4 ms·
It's bad to keep countering complaints about 2008 as if the balance sheet is all that matters. The ethical complaints aren't about the money, but about the ince
by naasking 5y ago
It's bad to keep countering complaints about 2008 as if the balance sheet is all that matters. The ethical complaints aren't about the money, but about the incentives and disincentives for certain behaviour, and the constant preferential treatment for a certain class of people above others. The cited reason for buying the bank debt instead of the home owner debt was "moral hazard", which actually applies to them both, but you don't need to guess which group was exempt from that consideration.
- abakker 5y agoThe worry was about creating moral hazard — the idea being that we would set a precedent that would drive the banks to be even more risk tolerant. Ultimately, everyone decided that the risk of bank collapse and bank runs were worse risks that the possibility that moral hazard would be the outcome.
- naasking 5y agoAlmost exactly the same argument applies to mortgage relief for the home owners, that's my point.
- Aunche 5y ago>The cited reason for buying the bank debt instead of the home owner debt was "moral hazard" The moral hazard was the smallest of the problems. The complexity of how to do so seems like the much bigger issue. What does "buying homeowner debt" even mean when much of that debt has been securitized?
- kbenson 5y agoPaying mortgages, or a percentage thereof, for people? If it's considered an interest free loan on which the people would pay back in their taxes or on any sale of the home initiated by the owner or as inheritance fees, possibly with a maximum delay before payments must be attempted, then that seems fairly straightforward to me.
- Aunche 5y agoHow would the government have capacity to do this? It's much easier to just purchase bundles of mortgage backed securities. From the moral hazard standpoint, I think they were worried more about the lenders rather than the lendees. Under this arrangement, even the shadiest of private lenders get rewarded. Under TARP, at least it was just banks that got bailed out, and they could buy the MBSs at a discount.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> How would the government have capacity to do this? To pay mortgages? Set standards for when it would do it, and then open up public applications.
- kbenson 5y ago> How would the government have capacity to do this? It's much easier to just ... I don't find the argument that "it's hard to track and manage that" valid or compelling for an organization which includes the IRS as one of its constituent parts. Actually paying portions of mortgages would both keeps the banks solvent as well as keep the people capable of pulling through with assistance from taking the burden of the problem because of what might be temporary issues (a recession and lack of work). It's a much more market based solution than "throw money at banks", in that it doesn't subvert the market entirely, just supplements it. They would still need to allow people that had no hope of paying their mortgage to lose their homes, and something different might be needed for that to keep that subset of the problem space (which might be a large subset, a lot of lenders were fudging number to get people into homes they couldn't afford) from still causing things to spiral out of control, but there was no guarantee that the first part of TARP was going to be enough either, so it's not like "the situation needs to be closely monitored for future needed intervention" wasn't an assumed part of any proposed plan.
- Aunche 5y ago>I don't find the argument that "it's hard to track and manage that" valid or compelling for an organization which includes the IRS as one of its constituent parts Doesn't this article highlight what happens if you haphazardly throw together a complicated relief effort overnight? The money ends up in the pockets of the rich anyways. >Actually paying portions of mortgages would both keeps the banks solvent Exactly, which is part of the problem I'm highlighting. Under this arrangement, the lenders and mortgage backed securities holders don't get punished at all. If the homeowners get to keep the their home, that means the lender gets everything that they asked for. If the homeowner receives government assistance and loses their home anyways, the lender still ends up with government money. Lenders are literally getting rewarded for their reckless lending. Presumably with TARP, the Treasury negotiated the purchase prices with the banks to make sure that they were punished, but not so much they'd collapse.
- naasking 5y agoI'll describe it by the ultimate objective: most people keep their homes, and the lenders who encouraged and inflated this bad debt lose money on it instead.
- abakker 5y agoMost people kept their homes. People who were far underwater were underwater because the value of their homes fell.