3 ms·
Thanks for sharing this context. It is ironic that the topic of Stuart's post was a call to stop canceling potential allies and pushing them to the alt right.
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
Thanks for sharing this context. It is ironic that the topic of Stuart's post was a call to stop canceling potential allies and pushing them to the alt right.
>he states as facts some things in that quoted post which are completely contrary to the reality of the treatment of trans minors
Coming at this with fresh eyes, He doesn't state anything as facts. He just summed up what JKRs position was and said this person is a potential trans ally.
As a result, he lost his political position and was canceled for begging people to think twice about canceling someone else.
- pjc50 5y ago> He just summed up what JKRs position was .. which was based on a set of wrong (and inflammatory!) claims about how trans healthcare works. > and said this person is a potential trans ally. Only in the sense that any alive person is a potential trans ally; you are not an ally simply because you claim to be, you have to actually do the work, and in JKR's case that means she would have to do a lot of work simply to undo the damage and hurt that she herself has caused to trans people. You can't say "I would be an ally to those people if only they'd stop cancelling me!", that indicates a fundamental failure to understand what an ally is.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt seems like he said, JRK is opposed to these 3 things. If the trans community is also opposed to those 3 things, why wouldn't or couldn't they be an ally? There should be violent agreement! Further, if the community wants 100 things, and someone supports 97, and disagrees on 3, must they be an enemy? The point does indeed revolve around different definitions of what an ally is. Is it someone willing to work with you to get what you want, or get some of what you want, or is it someone who holds identical views? The topic has strong parallels to the title post. Can the green party march alongside radical communists to protest climate change?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]