6 ms·
This issue periodically makes the rounds in expatriate communities, and I think panicked blog posts outnumber actual enforcement actions by about 10,000 to 1.
by patio11 15y ago
This issue periodically makes the rounds in expatriate communities, and I think panicked blog posts outnumber actual enforcement actions by about 10,000 to 1. Anecdotally, most Americans living abroad are probably non-compliant on this one. They're not going to suddenly decide to break the kneecaps of a couple million people, for the same reason that they don't audit every $50k per year small business' office expenses every single year. They'd end up hated and not meaningfully boost revenue.
All bets are off if you have signatory authority on a $30 million dollar account in the Caymans and have forgotten to report interest for the last 10 years running.
P.S. Orthogonal to the disclosure of accounts issue but worth mentioning since folks often commingle them: If you're an American living abroad, you should file your taxes every year whether you think you need to or not. Same for Americans in the US, by the way. The statute of limitations on unfiled taxes is essentially infinite, but the window to audit a return is only six years, so if you just file a 1040 with a zero on it every year and 20 years from now the IRS decides to get frisky, you're covered for all but the last 6 years automatically.
- david927 15y agoYou're right, it used to be only the big accounts -- before 2008. Post-2008, that's not the case anymore. They have become very, very active since then on all earning levels.
- Hyena 15y agoEvidence?
- ams6110 15y agoIt applies to accounts of $10,000 or more (I don't know if you consider that "big"). But note that's "in aggregate" not a per-account amount. From the IRS FAQ: Q. Who must file an FBAR? A. Any United States person who has a financial interest in or signature authority or other authority over any financial account in a foreign country, if the aggregate value of these accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time during the calendar year.
- jarek 15y agoI'm not sure how you could consider $10k big, especially in aggregate. That's probably less than six months' savings for a family.
- burgerbrain 15y agoHell, I had more than twice that when I was a broke-ass sophomore in college. This seems to apply to all but the homeless.
- Duff 15y agoNo way. Most people live paycheck to paycheck. 50% of Americans are unable to raise $2,000 within 30 days.
- burgerbrain 15y agoHuh. I guess I'm getting out of touch.
- jarek 15y agoYes, and that is disturbing. But I still wouldn't say savings for six months of ordinary middle-class life is a big amount.
- Duff 15y agoI tend to agree, but then I'm a well-paid IT guy. 90% of the population probably doesn't have $10k of assets. So while $10k isn't alot of money, it is out of the ordinary, especially if you are able to store it out of the country.
- antihero 15y agoHow the fucking hell did you have that?
- 15y ago
- ajross 15y agoAre there statistics to back that up? The date you list makes me very suspicious that you got this statement from a politically motivated news source. The real truth is that the IRS is a huge bureaucracy with a more or less static funding source, and there's very little the executive branch can do to rapidly change its methods or priorities.
- davidw 15y agoOne of the things I miss about the US, here in Italy, is that people care a bit more about the rules, and obeying them, or changing them. Yeah, you probably won't get caught, but that's ultimately not the point. The point is that it's a bad rule.
- ArbitraryLimits 15y agoI had a friend who lived in Florence for several years before email. Once he was expected a letter from home and it didn't come and didn't come, so he decided to shadow his mailman to see what was going on. Turns out the mailman did as much of his route as he felt like, and then emptied the rest of the mailbag into the Arno at quittin' time.
- rmc 15y agoHehe. Tis similar in Ireland. My partner moved over from England and took a while for him to adapt to things not fulling linking up and the state not always enforcing rules (e.g. avoding paying car tax is much easier in Ireland than UK, etc.).
- nl 15y agohere in Italy is that people care a bit more about the rules, and obeying them, or changing them Wait.. what? Not American nor Italian here, but I've been to Italy and judging from the driving there isn't a great amount of care shown for the road rules anyway. Also, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silvio_Berlusconi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silvio_Berlusconi
- davidw 15y agoI omitted a comma, and I think you didn't parse my phrase correctly. People are generally more rule-abiding in the US than in Italy, with plenty of positive and negative exceptions in both places. Once you start picking and choosing which rules are sensible, and which ones you can 'get away with', I think it's detrimental to society.
- nl 15y ago
- omonra 15y agoAgreed - given how US government is cracking down on expats, it simply makes sense to file your taxes every year, especially when most expats end up owing nothing. Here are more reasons to do it: http://www.taxesforexpats.com/expat-tax-advice/why-file.html http://www.taxesforexpats.com/expat-tax-advice/why-file.html
- jtbigwoo 15y agoThe statute of limitations on unfiled taxes is essentially infinite, but the window to audit a return is only six years, so if you just file a 1040 with a zero on it every year and 20 years from now the IRS decides to get frisky, you're covered for all but the last 6 years automatically. This is not technically correct. There are three time limits that apply: In a normal circumstances, they have 3 years to conduct an audit. If they suspect you've under-reported your income by 25% or more they have 6 years. If they suspect fraud, they have unlimited time to conduct an audit. (Fraud requires intent to deceive, so it's a higher bar than just making a mistake or not understanding a rule.)
- patio11 15y agoThanks for the correction.
- thaumaturgy 15y agoThis op-ed, written for a major Canadian publication, relates the story of 2 people, and also mentions that the Finance Minister has been moved to start writing to U.S. newspapers over the issue. So, I am extremely skeptical of your 10,000-to-1 estimate on the matter. It would make sense for the IRS right now to follow the RIAA's playbook -- send out a lot of letters and see who bites. It would also be irresponsible in every way to realize that you're part of such a list and yet still ignore it because you don't expect the IRS to actually ever do anything about it. I've got extended family that uses that approach to life, and it bites them in the ass all the time. -- On a personal level, I've noticed that you seem to be the antithesis of an alarmist, whatever that is. When another round of "PayPal screwed me!" posts and articles comes around, you seem to show up with at least one or two comments along the lines of, "Hey, I use PayPal, it's never been a problem for me, it shouldn't be a problem for you either"; shortly after the Fukushima incident, you leveraged your intimate knowledge of Japanese culture to powerfully downplay the seriousness of the matter, except that it turned out that you were wrong, and the facilities did have problems before the incident, and it did turn into a serious disaster. I didn't notice any comments from you once that news started coming 'round. So, all this is just to say that I think you have a different approach in your thinking than a lot of people in matters like this. Whereas a lot of people try to anticipate problems and minimize their future impact, you seem comfortable with waiting to see if they actually become problems and then dealing with them at that point. And, there's nothing necessarily wrong with that, but it does mean that your opinion on things like IRS penalties may not be to everyone's benefit.
- fleitz 15y agoFor all intents and purposes it's the same in Canada. If you have any significant ties to Canada you pay Canadian income tax if you're a citizen. A significant tie could be as simple as owning a motorcycle, a corporation, or still having a Canadian bank account.
- potatolicious 15y agoNot true - I'm a Canadian expat working in the US and I've had to deal with this myself. It really comes down to this: - Canadian residents always pay tax to Canada on all income, no matter where it is made. - Canadian non-residents do not pay tax on international income. - Residency is determined by: A) How much time you have spent outside of the country. If you have spent the majority of the year (6 months + 1 day) outside the country, you can claim non-residency. If you have spent the majority of the year in Canada, fat chance. B) "Significant ties" to Canada. This seems draconian, but is actually not really. You can have a driver's license, space in a storage unit, or bank accounts and still easily make the claim of non-residency. Hell, I have a friend who owns a rental property in Toronto and still makes it. - In any case, the whole process is much easier and less burdensome than the American equivalent. The first year you believe you qualify as a non-resident, you file a form with the CRA (Canadian equivalent of IRS) with your blank tax return (stating all income is international). Once you do that, you no longer have to do it ever again. I do not have to get my non-residency status constantly recertified. It's all pretty simple. At the end of the day, if you live in Canada you pay tax on money you make - anywhere - and if you live outside of it you're basically just off the hook.