4 ms·
Telemetry has massive direct user benefit. It gives every user a vote on how important each feature is rather than letting power users who manually submit feedb
by Gigachad 5y ago
Telemetry has massive direct user benefit. It gives every user a vote on how important each feature is rather than letting power users who manually submit feedback control the show.
- account42 5y agoEven ignoring that decisions based on Telemetry are very much influenced by the person making the decision, importance has nothing to do with how much a feature is used.
- gilrain 5y agoIncorrect. It gives the designers and developers an opaque dataset of user behavior which they can interpret in many ways. I find their interpretations of this data to be highly motivated and suspect.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoHow does gradually removing power user features over time empower regular users over time? Hint: It doesn't. And then when the regular users are all piling up on support because they can't learn how to configure the product (or indeed ask their power user friends for help, since the features no longer exist), what happens then? Nothing. Nothing happens then. And the shitshow continues.
- barrkel 5y agoThat is not what telemetry does. Useful features that are hidden aren't distinguished from useless features people don't use. Features that are used rarely but are super important aren't distinguished from features that don't work well. Feature usage is a poor proxy for usefulness, importance, usability, visibility; it confounds them all.
- cxr 5y ago> Telemetry has massive direct user benefit. No. The benefit you're describing is not a direct benefit. It's an exemplary instance of indirect benefit even under the most generous evaluation criteria/process.
- kbelder 5y agoHas it in truth done that? I know of changes for the worse that Mozilla has made, using telemetry as a justification. I don't know if I've heard of any changes for the better that have been prompted by telemetry data. It could be... maybe there are bug fixes or UI refinements. I just haven't heard of any.
- jamienicol 5y agoSome examples of things I've used telemetry for at Mozilla: * Noticed performance regressions not caught by our testing, and therefore been able to fix the regression. * Noticed an unexpected number of users with hardware acceleration disabled, and therefore been able to find and fix the bug that was causing them to have acceleration switched off * Figure out which device in a category is most commonly used by our users, so that I can dogfood my work on a representative device Those are just a few examples off of the top of my head. It's not about removing features because telemetry says nobody uses them. People Mozilla use telemetry to answer all sorts of important questions. We also have to jump through hoops to add any new data collection, justifying why it's needed and ensuring the data is not personal. As is right, because we take user privacy very seriously