5 ms·
So with a capacity of 1k cycles and recharging on weekdays only, the battery should last about 4 years? Is that enough to make electric cars viable for all use
by jqpabc123 5y ago
So with a capacity of 1k cycles and recharging on weekdays only, the battery should last about 4 years?
Is that enough to make electric cars viable for all use cases? It depends on cost --- of the car initially and of a battery replacement. It would have to be less than the cost of current electric vehicles which have a much longer expected battery lifetime.
- deergomoo 5y agoYou wouldn’t be charging from 0-100% every day though. For most people it would be more like 1-2 cycles per week, if not less.
- jqpabc123 5y agoIt's hard to say what "most people" will do. My wife plugs her phone in every night as a matter of habit --- just to be sure, whether it really needs charging or not. I know from experience that this degrades the battery lifetime.
- ninkendo 5y agoAny battery that has an even moderately intelligent chip moderating its charge will round-robin the individual cells so that it’s not the same cells being charged/discharged all the time. If you’re always topping off the charge at night, the cells in the battery pack are still experiencing full discharge cycles eventually. (Cells will end up staying at 100% charge for a while though, which is probably ultimately bad for them, but they should still be fully discharged/charged eventually…)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CorrectHorseBat 5y agoA phone doesn't have a thermal management system that can cool and heat the battery if required. Charging your car every day is not an issue.
- jacob019 5y agoCharging the phone from 60% to 100% is 0.4 cycles. So your wife is putting less than 3 cycles per week on the phone battery. Sitting at 100% does degrade the battery, especially since the phones all charge to 4.4V these days. I root my phones so I can set a 4.1V charge limit.
- moduspol 5y agoiPhones do have logic in software now to hold off on charging above 80% until the user is expected to take it off the charger [1]. Probably still not as good as personally optimizing your charge time based on battery level, but it's at least not quite as bad to be plugging it in every night as it used to be. [1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210512 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210512
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoSamsung phones on Android 12 have a toggle for "charge to 85%" now. Not as "smart", but a great way to extend battery life if that's your focus. That last 15-20% charge is apparently a killer.
- moduspol 5y agoIt'd work for me. I'd absolutely trade long battery life to only ever using 80% of the battery for pretty much all my electronics.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoYeah, I was happy to toggle that option on.
- duffyjp 5y agoI babied my iPhone 12 Pro by using an automation to turn off a smart-outlet at 76% charge. After a year I'm at 95% health, basically on par with everyone else. I've discontinued the automation and will just buy a new battery in another year or two instead. /shrug
- MaxikCZ 5y agoI would say its even smarter. I don't want to charge my phone to 100% every day, and I don't want to babysit it. Smart charging would be: "start charging now and finish at time my alarm is set, while reaching 80% battery." Slow charging to 80% and your battery can last multiple times what it would "normally". I don't understand the craze for 40-60-100 watt phone chargers...
- gameswithgo 5y agoThat isn’t usually how “cycles” works out, no, unless you deplete the battery completely every day.
- jqpabc123 5y agoI know from experience that a lot of people will recharge every day --- just to be sure. How this will impact their definition of "cycle" is unknown but again; based on my experience with batteries, it won't be good.
- alias_neo 5y agoI think you may be misunderstanding the meaning of "cycle". Charging every night for a 5 day week, from 80% to 100% is 1 cycle (in this crude example). A cycle is not the number of times you plug in a battery to charge, it's a single charge/discharge full to empty and vice versa. There is more to it of course because you never really "empty" a lithium battery, and for longevity it may be configured to never be fully charged to 100%, but that's roughly the point.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThere is more to it of course ... Yes, most rechargeable batteries will degrade over time just sitting there --- without any "cycling".
- DennisP 5y agoThe article says it's a ten-year lifespan. Which seems reasonable since ideally, if it's a thousand cycles and a thousand miles per cycle, that's a million mile battery.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- maxwell86 5y ago99% of commutes are less than 200 miles. Current car batteries support large numbers of charge cycles and have a capacity that's high enough for these trips. However, many drivers do a bunch of 500+ miles drives per year; 1, 10, or 100, depends on the driver. At 500+ miles, battery anxiety starts to kick in. An electric car that combines current high-cycles-low-range batteries with a smaller low-cycle-very-large-range battery for those 10 500+ miles trips per year would be a killer product. We are talking here 1000+ miles without charging, which is kind of much farther than what most cars can get without re-fueling. I do maybe one 500+ miles trip per month. That'd be ~24 cycles / year, such that these batteries would have a lifetime for my use of ~40+ years. That's more than enough for me. There are a bunch of companies working on hybrid battery designs that combine different technologies to serve different purposes. Some of them are already hitting 800+ miles in real-world tests.
- jqpabc123 5y agoThe tricky part is the recharging. The car can't possibly know if the owner is planning a 500 mile trip the next day. The only "safe" approach is to assume they are and top up all batteries every time it is plugged in. If the owner plugs it in every day, how does this impact the usable life of this new battery?
- notreallyserio 5y agoThe car doesn't necessarily have to know that someone is planning a 500 mile trip, the car operator can tell it to top up overnight when necessary.
- nicoburns 5y agoWhat could possibly require you to take an unexpected 500 mile trip at short notice?
- notreallyserio 5y agoAnd without the opportunity to charge at a supercharger on the way?
- parkingrift 5y agoThat would depend on the definition of a "cycle." If these truly enable 5x energy density there would be cars on the market with 1,200 - 1,500 mile range. The average American drives 40 miles per day. If I were an average American driving an average amount and I charged my car every night it would be topping the battery from 97% to 100%. Does that qualify as a cycle? I don't know, but I doubt it. Even if I recharged once per week that would be 80% to 100%, and I would also doubt that qualifies as a cycle. The authors estimated 10 year lifespan but I'm not sure how they came up with that number, either. If these batteries really do offer 5x density I would likely charge my car 30-40 times per year.