4 ms·
The thing is, phages require a lot more effort than antibiotics at all stages from production over stockkeeping and selection (unlike antibiotics, phages are hi
by mschuster91 5y ago
The thing is, phages require a lot more effort than antibiotics at all stages from production over stockkeeping and selection (unlike antibiotics, phages are highly specific to bacterial strains) to administration.
In the West, we simply used antibiotics which were good enough until a decade or two ago, so we didn't need to invest in phages.
- nikolay 5y agoWe didn't use antibiotics, we abused them! For example, often doctors, instead of testing, and then prescribing a targeted antibiotic, give you on, two, three until you have an improvement without getting culture and prescribing the right antibiotic! Also, often, antibiotics are prescribed preventively for viral infection (like pneumonia), and not given ONLY when you have a proven bacterial infection, so, being lazy and cutting costs pretty much erase a whole arsenal of drugs!
- mschuster91 5y agoYeah, and add to that the abuse of reserve (!) antibiotics in farming to improve yield.
- folli 5y agoTo be fair, lab testing can take a day or more, if you need to include an antibiotics screen, even more. Sometimes an infection can get very severe in this time span, so sometimes antibiotics are given prophylactically without waiting for the results to come back. I hope the massive advances of sequencing will reach the clinics soon, it should be possible to get the genome of the infectious bacteria/virus in a couple of hours with today's tech. You can even infer the antibiotic resistance from this info, so you'd know how to treat the infection in a very targeted fashion.
- andai 5y ago>I hope the massive advances of sequencing will reach the clinics soon What are the obstacles to this? I have been seeing articles lately about sequencing your own DNA at home in a few hours for about a thousand bucks. I guess the medical grade equipment has to be a lot more robust, so a lot more expensive? (And there might be an insufficient supply of biology interns to operate the equipment.)
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoWe still abuse them HEAVILY. My boyfriend got a whole stock of different antibiotics for his acne (that isn't even that bad). Women mention an itch in their private parts to doctors and, you guessed it, immediately get prescribed, often random, antibiotics. I had a (not yet, but moving towards "life threatening") abscess. In the phase where we were still seeing if it could heal out by draining without antibiotics, no culture was done. When it quickly got worse, I got prescribed a set of three distinct antibiotics at once. That lead to me developing persistent gram negative folliculitis on the beard that another doctor wanted to treat with Ciprofloxacin, which is known to cause permanent tendon, cartilage, eye damage or death in a significant amount of patients. At my urging I got prescribed a different one. Which didn't help. I got rid of my folliculitis myself with an extreme regime of topical salicylic acid, tee trea oil and BPO. Doctors pretty much roll the dice on which antibiotics they prescribe.
- webmobdev 5y agoThis is very much true in India too, where antibiotics are sometimes administered even for common cold, without any tests, on the doctors judgement. Healthcare policies has also changed the attitude of the people as they tend to consider any medical tests suspiciously as an unnecessary money making venture by the doctor and / or hospital. Moreover, most people also don't strictly follow the instructions to take the antibiotic doses for the requisite period and often stop in the middle, once they feel better.
- andai 5y ago>unlike antibiotics, phages are highly specific to bacterial strains Considering the negative effects of antibiotics (disregulating the gut microbiome which leads to all kinds of problems, and exerting evolutionary pressure in the direction of antibiotic resistance), isn't selectivity actually a huge plus?
- mschuster91 5y agoIndeed, the problem is that if the patient comes into the ER with a suspicion of acute sepsis due to bacterial infection, you don't have much other choice than to blast him with broad-spectrum antibiotics as it takes time for making blood cultures - time the patient may not have.
- sudosysgen 5y agoCould a large sample of phages be administered instead?
- chasil 5y agoThe article discusses "training" phases, where the stock phage is applied to a sample of the specific pathogen, and only the most successful daughter phages are retained, over several repetitions. This process of encouraging adaptation appears to greatly increase successful outcomes.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThat makes sense for resistant infections, but for general infections a pre-made stock should work, no?
- chasil 5y agoFor something that is already resistant to antibiotics, the training phase seems prudent. Exploiting evolution as part of the treatment leads to greater success. The emergence of phage-resistant pathogens should not be encouraged, as we have encouraged antibiotic resistance. I think it's a change in mindset, as well as a change in procedure.
- chasil 5y agoThe article states that the "six most dangerous antibiotic-resistant bacterial pathogens" are known as "ESKAPE." The viral phages used to target this group are used in tandem with appropriate antibiotics, and the phages are "trained" in several rounds to optimize effectiveness prior to application. It would seem reasonable to begin general distribution of this treatment for ESKAPE, and begin preparing similar treatments for what we might guess are the next few dozen that will join this group.