4 ms·
What’s so good about states? Just an employer who can’t pay enough or hire people who smoke weed, but you seem to be worshipping them like they’re automatically
by astrange 5y ago
What’s so good about states? Just an employer who can’t pay enough or hire people who smoke weed, but you seem to be worshipping them like they’re automatically gods.
- amanaplanacanal 5y ago> What’s so good about states? I’d say strong incentives plus unlimited funding.
- astrange 5y agoTheir incentives aren't that strong (best you get is a medal you can't show or tell anyone about) and unlimited funding can mean they start an unlimited number of underfunded projects, rather than funding one endlessly. What they do have is patience and secrecy.
- fsflover 5y agoIncentives to do what?
- viktorcode 5y agoSoftware security can be thought of as operating on a cost/benefit model. To produce secure software means making attackers spend more resources on penetrating defences than the value they get from successful attack. And it works well for mass market, because the vast majority of attacks are non-targeted attempts to fish for financial credentials, taking over the devices for use in a botnet etc. For state attacker the model breaks. The value of a target can be very high. And the available resources - financial, technical, other - are there to fill the budget.
- datavirtue 5y agoI can exchange pgp keys with someone and send encrypted messages back and forth. No amount of funding or resources will ever be able to expose those messages. This is math. You sound like you are defending Apple for exposing journalists and activists when Apple, in fact, explicitly allowed remote code execution by untrusted actors. They way you put it, these people fired up a quantum computer and broke the users password hash. What they actually did is the equivalent of an activex control owning a machine in a drive-by attack.
- viktorcode 5y agoWhat you describe is an ideal Alice / Bob situation, setting just a single protected surface. In real world it's getting far more complex: what OS your PGP client is running on? On what hardware? Is anything else running on the same device that may break out of its sandbox and inject the code in another process? And so on. > when Apple, in fact, explicitly allowed remote code execution by untrusted actors Can you please elaborate what do you mean by that?
- NikolaeVarius 5y ago>I can exchange pgp keys with someone and send encrypted messages back and forth. No amount of funding or resources will ever be able to expose those messages You have no goddamn clue if this is correct or not. Your keys may be compromised, your computer might have spyware on it, your messaging client might be backdoored.
- krisoft 5y agoStates have crazy amounts of resources and they are not worried about their return on investment the same way other actors are. If a hacker wants to scam people out of their savings they have a limit on how much money they can potentially earn. I don’t know what the actual numbers are, but let’s say an attacker can hope to extract 100k USD from one in every 10k prospect. If those are the numbers then the attacker can’t waste more than 10 dollar on any individual targets on average or they would start loosing money. I suspect the real numbers are even worse. On the other hand if you work for a state and you burn a few billion dollars to research some zero day vulnerabilities which you then use to delay the weapons development of your adversaries by a few months you get a medal. Or maybe you don’t but one thing is for sure the state won’t collapse just because of this. What does it mean in practice. Imagine a scenairo where you left your smart phone at the side of your bed for the duration of a bathroom trip. You return and you look at your phone. Can you trust that the phone on the side of your table is the same you had earlier? It is absolutely 100% sure that the would-be-savings-scammer doesn’t have the resources to camp outside of your bedroom, monitor your comings and goings, sneak in when you leave the room, swap your phone and leave unnoticed. An operation like that costs serious money. But if a state put in their collective head that their national interest is best served by your phone being swapped then the above can and will happen. They have the resources to do it and they don’t care about “ROI” in a traditional sense. Now will a state actor sneak in to your bedroom? Probably not, because there are lower hanging fruits to achieve the same cheaper. For example by paying a batalion of nerds to find zero day exploits in complicated software. The thing about states is that they are higly uneven. One can have slow and inneficient burocracy and crumbling infrastructure and failing healthcare yet still pursue some other goal with dodged persistance. And the truth is if someone decides to spend a billion dollar to hurt you you will be hurt, if they decide to spend a billion dollar to know your secrets your secrets will be known. States can be both bumbling idiots and godlike entities at the same time, maybe even in the same building.
- rapsey 5y agoApple has the resources very few states could justify spending tax dollars to match.
- 5y ago
- honkdaddy 5y agoThe state has a monopoly on violence. The state has no legal or fiduciary obligation to play by any set of rules which other actors abide by. The state can, effectively, do anything it wills without real consequences. Individual actors don't have that power.