3 ms·
That is surely fixable. I.e., there is no constitutional restriction against Congress assigning such a task to some agency. NASA might be best organized, of fe
by ncmncm 5y ago
That is surely fixable.
I.e., there is no constitutional restriction against Congress assigning such a task to some agency. NASA might be best organized, of federal apparatus, to do the work, maybe under a future "General Aviation Revitalization Initiative" authorization, maybe letting contracts for actual development.
The problem to be overcome is that nobody private seems to be rich enough to jump through all the regulatory hoops to get a modern engine approved to build modern small aircraft around, no matter how much better one could be.
I don't know why a Cessna-size turboprop mill never got to market. Is periodic maintenance and inspection of turbines prohibitively expensive?
- sokoloff 5y agoThere’s no real reason to pre-approve something (IMO). You want to certify an airplane? Build and fly a prototype. If you’re capable to build an airplane manufacturing company, you’re capable to make and fly a prototype. For small aircraft turbines: Cessna makes the 208 Caravan. If the 208 is too big, Quest makes the Kodiak and Socata makes the TBM. If someone’s going to pay all the purchase and operating costs to run a PT6 turbine, they might as well drag around a medium-sized airframe. Maintenance and inspection of turbines isn’t prohibitive. Initial purchase price and specific fuel consumption at low altitude is a far greater concern for private operations. Pistons are way more popular simply because of economics. Virtually everything else about turbines is better. If I could afford a turbine, I’d switch to one immediately.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf it were that easy, we would not still be flying 70-year-old Lycoming and Continental designs. I interpret the facts on the ground to mean qualifying a new light-aircraft power plant is in practice prohibitively difficult and/or expensive, and needs assistance, maybe even statutory assistance.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt’s not the regulatory side so much as the total addressable market being quite small. If you build a new light airplane now, you’re looking to steal market share from annual sales figures totaling just over 1300 airframes per year. Worldwide. Ferrari sells almost as many cars in a month as light aircraft are sold in a year. I’m not surprised that people aren’t lining up to compete for those scraps.
- ncmncm 5y agoWe can speculate about what exactly are all the reasons, but none of it can change the facts. It is a safe bet that if small aircraft got as cheap and performant as is in easy reach of modern engineering and production capabilities, there would be a lot more of them bought and used. Halving cost ought to result in much more than twice the demand. For comparison, we may look at solar panels. There have been no fundamental advances in a long time, but increasing volume triggered by heavy Chinese subsidies kicked the market into a different mode it is still far from settled into. Probably there are lots who would rather general aviation not become a lot more accessible, but that is policy, not fundamental economics.
- sokoloff 5y agoFlying and maintaining a light aircraft for 100 hours in a year is a $25K-$50K endeavor. Insuring and paying the note on a six figure loan is another $10K+ expense. Hangaring can be another $5-20K. Most people would be paying these amounts with after tax dollars if it’s not for business use, so there are clear economic limits to how popular this will be. In many ways it’s like other expensive hobbies. Horses aren’t expensive because they’re rare or complex to make. Blue water sailing isn’t expensive due to lack of innovation in boats.
- ncmncm 5y agoHorses are mature tech, thousands of years old. Boats, likewise. Aircraft, barely more than a century. You cite costs as if they were ordained, but they are a direct product of history. Make a different history, you get a different product. You could have said the same about computers just a few years ago. Now you carry a supercomputer in your pocket and complain how slow it is.