4 ms·
Britain doesn't even have vague principles of free speech (or association for that matter.) The recent Rachel Riley case is an insane example, but it happens ev
by pessimizer 5y ago
Britain doesn't even have vague principles of free speech (or association for that matter.) The recent Rachel Riley case is an insane example, but it happens every day.
-----
> Riley initially posted a screenshot of a January 2019 tweet by the Guardian columnist Owen Jones about an attack on the former British National party leader Nick Griffin, which said: “I think sound life advice is, if you don’t want eggs thrown at you, don’t be a Nazi.” She added “good advice”, with emojis of a red rose and an egg.
> Later, Murray tweeted: “Today Jeremy Corbyn went to his local mosque for Visit My Mosque Day, and was attacked by a Brexiteer. Rachel Riley tweets that Corbyn deserves to be violently attacked because he is a Nazi. This woman is as dangerous as she is stupid. Nobody should engage with her. Ever.”
> Riley said she was being sarcastic in her tweet, did not call Corbyn a Nazi, and told the judge that Murray’s tweet caused serious harm to her reputation.
-----
Riley was awarded £10,000.
- vxNsr 5y agoThis doesn’t seem like it has anything to do with free speech, you can’t slander someone, it seems Murray attempted to slander Riley, she claims he succeeded in some regards.
- atdrummond 5y agoGiven the amount of people who venue shop such cases in the UK, I would buy an argument that speech has been curtailed due to how much easier it is to win such judgements there - even when it is often unclear how the party claiming harm was actually damaged.
- pessimizer 5y agoI disagree. Riley's tweet was clear and expressed her views accurately and sincerely, and Murray's tweet was sincere and a reasonable interpretation of Riley's tweet, which it directly referenced. Riley wasn't slandering Corbyn by cheekily calling him a Nazi - although part of her defense was explaining how Corbyn is actually an antisemite (which would be irrelevant or even counterproductive in a case accusing Murray of maliciously lying.) It's her honest belief. Murray honestly believes that Riley is stupid, and that Riley was showing her agreement with a physical attack on Corbyn. This can be a questionable interpretation if you realize that Riley probably hates Owen Jones, too, but it's certainly reasonable. Besides that, everyone had access to the Riley tweet, and could decide for themselves. It's an unbelievably low standard for liability. ----- > There are three major defenses against a defamation suit. The first is “privilege,” which typically protects journalists when they quote otherwise defamatory statements made by officials in parliament or the courts to allow for full reporting of issues of public interest. The second is “truth,” which protects the person being sued if they can show that what they said was true. And the third is “honest opinion,” which applies if an opinion was expressed and that opinion was held reasonably and expressed honestly rather than out of malice or to harm someone’s reputation. > Murray’s lawyers believed they could defend their client using not just one but two of the defenses: truth and honest opinion. Was Murray not justified in inferring that Riley was equating Corbyn to a Nazi when she implied that the two cases were similar, especially in the context of Riley’s earlier statements? Was Riley’s comment not agreeing with Jones’s approval of a previous attack and suggesting it was deserved this time too? And was Murray’s view not expressed honestly and with the intention chiefly to defend Corbyn’s reputation rather than harm Riley’s? (Calling someone “stupid” in a heated exchange on Twitter is not usually considered defamatory, otherwise we’d have many tens of thousands of people facing enormous fines.) https://www.mintpressnews.com/rachel-riley-libel-defamation-ruling-judicial-attack-political-speech/279419/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/rachel-riley-libel-defamation-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 5y agoIsn't Riley attempting to slander Corbyn by implying he is a Nazi? The saddest part about this is that Riley decided she should take someone responding to her tweet to court.