2 ms·
> It is an app written by one of the largest and most ancient software companies in history, so they should know something about making apps. I think tradition
by robertlagrant 5y ago
> It is an app written by one of the largest and most ancient software companies in history, so they should know something about making apps.
I think tradition and collective experience matter very little with the issues you're describing. It is hard to form and keep a team that is both technically excellent and will make sensible UI choices.
Additionally, I don't know if this is true, but I get the feeling that pulling "product" and "UX" into totally separate professions has meant that ownership of the overall quality is now theoretically in the hands of people who can't ensure it. A similar idea to the principal-agent problem, although in reverse.
- fingerlocks 5y ago> I get the feeling that pulling "product" and "UX" into totally separate professions has meant that ownership of the overall quality is now theoretically in the hands of people who can't ensure it. Of all the answers proposed in this entire thread, this is the one I agree with the most. You put into words exactly what I’ve been thinking for years. The fundamental problem is the lack of accountability for the product owner. Consider the film industry: A reputable film director owns the film in the sense that their reputation and career depends on the quality of the final product. They still hire/outsource massive swaths of the work needed to produce a movie, but they are the person held ultimately responsible. Contrast that with some well-known software like Microsoft Teams. Teams is probably the worst piece of shit software I’ve used in 30 years. Who the fuck owns Teams? Not Satya. I have no idea. I bet no one at Microsoft can answer that question. The answer is probably nobody at all.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> They still hire/outsource massive swaths of the work needed to produce a movie, but they are the person held ultimately responsible. I sort of wonder whether software engineering is just weird, in the sense that in theory a director could probably do most of the jobs in a movie production, e.g. point a camera, select cast members, acting, set construction. They would do them badly, but they would have some idea of what is involved and what they want. Software is so iceberg-like that such equivalent direction seems impossible without a technical background.