8 ms·
No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. The main problem seems to be that people have invented an entirely ficticious nucle
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons.
The main problem seems to be that people have invented an entirely ficticious nuclear power that does not and has never existed, just so they can slag off renewables and "elite culture" whatever the heck that is.
The real actual nuclear power, which is better than coal, but not particularly competitive with modern renewables is apparently irrelevant to people who have bizarrely joined a one sided culture war on the side of fossil fuel companies and think this makes them cool, well informed and counter-cultural despite reality leaning the other way.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. Do you have a source for this?
- formerly_proven 5y agoEvery summer in France
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway894345 5y agoSource? Is this inherent in all nuclear plants, or only in certain designs?
- maccard 5y agoNot OP but I google dit and found this [0] from almost 20 years ago. No mention of it being every summer though, and it was during a heat wave that disproportionately affected france. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/aug/12/france.nuclear https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/aug/12/france.nuclear
- b3orn 5y agoAll designs that take water from rivers and return it there. There usually is a regulation for the maximum water temperature in the rivers, so during the summer they can't heat up the water as much, leading to lowered energy output to the point where they have to shutdown some or all reactors of a plant.
- throwaway894345 5y agoThat doesn’t imply that nuclear plants regularly get close to this threshold nor that it’s common for all nuclear plants of this type (consider 2 identical plants positioned on differently-sized rivers: the larger river will be able to absorb more heat than the smaller river, ergo reliability of this sort varies).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikeyouse 5y agoIt's not just the river's ability to absorb the heat, it's also the plant's design criteria. The river water is the coolant in the secondary loop, warm water obviously has less capacity to absorb heat, so the plant will either get hotter (not great!) or will have to slow down the reaction to produce less heat (also not great during the summer when demand is the highest!). This isn't just an environmental concern but a design problem.
- mikeyouse 5y agoIt happens all the time; https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2019-07-01/nuclear-power-once-seen-as-impervious-to-climate-change-threatened-by-heat-waves#:~:text=In%20little%2Dnoticed%20but%20publicly,plants%20is%20at%20its%20highest https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2019-07-0.... > Now, increasingly, more frequent heat waves and hotter average temperatures are making those waters so warm that engineers are concerned that it can't do the job. Analysts say climate change is to blame. > In little-noticed but publicly available reports to regulators, nuclear plant owners revealed that unusually hot temperatures last year forced them to reduce the plants' electricity output more than 30 times – most often in the summer, when demand from nuclear plants is at its highest. In 2012, such incidents occurred at least 60 times. At one plant in Connecticut a reactor was taken offline for nearly two weeks when temperatures in the Long Island Sound surged past 75 degrees. It's not like you can just change the legislation to say "allow hotter discharge water" though -- the plants' very engineering criteria is being impacted. Warmer water has lower absorptive capacity to cool the primary loop so things get dicey when temps increase outside the design specification.
- infamia 5y agoThat sounds good, predictability is what you want when designing a power grid.
- sampo 5y agoNuclear plants use water from a local river, or sea, for cooling. Or some plants use air and have cooling towers. Nuclear plants are also tightly regulated by law. So there is a limit on how warm cooling water the plant is allowed, as per environmental regulations, to release into the river, or to the sea. If weather gets hot, the temperature of the incoming cooling water gets warmer, too. And having to operate within the limits of the maximum allowed temperature for the outgoing cooling water, the plant may have to regulate its power output, or maybe entirely pause operation. The temperature limit is mostly a legal one: There is concern about the environmental effects of releasing warmer water to the water bodies. From an engineering point of view, the plant would probably be able to operate, and just release warmer water.
- missedthecue 5y agoWhy can't they just refrigerate the water before releasing? Nothing too crazy just a few degrees. Run it through cooling pipes are something to dissipate the heat.
- pfdietz 5y agoThey could evaporate some of the water to cool the rest. This is why many nuclear plants in the US have cooling towers. But cooling towers consume water, and are fairly expensive.
- robertlagrant 5y agoI'm not debating the mechanisms; I'm after a source that hopefully reliably cites the frequency and severity of it. Wind and solar power drop to zero regularly, as we would expect. If nuclear does the same, then the comparison is totally valid. If it's something else then the comparison becomes less valid or invalid.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWhy are you so keen to defend one particular power production method on one narrow stat? This isn't a game of Top Trumps where you need to find any one stat that's higher than your opponents to declare victory. Nuclear has to be better than wind and solar and hydro and batteries and everything else (demand response, better insulation, undersea grid connectors etc.) all working together across a wide range of metrics to find a place in a modern grid. It is failing at this. The alternatives are cheaper, better, greener, safer, quicker to build. Narrowly focusing on one tiny aspect does not change this big picture reality.
- niea_11 5y agoI found this article : https://energyforhumanity.org/en/resources/reports-en/effects-heatwaves-nuclear-plants/ https://energyforhumanity.org/en/resources/reports-en/effect... Curtailment of nuclear power due to periods of extreme heat has had the effect of reducing European nuclear power output by approx. 0.1% since the year 2000. For France specifically, which with its many inland river-sited plants has been the worst hit country, the corresponding figure is approximately 0.15%
- robertlagrant 5y agoThanks. This doesn't sound appropriate to compare with how weather affects most renewables.
- drran 5y agoIn my country (Ukraine), 3 nuclear power plants out of 15 are competing with cities for fresh water because of drought.
- schnitzelstoat 5y agoI like the engineering of nuclear power plants, but I'm not particularly biased towards them over renewables. But we need to greatly improve energy storage if renewables are going to work. Places like Scotland have generated equivalent to around 97% of their entire electricity consumption from renewables - yet still consume around 13% of their energy from fossil fuels as they export the renewable energy at peak production.[1] I also just really don't like the misinformation that surrounds nuclear energy. I majored in Physics and it's just irritating to see people so confident in their ignorance. I recommend the book "Atomic Accidents"[2] as an excellent book on the dangers of nuclear power and nuclear power plant engineering in general. [1] https://fullfact.org/environment/scotland-renewable-energy/ https://fullfact.org/environment/scotland-renewable-energy/ [2] https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-Mountains/dp/1605986801 https://www.amazon.com/Atomic-Accidents-Meltdowns-Disasters-...
- caoilte 5y agoYeah. We need a better transmission grid before we can go to 100% renewables (balancing out Scottish wind with Spanish solar). But a better transmission grid is miles cheaper than nuclear, so it's still a no brainer.
- throwaway894345 5y agoCitation? In particular, small modular reactors are estimated to produce energy at a cost which rivals natural gas (but we can’t know for sure because anti-nuclear folks have prevented us from seriously testing it) which is almost certainly less than the cost of solar/wind and tens of thousands of km of massive copper cables.
- pfdietz 5y ago> small modular reactors are estimated to produce energy at a cost which rivals natural gas You'd be foolish to believe those projections from salesmen. NuScale's attempt at new reactors has already doubled in cost.
- dahfizz 5y ago> No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. Could you please expand on this? What is the ideal uptime for a nuclear plant vs wind/solar?
- ageofwant 5y agoYou have invented a fictitious enemy in your own made up "culture war" to rage and rail against what you believe is the one true answer. Thousands of hectares of pristine remnant bush are bulldozed to move, note not install, move, wind turbines into place. Nobody blinks an eye when thousands of hectares of remnant bush gets covered in solar panels. I'm the greenest person I know, a self identifying eco-facist. And I want a nuclear power station in every suburb. And so should you, if you gave a rats arse about the actual environment, and not some fake "war" raging in your meme-space while actual living things get ground into dust in the actual real world.
- VyperCard 5y agoThat sounds really deranged.
- throw0101a 5y ago> No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. As someone who lives in Ontario, Canada, where we have 10,000 MW of nuclear (click "Supply"): * https://ieso.ca/power-data https://ieso.ca/power-data This does not happen here.
- coliveira 5y agoProbably because Ontario has ample access to water cooling, probably from the lakes. That's not the case for many countries in Europe.
- throw0101a 5y agoNo doubt. But it's important to differentiate "inherit" limitations of a technology versus situational ones. Plenty of EU countries have coast lines too.
- Fnoord 5y agoYeah, and they have floods, too (Re: Fukushima). I'm a proponent of nuclear fission energy (to complement solar/wind/hydro) but it has to be done safely. Hopefully in the future we don't have to rely on it (switch to nuclear fusion or something else), or solve the nuclear waste issue somehow.
- infamia 5y agoGreen energy and nuclear are in different product categories. They are in no way comparable. It's like trying to compare an electric scooter to a work truck. This is because green energy is mostly fine for transient demand, but at this time, is completely unsuitable for base load applications. Nuclear is a base load product (base load pricing is quite expensive) and needs to be far more reliable. Its failure modes are such that we can build a reliable energy grid around it, and have done for decades. You can't say the same for green energy (right now) as evidenced by its multiple failures as of late, which is now responsible for decreasing the security of Europe.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoIn 2021 there are only two useful types of power: cheap power and peak power, and nuclear is neither. Base power is only a useful term if it's cheaper than peak power, since you can fill 100% of your power needs solely with peak power.
- option_greek 5y agoHow about something like an SLA for power? Clearly, placing any country's energy security in the hands of ever changing climate (less winds and high cloud cover) or at the feet of dictators has to factor in some where.
- phicoh 5y agoThere are a number of issues: 1) Short term, the faster we avoid CO2 the better. If SLAs make that more complex, then it is a net loss. Long term, the situation will be different because cheap gains will be gone. 2) Europe has mostly privatized energy. Who is suppose to set the SLA? 3) Nuclear plants need to be refueled. Does the SLA include a couple of months downtime every few years? That would suggest that the SLA is uniquely tailored to nuclear. 100% uptime? How is nuclear going to deal with that? 4) Power consumption varies over the day. A constant load again favors nuclear. A load that can handle daily and seasonal variation would be quite bad for nuclear. Basically what we need is flexible electricity production. On their own, nuclear, solar and wind are all equally bad at flexible electricity production. So the questions are: - how do we get cheap storage - how do we minimize the amount of storage we need
- thatfrenchguy 5y ago> The real actual nuclear power, which is better than coal, but not particularly competitive with modern renewables “Modern renewables” aren’t competitive at all, you can’t build a grid based on them. The ginormous amount of renewables in Germany compared to how much CO2 per kWh their grid produces (https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DE https://app.electricitymap.org/zone/DE ) is everything you need to know. Even in places like California (where I live) where Solar is viable, renewables will require so many battery storage to remove gas plants that it’ll push their co2/kWh way higher that nuclear.