2 ms·
I freakin' love SICP. It has the same "energy", as they say, that Scheme itself does. It's succinct, and yet it covers nearly all of the big concepts of program
by bitwize 5y ago
I freakin' love SICP. It has the same "energy", as they say, that Scheme itself does. It's succinct, and yet it covers nearly all of the big concepts of programming, starting from a nucleus of a few key ideas (including, especially, lambda). It also explodes some of the myths underlying programming -- and by myths I mean "stories we tell to describe the shape of the universe", not "utterly false things a lot of people think is true". One of those myths is OO. You can see how OO works through SICP, and you can build your own OO system in Scheme, so there is nothing irreducibly fundamental about OO; it doesn't even need a language that explicitly supports it!
But uh, yeah, all of y'all recommending SICP as an intro to programming need to stop. Your target audience, if they take up programming at all, as a hobby, as a profession, or as a way to help them do their real work, is probably not going to use Scheme. They're not going to give a single flying fuck that a small language nucleus can give rise to a whole kundalini of programming concepts and approaches. And when they see the unrelenting mathiness of SICP, they're going to doze off. Plenty of copies of TAOCP sit unread on bookshelves for this same reason also.
I've gone from being a Lisp, Jazz, Aikido guy to a Visual Basic, Punk Rock, MMA guy. At the end of the day, what counts is getting it done with a minimum of fuss, not beauty or orthogonality or any of those other concepts. If you want to teach people programming, teach them to program things they care about in a language they are likely to use.
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> But uh, yeah, all of y'all recommending SICP as an intro to programming need to stop. Your target audience, if they take up programming at all, as a hobby, as a profession, or as a way to help them do their real work, is probably not going to use Scheme. Some of us are working on that, and that's all I'm gonna say right now. And yeah, maybe that's not going to work out. Anyone see a white whale around here? > Plenty of copies of TAOCP sit unread on bookshelves for this same reason also. I'd say that TAOCP is more of a reference work than a course textbook. It's a completely different kind of book to SICP.
- bitwize 5y ago> Some of us are working on that, and that's all I'm gonna say right now. Some sort of Guix thing? Near as I can tell, Guix is the second biggest attempt to mainstream Scheme (the first being Brendan Eich's failed attempt to embed Scheme in Netscape Navigator, resulting in JavaScript).
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> Some sort of Guix thing? Nah, this is very small and rough at the moment -- may never come to anything. But it's fun to work on. > the first being Brendan Eich's failed attempt to embed Scheme in Netscape Navigator, resulting in JavaScript What a different (and better, IMO) world we'd be in if he'd managed to sneak that by the suits... ah, well.
- snicker7 5y agoA lot of JS bloat could have been eliminated if it had lisp-like macros.
- singingboyo 5y agoArguably, the problem is conflating programming as a job with CS degrees. CS degrees cover very little of what day-to-day programming looks like. They're a useful theoretical underpinning, but as the saying goes, "In theory, theory and practice are the same. In practice, they are not." So, if you go through SICP as an intro to learning those theoretical underpinnings, it's probably pretty good, but you'll also want some more 'real-life' programming experience. If you read SICP expecting some deep insights into programming as a job, then it's probably not going to help.