3 ms·
Not as long as I own my own computer. Does my computer use CPU to display your ad? Yes. Do I get to control my computer? Yes, we're not a socialist state yet, n
by bediger4000 5y ago
Not as long as I own my own computer. Does my computer use CPU to display your ad? Yes. Do I get to control my computer? Yes, we're not a socialist state yet, nor are we a fascist state. It's mine. I will do what I please.
- thfuran 5y agoYeah, sure. Just like since my car is mine, I spend my weekends driving over my neighbors' mailboxes and no one has any right to complain because I'm just using my car as I please. Only socialists and fascists could complain about that.
- bediger4000 5y agoNot the same thing - broken analogy. If anything is the case, web advertisers are using my car to drive to my mailbox and stuff it full of crap. Just like email spammers of the past, web advertisers are externalizing the costs of their ads onto all of us. They are morally in the wrong.
- thfuran 5y agoOf course it's not the same thing. It's an analogy. The point is, your ownership of something simply does not entitle you to use it however you please. And frankly, what you're demanding in this case is more like the right to use other people's hardware precisely as you please. Serving your requests uses their CPU time and you're refusing to hold up your end of the deal. To go back to a car analogy, you're going to a drive-in theater and refusing to pay.
- _zzaw 5y agoHave you ever gotten a drink during a commercial break? Then I guess you’re a thief and a pirate who isn’t holding up their end of the deal. He’s certainly welcome to bar adblock-users from his site. That’s technically possible, if his CPU time is so valuable. Same as a drive-in theater keeps out people who don’t pay. But he’s not requiring ads. He’s requesting that people choose to watch them. Those ads are insultingly intrusive and obnoxious, and we are saying “no”, per our right to use our computers as we see fit. Huffing about how terrible it is that people are refusing to subject themselves to that garbage won’t accomplish anything. I’d say a better solution would be to identify monetization approaches that aren’t repellent. Disincentivizing bad ideas is how progress is made. That’s just how a free market works. If treating his users badly is turning out to be unprofitable for him, I would classify that as a feature, not a bug.
- manuelabeledo 5y agoSocialism doesn't disallow private property of consumer goods.
- bediger4000 5y agoI just threw that in as a lightning rod. In the USA, at least, "socialism" or "communism" or "radical left" is just something that conservatives use to label anything they don't like.