4 ms·
> Since then I honestly think there should be no profit in making weapons while a war is going. It is an interesting thought but ... if the government tells th
by roenxi 5y ago
> Since then I honestly think there should be no profit in making weapons while a war is going.
It is an interesting thought but ... if the government tells the industrial chain "you aren't getting paid for this" then there is a pretty high chance the war will be lost. Being optimistic, maybe it could work for one war. Then the next war people ask "where are our weapons?" and the answer is "there are none".
There is really only one solution to DC's warmongering - someone needs to be held accountable for constantly lying and sleepwalking the US into wars. And not the weapons manufacturers, the actual politicians who are pretending that they didn't realise there were billions-to-trillions being sunk into blowing up taxpayer dollars to kill random goat herders.
The public seems pretty peaceful, anti-war rhetoric has been doing well for a while. They just keep getting distracted by political issues (which are obvious distractions if you look at them in context of the US's defence & fiscal policies).
- eru 5y agoDon't they have elections for that purpose?
- hilbert42 5y agoThe should, but with modern politics such matters are only ever skirted around the edges. The real issues nearly always remain unresolved.
- jessaustin 5y ago...then there is a pretty high chance the war will be lost. That is the status quo. USA military has not won a war in my parents' lifetimes. USA military is optimized to consume resources, not to accomplish traditional military objectives.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThe first Iraq war could be considered a victory. Clear objectives, once achieved the war stopped. Bush Sr was smart enough not to expand the war although a lot of people were pushing for a march into Baghdad.
- jessaustin 5y agoThat war didn't "stop", since USA military remained in Arabia for reasons. This occupation was cited as the reason for the 9/11 attacks. So, the enlisted did their jobs but the end result makes it feel sort of weird to call this a victory.
- eru 5y agoWell, we also say that the allies won the first world war, even though many people see the harsh treatment of Germany as contributing to the second world war. (So I think that calling both of them victories is reasonable. If you want, you can also call both of them failures. But it seems a bit weird to call one a victory and the other not.)
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoHey what about Grenada? I remember this movie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbreak_Ridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heartbreak_Ridge celebrating the victory!
- jessaustin 5y agoAlso... f2r is correct as usual.
- maxbond 5y agoI don't disagree, but I think you're neglecting to consider that there is a relationship between defense contractors making money and politicians making war. Not per say causal, a more complex one than that, but incentives can align and push things into happening even in the absence of explicit quid pro quo. Eg, defense contractors can spread projects out over many states to maximize the political impact of their economic activity; politicians observe that war brings money into their state; their incentives have become more aligned, but no laws were broken or bribes exchanged. There are many ways for this to happen, and all of them occur (to some degree) simultaneously and the impact is cumulative. The result is that you cannot create a lasting solution by addressing one side of the equation or the other. You have to address them both, simultaneously, or the system will form again for exactly the reasons if formed before.
- netcan 5y agoSo first, looking at recent decades' experience doesn't seem to support a "arms profiteering = victory" correlation. Second, historically... actively curbing private profiteering has generally been considered a crucial part of a successful wartime economy. Post WWII conflicts didn't really have a "war economy" but the principle, IMO, stands.
- roenxi 5y agoThe US hasn't fought a serious war in recent decades. They've been bullying countries that practically couldn't fight back. A war against someone with an actual military (Russia, China, India) is different. There is a great argument that they shouldn't be bullying people. It is a disgrace that the people who benefit from the bullying are getting rich. The bullying doesn't make the US strong either, it probably rots the military in strange ways. But that doesn't change the basic dynamic that the people who support the US war machine need to be paid or the machine will rust and become ineffective. The old maxim "he who wants peace, prepares for war" is a good hint at what will happen if the US tries to curtail war by cutting off funding to their suppliers. Real wars will be started and the US military would lose them.
- hilbert42 5y ago"- someone needs to be held accountable for constantly lying and sleepwalking the US into wars." I'm forever whingeing on HN about this. The real problem is that much of the citizenry has lost faith and trust in its leaders and in many of its longstanding institutions and rightly so given the never-ending scandals. We need a new covenant - a formal undestanding - between the Government and the people but I, like millions of others, have little clue where to begin.
- fit2rule 5y ago