2 ms·
> In the 1970s, I heard all about oil companies buying 200 mpg carburetors to keep them off the market. My dad laughed at that, saying the military would never
by wolverine876 5y ago
> In the 1970s, I heard all about oil companies buying 200 mpg carburetors to keep them off the market. My dad laughed at that, saying the military would never let patent law keep them from making 200 mpg tanks and stuff.
I know nothing about that story, but the military is budgeted by Congress and commanded by the President, and thus subject to political influence. Plenty of the what the military does is inefficient economically and militarily.
- WalterBright 5y agoBattles are won and lost based on gasoline. In the Battle of the Bulge, the German offensive failed when they ran out of gas. The Allied offensive in Europe was also limited by gas supplies. Do you think any military is going to allow itself to be crippled by patents? In WW1, the American aviation industry was crippled by patent lawsuits. The government put a stop to that nonsense and forced them to form a patent pool, so advanced military airplanes could be built.
- austhrow743 5y agoDuring a war amongst peers? No. Outside of that? Sure. Particularly if the crippling allows for an element of surprise and keeps that tech out of other peoples hands. Even without that though every country that isn’t spending the most it can on its military is choosing to ‘cripple’ it in favour of other things.
- WalterBright 5y agoDo you think your enemy could possibly care less about respecting your patent?
- austhrow743 5y agoWhy is the US military sending them the designs and saying please don’t copy these?
- WalterBright 5y agoWe're talking about the US military and US patents.
- fmajid 5y agoPatents require the invention to be disclosed. Now the Atomic Energy Commission had some special classified patents that were exempt from that rule, but that is very much an exception. The whole societal bargain behind patents is limited time monopoly in exchange for disclosure.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Do you think any military is going to allow itself to be crippled by patents? That might make sense in theory, but the history of war profiteering, etc. is otherwise. Militaries are 'crippled' by poor materials (though 'crippled' is an extreme case) - especially at the beginnings of wars. For example, many think most US airplanes are ineffective against serious foes, including the A-10, F-35 (not my opinion, but many think it), and all the older planes (including the new-old planes they recently signed to buy). That also applies to aircraft carriers. However, there are many vested interests in those weapons programs and they resist tooth and nail. Change requires aligning people within the national security community, the easy part, and then Congress and the President. Uniformed and civilian officials in the Department of Defense can be just as political and corrupt; many of both sorts go through revolving doors to industry and have careers invested in one thing or another, or simply, like many incumbents in many fields (such as IT), bury their heads in sand about change. > allow itself They have limited power to make these decisions, at least in democracies.