3 ms·
Bernstein is generally careful to make only claims that he knows to be correct. Presumably Peikert will see this post and will either not respond publicly, or
by kragen 5y ago
Bernstein is generally careful to make only claims that he knows to be correct.
Presumably Peikert will see this post and will either not respond publicly, or respond. If he responds publicly he will either deny or affirm Bernstein's claims. If he does not respond, he is being consciously and deliberately deceptive. If he affirms Bernstein's claims, he was being consciously and deliberately deceptive in the past. If he denies Bernstein's claims, then either they are correct or not. If they are correct, then his denial is just more of the kind of deception Bernstein caught him at. If they are incorrect, then Bernstein is the one at fault.
- Ar-Curunir 5y agoDJB regularly makes false claims on the relevant pqc mailing list; it has at various points devolved to him making false claims about lattice-crypto security, and various cryptographers correcting him.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- matthewdgreen 5y agoFrankly Peikert shouldn't respond to such accusations. He should go to the IACR and Dan's department chair and take them up there. Most likely what he will do is continue the extensive discussion both parties have had on the PQC mailing list. But of course the general public doesn't read the PQC mailing list: where the actual experts in this area communicate. And Dan knows this. That's why he posted this set of accusations on a blog that has a general audience, knowing full well that Peikert won't be able to defend himself to the same people. When you say "If [Peikert] does not respond, he is being consciously and deliberately deceptive" you captured precisely the problem with writing this post: it makes a bunch of weak, unsupported allegations against Peikert in a forum where most readers can't judge the evidence and Peikert can't respond. It's incredibly dishonest -- and its a matter of public concern, since I believe Dan's post is consistent with a pattern of bullying and intimidation of researchers who criticize his NIST proposals on scientific grounds.
- kragen 5y agoAre you saying Peikert shouldn't respond to such accusations even if they're true? Do you think there is no legitimate public interest in whether Peikert committed plagiarism? I think there is a legitimate public interest in understanding why PQC hasn't been widely adopted.