an asteroid collision to be the single biggest threat to the planet.
- bgun 5y agoWhile HN complains that we want cars without chips to begin with.
- jqpabc123 5y agoHN is just a web site where people can post opinions. "HN" doesn't complain --- you can't reasonably attribute one post to "HN".
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoThat was 2 days ago? Please make a dumb car (techcrunch.com) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30144101 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30144101
- yread 5y agoChips? We need more crisps
- emiliobumachar 5y agoThe ISS is a microgravity lab, and allows experiments in i.e. growing crystals. That's far out of my area of expertise, but it wouldn't surprise me if it eventually yielded some application in microchips.
- rtkwe 5y agoThere's research that can only be done in space because the microgravity allows smaller forces to be isolated and studied in ways they can't be on Earth. For one example they can grow protein crystals better up there which allow studying their structure and finding medical interventions to treat the diseases associated with them. https://www.issnationallab.org/iss360/probing-proteins-leveraging-microgravity-for-medically-important-molecular-crystallization/ https://www.issnationallab.org/iss360/probing-proteins-lever...
- jqpabc123 5y agoSo there is a "protein crystal disease"? How many people suffer from this?
- rtkwe 5y agoYes lots of diseases manifest as malformed proteins, to understand them you need to know the structure of the protein which is commonly done using x-ray crystallography which requires growing a crystal made of the thing you're studying. It's the way we learned the shape of DNA and a fundamental process for studying a lot of biological systems. Growing those crystals is tough on Earth because of gravity so they grew some on ISS they'd never managed to grow on Earth.
- jqpabc123 5y ago...they grew some on ISS they'd never managed to grow on Earth. It's nice they were able to grow some crystals that never occur on earth because of --- gravity. But is this valuable in any way back on earth? Highly doubtful. Probably about as productive as funding for an anti-gravity device on earth --- which the military is doing by the way.
- rtkwe 5y agoI've said it 2 times now basically but I'll spell it out I guess. With the crystals they can determine the structure of errant proteins and develop treatments to target them to help people with the diseases these proteins create. Without the structure of the protein this is on the scale of extremely difficult to impossible.