5 ms·
Where did Omicron come from? Three key theories
- natch 5y ago>Ahead of that report, scientists are investigating three theories. Although researchers have sequenced millions of SARS-CoV-2 genomes, they might simply have missed a series of mutations that eventually led to Omicron. Alternatively, the variant might have evolved mutations in one person, as part of a long-term infection. Or it could have emerged unseen in other animal hosts, such as mice or rats There is another theory, that Omicron is from a lab leak (or we might say "another" lab leak, but I don't want to jump to conclusions about that). From what I've read about this, and how Omicron is lacking the signs of natural evolution (specifically having branched off a strangely early strain of COVID and having a suspiciously low count of silent mutations which are expected in natural evolution) they truly have some gall to leave this theory out of their list.
- kaczordon 5y agoConsidering how many animal pool reservoirs there are it seems pretty likely that this variant came from such a reservoir and then hopped back into the human population where we first saw it, South Africa.
- natch 5y agoAbsolutely sounds plausible, but it seems odd to leave out another competing reasonable theory if the intent is to survey the various theories. Certainly they know stuff I don’t, though.
- jjulius 5y ago>Absolutely sounds plausible, but it seems odd to leave out another competing reasonable theory if the intent is to survey the various theories. To be fair, even the article suggests that "whichever idea a researcher favours 'often comes down to gut feeling rather than any sort of principled argument'", that "they are all fair game" and "everyone has their favourite hypothesis." So there are a lot of reasonable theories out there; at what point do they stop adding other theories to the article without upsetting someone that certain theories were ommitted? >Certainly they know stuff I don’t, though. Maybe that's why they had the "gall" to not mention it?
- natch 5y ago> Maybe that's why they had the "gall" to not mention it? Maybe. Could be other reasons as well, like circling the wagons to protect their preferred work approaches and their colleagues. It’s not like this isn’t a known phenomenon in virology.
- 22c 5y ago> then hopped back into the human population How likely is that? Do you think Omicron got very lucky, or are we just very lucky that (if the animal reservoir theory is correct) it only happened with Omicron?
- natch 5y agoSomehow doing so without the expected number of silent mutations. Off by an order of magnitude. Yeah not sure how that could happen.
- dudul 5y ago> or we might say "another" lab leak, but I don't want to jump to conclusions about that) I think we're good now. When Newsweek is finally admitting the thing that got 1000s of people vilified it's now part of TheScience(TM)
- kuhewa 5y agoThat's technically a variant of emerging from other hosts.. although I suppose it could have been grown on tissue culture and not animal models.
- jml7c5 5y ago>having a suspiciously low count of silent mutations which are expected in natural evolution AIUI the low dN/dS isn't too far out of line with other variants.
- burner556 5y agoYeah! Didn’t they say it evolved in rats? Hmm.. I wonder where they use rats? Yet nobody wants to say it.
- lmilcin 5y agoStupid idea: create artificial virus that spreads faster than natural one but without negative health effects. Nobody would admit that, but that could potentially be most efficient way to combat a future global pandemic (assuming people keep sabotaging the system by not cooperating).
- bediger4000 5y agoI dunno, nobody even does this for computer viruses, which have a lot less ethical downside.
- halpert 5y agoThe FBI did something similar once: https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2021/04/14/fbi-hacks-into-hundreds-of-infected-us-servers-and-disinfects-them/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2021/04/14/fbi-hacks-into-h...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kuhewa 5y agoHard for it to spread faster than a respiratory bug unless it has some symptoms - coughs etc. The version of that idea that is feasible is intentional innoculations, which is basically a live attenuated vaccine.
- lmilcin 5y agoWell, a virus can be contagious without symptoms. COVID in particular starts spreading before symptoms suggesting you could have respiratory virus without people even being aware they are infected. And we know most people are not even aware they were sick or they had only mild symptoms. The issue with COVID is that some people are hit hard and a lot of people develop hard to detect complications. If you could modify the virus to avoid complications and avoid hitting some people very hard, you could have pretty effective way to innoculate population. The thing you are after is a virus that has same basic spike protein for your immune system to recognize and only enough mechanism to multiply itself.
- laserbeam 5y agoOption 4: lab leak. Now, I don't know if there's any evidence for/against this. Most people don't understand how these things work. But, if you're going to write an article stating all hypotheses... You best state them all and then procede to arguing for/against each one. Not even acknowledging that omicron could be artificial is poor practice. We've already been through this once yelling "bats!". I understand people needed comfort at that time, and I agree that talking about a lab leak at the start of the pandemic could cause people to point fingers instead of working together to solve the issue. But, we're not there anymore. We need to list all theories and rigurously reject each incorrect one.
- jjeaff 5y agoMy understanding from listening to virologists (this week in virology podcast) is that bats or similar animals are still the most likely culprit. Not that lab leak is impossible, but just that animal spillover still seems most likely.
- puffoflogic 5y agoI wonder if there's a group of people who are uniquely motivated to prove, or convince, that COVID is not a lab leak... It's been pointed out that a couple decades ago, we had this notion "conflict of interest": that someone too close to an issue is a poor choice to report on that issue, because everyone is influenced by their own self-interest. But now we have turned that idea completely on its head! We demand to hear only the opinions of "the experts"; who are in fact the same people who we used to describe as having a conflict of interest!
- jjeaff 5y agoVirology is far too complicated for non-experts to have any chance of finding a valid answer. We simply need to watch for and be careful of conflicts of interest. Any good expert, especially academic, knows the importance of disclosing conflicts and for bias, well, we can only hope that there are enough diverse experts that they will catch that.
- 5y ago
- tomjonesey 5y ago