4 ms·
Was anybody else completely turned off by the pop-up that screams "Keep Reading..."? Ugh. I quit after that. Also, please don't confuse conscientiousness wit
by throwaway2037 5y ago
Was anybody else completely turned off by the pop-up that screams "Keep Reading..."? Ugh. I quit after that.
Also, please don't confuse conscientiousness with bed-side manner. They are plenty of people have excellent "bed-side manner" (all industries), but are not conscientiousness. Think of a school librarian who is loved by the children, but cannot manage the day-to-day work of library operations. The two may be correlated, but certainly not 100% as this author implies.
To me, testing a software developer for conscientiousness, I could think of two different, but equally valuable ways:
(1) A ridiculously complex set of _written_ requirements to code a function. Literally, show the man page for class C-function "atoi()", then ask them to re-impl in any language. There are /so/ many corner cases. Oh yeah, then testing too. There are harder versions of this function, like "strtol()". Another good one: Ask someone to write a function that can add/subject date periods using multiple holiday calendars. Almost none of them will program it where weekends may be days other than Sat/Sun (looking at you Middle East zone). Example: Subtract six business days using these holiday calendars and these weekend days.
(2) This part is behavioural. Think of an absolutely ridiculous "obstacle course" that you _personally_ needed to complete in the last three months to get something trivial done. Use this as your template. Now create a "Choose Your Own Adventure" style story in your mind. Prompt the candidate with an issue, such as add 10GB of disk space to a network attached storage mount or open/whitelist a port on a firewall. Imagine how many things can go wrong. Every step of the way, challenge with new and absurd obstacles. Check how persistent they are to try different paths. Example: "I cannot log into the website to make the request. Help desk says it takes 3 days to get that access." Better candidates will quickly pivot to ask their teammates -- "Can you help me log into this website?" Etc.
Yes, it is impossible to get perfect on both tests, unless you are a robot or Singularity AI. I've met a few incredibly strong co-workers in one of those categories. If they were even average in the other category, they were a top 5% worker -- easily.
- Palomides 5y agoI experienced an interview like your #2 a few years ago, they gave a situation like "it is your first day and a customer has an issue, here is their phone number" and played through a tricky drawn out process of figuring out what was going on I flubbed it because, I assume, I didn't ask teammates for advice/support, so I guess it worked, since that was a weakness I had in retrospect I think it's a fair strategy for interviews
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoIn different interviews, candidate might be asked the same literal question but be expected to produce very different responses. The interviwer will ususally provide no context for the situation or state what he is looking for. Interviews are not a simulation of reality, so you don't have context like you would in a real situation. Like in dungeons and dragon, what moves are allowed? What are the rules of engagement? The people you will select are often those that read non-verbal clues or guessed what you are looking for. Thats why there is so much culture bias in interviews.
- throwaway2037 5y agoThat is a good point. I would be very upfront and provide a one pager before the interview explaining sample questions and what we are looking for. Also, each time I interview a software engineer, I give a 30 second "speech" that is roughly: "For today's technical interview, we are not interested in what you do NOT know. We are interested in what you do know and how deeply you know it. Some interviewers are trying to trick you or show they are smart or show that you are wrong. That is not us. If we discuss a topic that you don't know about or have no experience, just tell us. No problem -- we will move to a different topic."
- civilized 5y agoI haaaaate it when interviewers ask vague questions and then fault you for taking it in a direction they didn't want. So many interviewers act as if they expect to hire someone who has already worked at their company for five years and knows the codewords of the local cult.
- rendall 5y ago> Was anybody else completely turned off by the pop-up that screams "Keep Reading..."? Ugh. I quit after that. Absolutely, and me too. It seemed to be a good article, but it had not convinced me that it was worth it to give up my anonymity and data to those people. No, quite the contrary. It pissed me off so much that I came to HN to whine about it, which is something nobody wants.
- motoboi 5y ago>Was anybody else completely turned off by the pop-up that screams "Keep Reading..."? Ugh. I quit after that. > Also, please don't confuse conscientiousness with bed-side manner. They are plenty of people have excellent "bed-side manner" (all industries), but are not conscientiousness. Think of a school librarian who is loved by the children, but cannot manage the day-to-day work of library operations. The two may be correlated, but certainly not 100% as this author implies. Well, you actually lost the best part of the article. No paywall: https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https://www.holloway.com/s/trh-hiring-for-conscientiousness https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https://www.holloway.com/s/trh-hirin...
- phkahler 5y ago>> Was anybody else completely turned off by the pop-up that screams "Keep Reading..."? Ugh. I quit after that. Me too, but because it wasn't clear how to get rid of it without "continue with Google" or the other options. I always stop reading when presented with that crap. This one was particularly annoying with how far it let me read before making me stop.