6 ms·
Trio of Rust Core Team members hit the road
- gostsamo 5y agoSteve Klabnik is an HN regular and I always enjoy his participation on rust posts. I hope that he will continue to enrich the community.
- davidkunz 5y agoFully agree, his posts are insightful, clear and precise, I hope he remains involved in the community.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- runnerup 5y agoSomething about Steve Klabnik's communications always carried a lot of weight for me and lent a great deal of credence to Rust as a whole.
- capableweb 5y agoThis seems to be relatively drama-free, compared to the last departure (off the entire moderation team https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29306845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29306845), or they've learned there lesson that it's better to not say anything drama-inducing if they won't give the full story. Speaking about that, anyone know why the moderation team left by now? Has anything became public at this point or it's still anyones guess? There was some indication that some core member broke the Code of Conduct but was never "punished" for it, could this be the consequence that we're seeing after ~2 months?
- lijogdfljk 5y agoFlorian is commenting on the reddit post[1]. Sounds very drama free for them (the singular them.. not the plural... sigh). [1]: https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/sh7erp/changes_in_the_core_team_rust_blog/hv16u8a/ https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/sh7erp/changes_in_the...
- weakfish 5y ago
- melissalobos 5y ago> Sounds very drama free for them (the singular them.. not the plural... sigh). I don't quite understand this line, would you prefer they identify as multiple people? Or is the objection to using the singular them in general? There is a large historic precedent for using a singular them for people you for whom you are unfamiliar with their gender. Not even trying to be "woke" but if there was someone named Terry(about equal likelihood of being male or female), it makes a lot of sense to use "them"/"they" instead of "he" or "she". Edit: did you mean that for the other members it wasn't drama free?
- Azsy 5y agoI think they just meant that in this context them is ambiguous, meaning they are forced to clarify in this case. A regression in API. One that would be nice to see fixed in the next release.
- AprilArcus 5y agoIf you're troubled by the ambiguity of singular "they", I would like to invite you to share in the use of my boutique third person plural neopronoun, "th'all" (objective "all'em"; possessive determiner "all th'all's"). It's the perfect neologism for these factionalist and accusatory times, indexing no one's gender other than your own, insofar as it identifies yourself as someone who has a use for it. As for the Rust team, th'all have contributed mightily to the advancement of the industry and to the open source community in particular. I wish all'em the best of luck in all th'all's future endeavors.
- qzw 5y agoOk, I just read your last sentence out loud, and I reckon I sounded like a cross between Colonel Sanders and Yosemite Sam. Thanks for the laughs!
- Communitivity 5y agoWe in the Rust community owe all three of them a great deal for their many contributions of software and community involvement. I owe Steve Klabnik for turning me onto Rust in 2017 with his blog post "Five Years with Rust"[1]. Five years later he is heading into a new chapter of his life with Rust. Here's to another five years of Rust evangelism and activity. [1] https://steveklabnik.com/writing/five-years-with-rust https://steveklabnik.com/writing/five-years-with-rust
- CyberRabbi 5y ago
- red_trumpet 5y agoI don't think it's toxic to quit, whatever the reasons. Quite conversely, it seems toxic to persuade someone to stay, because there reason to quit appears to be bad. > Moderators are relatively easy to replace compared to members of the core team. I suppose they forgot that. Why do you suppose that? Apparently, they didn't want to do the moderating anymore. Just because finding a replacement is easy, doesn't mean they should do a job they don't like.
- CyberRabbi 5y ago> it seems toxic to persuade someone to stay, because there reason to quit appears to be bad. My comment is not meant to imply they should have stayed. The decision itself wasn’t toxic but a reflection of the toxic nature of the person who made the decision. The fact is that they were perfectly able to adequately do their job without codified power over the core team so this resignation was clearly not about being unable to do their job. They used a manipulation tactic to acquire power and their bluff was called. > Just because finding a replacement is easy, doesn't mean they should do a job they don't like. That conclusion wasn’t the intention of my comment either. The point is that they had a fundamental misunderstanding of their role in the organization and that came at a cost.
- istjohn 5y agoUnless you know something we don't, it sounds like you are extrapolating an awful lot about some folks based on extremely little actual information.
- CyberRabbi 5y ago> it sounds like you are extrapolating an awful lot about some folks Can you help me understand which of the things I said come across as an extrapolation? From my perspective all of it is a factual description of what happened with basic reasoning applied.
- bumblebritches5 5y ago
- _han 5y agoSee also yesterday's discussion about the original blog post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30151923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30151923
- Shadonototra 5y agosomething very nasty must have happened for moderation team then core people to leave like that.. also it is very sketchy that some people here want to hide/minimize the story as much as possible i remember everyone was being VERY VOCAL about the .net foundation "drama" you can see how pro-mozilla this website is in general, very sad for journalism and internet in general
- staticassertion 5y ago> also it is very sketchy that some people here want to hide/minimize the story as much as possible a) I don't think anyone expected people to stay with Rust for a decade or more b) I don't care about Rust governance that much c) I don't care about the .net foundation or even know wtf you're talking about I assume most people are a lot like me with regards to the above. I've been using rust since 2014, I've met many people across these teams, spoken at and attended conferences. None of this just feels like something I should worry about. If it were 2015, yeah, I'd be worrying. It's 2022, Rust has grown beyond the tiny group of people who had to shepherd it. They did a wonderful job - that's why I'm not worried. They succeeded in bringing Rust to mainstream, where now there are so, so many people invested in it.
- Xevi 5y agoIn which way does this news relate to Mozilla?
- floxy 5y agoWhat do the core team members do? I mean in more detail than: "Managing the overall direction of Rust, sub-team leadership, and any cross-cutting issues" ...as found at: https://www.rust-lang.org/governance/teams/core https://www.rust-lang.org/governance/teams/core Do they have regular meetings? If so, are there notes/minutes/video published from these meetings? Is there a list of edicts that the core team has decided on? Is the core team a voluntary or paid position? Who decides the core team membership? Who decides how many core team members there should be? Does the core team make tactical decisions (like Rust 1.7 shall have support for architecture X)? Is there a document from the core team outlining the current "overall direction of Rust"? Do they control what appears on the rust-lang.org domain? Do they control any funding that might be distributed to the other teams? Is there a potential better name for the core team? Executive team? Strategy team? Many people seem to believe that the core team members are working on rustc, but I don't think that is accurate.
- capableweb 5y agoYou can implicitly figure out what the core team does by going to https://www.rust-lang.org/governance https://www.rust-lang.org/governance and seeing what team does what. Otherwise, a good way to understand how Rust governance is happening is by reading the various RFCs, I think this one is the most relevant one for you: https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/1068-rust-governance.html https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/1068-rust-governance.html, specifically the "Core team" section: https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/1068-rust-governance.html#core-team https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/1068-rust-governance.html#c...
- floxy 5y agoThanks, that is interesting. Does anyone know where the charters for the teams are located? This is called out in 2021-Roadmap: https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/3037-roadmap-2021.html https://rust-lang.github.io/rfcs/3037-roadmap-2021.html ...I'm not seeing the 2022 Roadmap, is that still in the works?
- mjw1007 5y agoThey certainly used to have regular meetings. https://www.youtube.com/c/RustVideos/search?query=core%20team%202020 https://www.youtube.com/c/RustVideos/search?query=core%20tea... shows meetings up to 2020-09, though I don't see any since. (That's about the time of the big Mozilla layoffs, so maybe the person who used to upload the videos moved on then.)
- digitalsanctum 5y agoWhat struck me is there were no replacements named or even hinted at. Anyone know what the plan is moving forward?
- stblack 5y agoGiven the title and vibe of the article, could its closing sentence be worse? "Founding members of the Rust Foundation (kicked off in 2021) include Microsoft, Google and AWS." How hard can it be to craft a clear, clean closing sentence?
- istjohn 5y agoNews articles are not typically written like formulaic school essays where you state a thesis, support the thesis, and then conclude. They are instead written as if the reader could be whisked away at any moment and so the most important information must be front and center. Less relevant asides get tacked on the end. It's written to be read by busy people, in other words. Which is actually pretty cool.
- andrewflnr 5y agoIn my experience, really dang hard. In high school I agonized for hours about concluding sentences. I've gotten slightly more skilled, but I mostly solved the problem by lowering my standards.
- YATA0 5y agoDon't forget that Ashely Williams, one of Rust's Core team members, is cartoonishly sexist and racist: https://archive.md/VEtHu https://archive.md/VEtHu The Rust reddit moderation team actively removes any and all "negative" comments about her.
- u-r-dumb 5y agoLol how did I know this "sexism and racism" was about white men before even clicking
- YATA0 5y ago> Lol how did I know this "sexism and racism" was about white men before even clicking Because we've all become accustomed to expect it from SJWs like herself. You're only making my point for me. Just calling blatant racism and sexism out was enough for you to make a throwaway and post a reply to my factual comment. Out of the woodwork comes the triggered snowflakes. Sad.
- lol_u_cuck 5y agoHow do I know you showed your partner's boyfriend this post, seeking his approval "Heh I sure showed that chud! Hope he thinks next time about posting uncomfortable facts online!"