5 ms·
The manufacturer changing the UI of a car after you bought it should be illegal or at least highly restricted. I think many of us have been incensed by UI chan
by userbinator 5y ago
The manufacturer changing the UI of a car after you bought it should be illegal or at least highly restricted.
I think many of us have been incensed by UI changes in software we use for our daily work, and that's already bad enough; but IMHO this really crosses a line.
There were jokes when Apple changed the scroll direction, comparing it to the steering wheel of a car suddenly working opposite to what everyone is used to; I'm not sure if it's possible to do that with a Tesla or other modern car, but it's disturbing that we seem to be headed down that path. What an absurd reality.
The icons-only UI is also a huge regression; would it really take much extra effort to add a text label? I know people often mention localisation when it's brought up, but much of the world knows English, this is an American car sold in English-speaking regions, and changing the text in software is much easier than a separate part with different printing.
(I drive a 50-year-old land yacht that's received many upgrades, but all under my control; so my perspective may be slightly biased...)
- yumraj 5y ago> The manufacturer changing the UI of a car after you bought it should be illegal or at least highly restricted I cannot agree more. A lot of safety in driving comes from muscle memory and doing without needing to look so that focus is on the road. No wonder Tesla fans are fan of self driving and afraid of human driving, the effing Teslas seem like a usability nightmare.
- abustamam 5y agoputs on tin foil hat This might be a "feature": make cars so confusing to manually drive that humans become worse at driving, so that Tesla doesn't need to improve its driving software. I don't actually believe this, of course, but it seems we're headed in that trajectory.
- perryizgr8 5y agoI truly believe that UI in software must be done by an external consultant, on a one-time contract basis. Don't hire them full-time, they will fuck it up eventually. It is extremely limiting for a designer to work on the same app, same design every day. They will always try to bring in a new UI every couple years, just to maintain their own sanity. But it's not good for the product and its users. So let designers work on various different products.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago> just to maintain their own sanity paycheck, see my other comment [0] for an example [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30145176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30145176
- cainxinth 5y agoTesla drivers have called this a feature not a bug for years and bragged that their vehicles can update over the air like a smartphone… while the physical knobs on my Subaru will only ever do what they were designed to do when I bought it. Well, just like a smartphone, sometimes the latest OS update makes changes that people don’t like. For good or ill, I think the Tesla way is probably the future for most cars and my not-so-smart vehicle UX will be increasingly rare.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xxs 5y ago>I know people often mention localisation when it's brought up, How so? If they design something that doesn't fit the screen, etc. in another language - it's just a bad design. Localizations have been a standard process for decades already. They can be quite challenging when it comes to bidi, yet most left to right languages are no issue to even bring the topic.
- copirate 5y ago> The manufacturer changing the UI of a car after you bought it should be illegal or at least highly restricted. Mandatory user feature flags would be a good solution for that. After installation if you don't opt-in for the new features you get the same behavior as before.
- edanm 5y ago> The manufacturer changing the UI of a car after you bought it should be illegal or at least highly restricted. Why? Just don't buy a Tesla or other cars that do this. You don't have to outlaw everything you don't like, you can just choose not to patronize the people who do this. Vote with your wallet!
- makeitdouble 5y agoThis works well until your last resort brand just follows the trend. For instance, I'd bet getting stick shift in a new car in 15 years would cost the price of a Ferrari. That's what it would mean to "vote with your wallet".
- edanm 5y ago> This works well until your last resort brand just follows the trend. For the most part, competition works well. If there are enough people who care about this issue, it will be worth it for a manufacturer to not follow the trend, to get those extra consumers. If almost everyone else prefers this way, well, yeah, you're out of luck. But unfortunately, the world doesn't owe you anything. If you're the only one who cares about this, that's just unfortunate. > For instance, I'd bet getting stick shift in a new car in 15 years would cost the price of a Ferrari General issues aside, I'm surprised you think this. Driving stick has been around for dozens of years despite the invention of automatic transition. And in many countries in Europe, it's actually much more common.
- makeitdouble 5y ago> competition works well It works with a healthy support by regulators. I'd back that claim with the amount of cartel like behavior that gets disclosed every so often, and how hard the different nations are trying to come with solutions to the MS/Meta/Google/Amazon/Apple problems. "Vote with your wallet" is the part that happens after the competition is alive and kicking, up to that point a lot needs to be done to have competition in the first place. > driving stick Auto transmission was seen as a luxury for a long time and a lot of EU country favor frugality. Now that hybrids and full EVs are seen as more eco-friendly the change will get a lot faster I think. Stick shifts will probably stay the norm for many decades more in rural Aftica for instance, but otherwise I don't think it's long for the more developped world.
- FredrikSE 5y agoI would say that most of the customers that buy Tesla more or less expect the UI to change with time. That's why they bought the car in the first place. - I know I do, love the fact that the car still feels alive and evolving after I bought it. Then I think the new ui is worse than the older one - but my wife prefers the new one.