4 ms·
Thanks, that's good to toss in things like Diner's Club and Facebook, too. I find it interesting that you're bullish about the space but seem to be one of the
by acdha 5y ago
Thanks, that's good to toss in things like Diner's Club and Facebook, too.
I find it interesting that you're bullish about the space but seem to be one of the few people asking the most important question: why should anyone join? I'm a couple of years older than you and it's been really weird feeling like that's strangely absent — things like CompuServ, the web, social media, smartphones, etc. all had such clear answers for that that people would be asking for help signin up because they knew they wanted it because it'd help them do something (school, trading stocks, gaming, reaching customers, etc.) but weren't sure the best option or something like that. It's been really weird to me that the answer remains nonobvious. I'd be happy even if it was as simple as “we want to turn PayPal into a smoldering hole in the ground” because a) such a deserving company and b) anyone who hears it would know immediately whether it's something they'd like — and that means that people in the space would know they need to hit certain cost and ease of use thresholds.
- magicjosh 5y agoYeah it's a weird vibe. Imagine if in the early CompuServ days the general person knew about it and thought it was a scam only for scammers, terrorists, and creeps. As a user, I find it fun to chat with other crypto peeps about what they're doing...but talking to the outside world seems challenging. I can't really explain how "CompuServechain" isn't just a waste of time...but I'm having fun so I just keep doing that. I got a site setup on IPFS and connected to a .eth domain! Maybe the difference is now people aren't coming to you for help with crypto, whereas maybe they were with CompuServe and smartphones? So you're playing a different role. Oh you might get a kick out of this index of all decentralized ENS websites: https://esteroids.eth.limo/#/ https://esteroids.eth.limo/#/ The only requirement I know is that it's directed through a .eth, so the site itself may be boring. But most sites in the index seem to be hosted on IPFS and some even ask for a wallet to have app functions.
- kkielhofner 5y agoThere were certainly people that thought the web was only for weirdos and nerds. I got bullied in school because I was on the web and playing with computers instead of playing sports, etc. Nerds weren't always cool. Life as a nerd got much easier when the money started flowing and it was completely obvious to EVERYONE we were taking over the world. Thanks for providing the link; the popular selection[1] is most interesting. The entire space has gone so meta (a little on the nose) most don't even realize it... Imagine if all the internet offered for the first 13 years of it's life was different ways to sell you more internet. That's what the entire space looks like at this point and this link is yet another example - there are maybe three instances of destinations that I could see being even remotely useful, interesting, or usable to anyone outside of the cryptosphere. I've been really excited about the space since at least 2017. After five years without a single "I can't live without this" moment that excitement has waned significantly. [1] https://esteroids.eth.limo/#/popular https://esteroids.eth.limo/#/popular
- magicjosh 5y agoFor me that moment is ENS and IPFS which I just learned about a few months ago. I think it's so cool to have a decentralized website and URL and I never want to go back. Had used Tor addresses previously for the DNS part. I realize this may seem like moving the goalposts -- but have you thought about comparing to the development of the internet instead of web? Arpanet 1971 means 13 years in is 1984. I figure you've thought this through so will have some good points for why web/1991 is a better analogy than arpanet/1971. All the stuff you wrote here is really good. Could be a blog post instead of these more ephemeral comments.
- kkielhofner 5y agoDo you have any references for other people, articles, etc with similar questions? They seem incredibly obvious to me but it's very strange to feel so alone in what I consider to be such an obvious perspective. That's just it - people went through A LOT to get on the web in the early days but the value was so immediately compelling and obvious they considered it worth the effort. As I note in the rant corporations were snatching up their .com within a year or two. How many legit companies have their domain and presence on ENS (which itself has been around for almost five years now)?
- magicjosh 5y agoA comparison of ENS and .com seems super interesting. In another comment you mention the difficulty of comparing chains vs popularity etc. Or comparing market caps and sich is so weird, what's the "market cap" of USD? Whereas for ENS you have something real to compare to with .com, including registration data. ENS does seem to be getting some adoption mostly at an individual/celebrity level. Here's the leaderboard of top ENS users by # of Twitter followers: https://ethleaderboard.xyz/ https://ethleaderboard.xyz/ I also think the ENS community in general is curious about the questions you're asking. Fundamentally ENS/DNS is pretty boring, so it's hard to get too wildly speculative.
- kkielhofner 5y agoYou’ll note I specially avoid any of the financial aspects of blockchain (market cap, etc). I really don’t want to open that can of worms. Chains are difficult to compare popularity because of the anonymous nature and how “users” are considered. How do you translate transactions per day and active addresses into users? Almost all users have more than one address. Transfers from hot to cold storage for a single user count as a transaction and involve multiple addresses, as one example. Bitcoin is 13 years old. Ethereum is seven years old. ENS is five years old. Yet I can’t go to Toyota.eth and learn about their new models or whatever like I could with toyota.com in 1995 (18 months after the web was released). Note I use the Toyota.com example because when my sister and I first got the internet in rural Wisconsin in 1995/1996 we used to watch TV with a pencil and paper to look for the fine print at the bottom of the screen in hopes for a new web address to visit. Toyota.com was one I remember writing down (for some reason). We thought it was so neat you could see something on TV, type a few letters in the computer, and get “taken” right to it immediately. Pick a handful of $bigcorps you can think of and hit the Internet Archive Wayback Machine. You’ll find out the vast majority of the Fortune 500 had a website up at a .com within a few years (archive starts in ‘96, I believe). Not to mention the millions of users that had been building websites on geocities and elsewhere since ‘95. By 2006 the web had over 85 million websites. In 1998 (using five years of ENS) there were over 2 million (including Google). There are currently 247 thousand ENS owners. 13 year old platform. Five year old service. Once again a fraction of adoption when compared to the web over the same time span. Don’t take this the wrong way but a leaderboard of celebrities with Twitter accounts that starts with Paris Hilton isn’t going to change any minds on the credibility of the platform. Rather the opposite. Frankly anyone who thinks Paris Hilton being the leading proponent of a five year old technology platform is a good thing is either desperate or delusional. It validates the huckster hype perspective. She was on late night TV recently in a very awkward “interview” promoting NFTs. Many have commented it resembled a video one might see released by someone in a hostage situation reading a propaganda statement [1][2][3]. In any case I’d be more interested to see an analysis of those top accounts and what percentage are actively selling NFTs or any other crypto-something. I’m betting it’s extremely high. Otherwise, there's always the Fyre Fest angle where most celebrities will sell anything with no due diligence or scruples whatsoever as long as the check (in fiat, of course) clears. ENS is not boring - having an ENS address is a marketing tool to the cryptosphere for whatever you’re trying to sell them. This is one area where it’s identical to DNS. [1] https://www.dazeddigital.com/art-photography/article/55313/1/are-celebrities-getting-paid-to-shill-nfts-paris-hilton-jimmy-fallon-post-malone https://www.dazeddigital.com/art-photography/article/55313/1... [2] https://wegotthiscovered.com/news/jimmy-fallon-conflict-of-interest-bored-ape-nfts/ https://wegotthiscovered.com/news/jimmy-fallon-conflict-of-i... [3] https://www.pcgamer.com/paris-hilton-and-jimmy-fallon-showing-off-their-nfts-is-the-longest-77-seconds-ever/ https://www.pcgamer.com/paris-hilton-and-jimmy-fallon-showin...