4 ms·
> backed by fiat centralized stablecoins will be used by governments and banks to further their control over people. Democratic government is the people; it is
by wolverine876 5y ago
> backed by fiat centralized stablecoins will be used by governments and banks to further their control over people.
Democratic government is the people; it is the people having power over things. Other sources of power, like big business and wealthy people, like to spread ideas deriding government (e.g., the Koch Brothers), so that the power shifts to them.
Who has power over your favorite cryptocurrency? If government gives up regulatory power, who gets that power?
Reasonably, the American people want control over the currency and money supply in their own country.
- rmbyrro 5y agoWe don't live in true democracies. Too many gullible people. Few politicians to vote for, the ones backed with hundreds of millions from rich people, who are the ones in charge at the end.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoThere's plenty of truth to your criticisms, but it seems to me that potentially they lead to nihilism (in the US that would produce arguments like "I don't vote, there's no difference between the two parties"). I prefer to think we can still influence the direction that policymaking takes, even if it's an uphill battle. Unless by "true democracies" you meant "direct democracies" since that's absolutely true, almost no one does.
- Nevermark 5y agoI don't think whether something leads to "nihilism" or what any of us "prefer" to think has any bearing. Even as a representative democracy, the distribution of power is by Supreme Court decision not one-citizen, one-vote, one unit of power over the government. The US Supreme Court ruled in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission essentially that money was free speech and so its effects on elections could not be limited. So the wealthy, or any wealthy interests internationally that have national entities that can spend money, have a hugely disproportionate hold on elections due to their ability to frame the information and motives behind elections, often with large amounts of coordinated misinformation. So both financially, and informationally, the US democracy is not only legally corrupt, but any corporation that needs to negotiate with the government at any level, is virtually forced into participating in that legal corruption or be at a severe disadvantage. The non-wealthy also suffer from that severe disadvantage, but have no wealth to balance it. So in the zero sum game of power politics, they have lost considerable power relative to any formal democracy, representative or not. The legal corruption is both self-perpetuating and a malignant motivator for new scales and means of further corruption. The people in government, and people with money, are both being selected and incentivized, with stick and carrot, to be, and to further enable via their levers on government, even worse systemic corruption. The US is not a healthy representative democracy and it isn't unreasonable to wonder if it is on a runaway path to worse outcomes without a clear mechanism for a turnaround in sight.
- rmbyrro 5y agoPrecisely. Adding to all you said: All assignments to the Supreme Court and its Circuits follow a Technocracy system, not a Democracy. Citizens in their daily affairs are subject much more to a Bureaucracy system than to the results of a Democratic system of government. The "intelligence community", for example, part of this Bureaucratic system of government, has extremely strong power. This is true for the US and most - if not all - other self-claimed "democracies" nowadays. I think Democracy accounts for <50% of what governments can influence in our lives. I'd personally say it's less than 10%, but being conservative. Anyway, it's certainly not the majority of it, so I wouldn't say we live in a Democracy. It's a mix of Technocracy/Bureaucracy, with a thin veil of Democracy.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoYes, the Citizens United decision was a clear move towards plutocracy. And while congress could pass a law to correct it, it's unclear if they have any inclination to do so, and if the court would let it stand if they did. I agree the health of the US system is poor, but hope that we can still revive it.
- wolverine876 5y agoCongress won't do it unless people push them to. If these people quit, they won't. Again, who gains from that? Who are the quitters serving, knowingly or not?
- rmbyrro 5y agoI understand your concern and respect your will to stand for Democracy. I was in that place until recently. But I've changed. I see current self-claimed "democracies" as a mix of Oligarchy, Technocracy and Bureaucracy, with Democracy influencing a tiny fraction of actual results of government action in citizens' lives. And I don't see a path to a truly democratic system without a major cultural change and, most importantly, change in the individual level.
- wolverine876 5y agoThose seem like empty, general claims. Do you have anything specific to claim that can be proven or disproven? It's what the people who want to shift the power from democracy like to say (including the empty, general nature). We don't live in perfect democracies, of course, but we will never live in perfect anything - these are human institutions, and it's humans all the way down. But lots of powerful people and institutions invest enormous amounts of resources in persuading the public - the entire world of news opinion (including, first among peers, most of Murdoch's news operations), massive disinformation operations, all the corporate PR spin, etc. etc. etc. Those are enormous investments for something that doesn't matter. No person I've ever admired, current or historical, ever advised despair and quitting. It's a sure way to lose, and hand over your power to someone else. Who are you handing it to?
- nathias 5y agoThere are no democratic governments, we have republics which are just a bit better oligarchies. We can make free and open systems that are more democratic based on participation, voluntarism and actual people voting. Which is what is happening in crypto. Of course in every system there is a possibility of corruption, but for crypto that's obvious and people are actually working on sloving this as a problem while in the real world that's a feature. > Reasonably, the American people want control over the currency and money supply in their own country. Sure and they can keep it, I just don't know why they need to control everyone else too. I'm on the other side of the planet and the only relevant politics is the US, whether or not I get to own a home in my lifetime depends on one guy deciding how strong he wants the dollar to be ... I don't find this system particullary reasonable.
- wolverine876 5y agoSomeone wants you to not use your power. Who benefits from that? Who will gain power? > There are no democratic governments, we have republics which are just a bit better oligarchies. That's what people who want a true republic or oligarchy will tell you - quit, give up, it's hopeless. We not only have democracy, they work well - but they are made of people. If you vote out the bad people, they leave. If we the people do a bad job, we'll have bad results. If you do a bad job, that's what you'll get. If you don't even show up, we will fail. It's straightforward. I'm counting on you. > Of course in every system there is a possibility of corruption, but for crypto that's obvious and people are actually working on sloving this as a problem while in the real world that's a feature. People are and have been working on that in real life for centuries, with great success. Democracies are far less corrupt than other systems of government, and until recently - until people started quitting and not supporting the work - they have been continually improving. What have you done to help? > crypto It's a sci-fi story; what you say is happening is a fiction (like many things on the Internet). We need to get serious about the real world and our real communities, now. We are losing ground every day.