46 ms·
USB C has a lot going for it that will hopefully make it last a bit longer. It's loaded with 24 pins, small, and reversable making it flexible in physical aspec
by zamadatix 5y ago
USB C has a lot going for it that will hopefully make it last a bit longer. It's loaded with 24 pins, small, and reversable making it flexible in physical aspects and on the protocol side it opts for a "negotiations first" mindset instead of mandating what modes made sense when it was made. Between the two of these categories the need to scrap the entire connector to do something new is much lower now.
In comparison micro-b had 4 pins, latches, and wasn't reversible. Better than before but it's easy to see why that didn't last very long! Eventually USB C will hit that point to but it's built with a bit more planning on being a "more than USB" interface in mind from the get go.
- throwaway81523 5y agoWasn't micro-B supposed to have things going for it to make it last longer than the earlier mini-B? Funny how that worked out.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoUSB3 support hacked onto the micro connectors was not so great. There is also a lot of inconsistency in the shape of the retention latches so that some cables nearly rip out the socket.
- rektide 5y agoAgreed and more. To claim we're churning through solutions is absurd, just off the wall perposterous. USB Micro was introduced in 2007, pretty much as a respin of the physical USB Mini connector- introduced in 2000. USB Micro is pretty much technology from 2000, with a couple small connector fixes. Whether we want to accept USB Micro as pretty much essentially 21 year old legal-drinking-age-in-any-country or only 14 year old tech, this connector has been around for a long long long long time, and in 2010, when it was "standardized" was a pretty obvious sensible choice with little on the horizon. The big characterization I'd make between USB Micro and USB-C (2014) is that USB Micro was designed for one specific task: connecting 5W power (expanded (unofficially?) to 11W) and USB2.0. USB-C is a much more abstract connector, with gobs of general purpose data & a huge range of power ranges. For data there's two pairs of highspeed differential lanes (so, 8 pins), plus some other lines, for power there's way more amps (5A) & scalable voltage (really scalable with USB EP's 48V) meaning tons of juice. These are all opt-in for use. There's a very flexible power delivery range, there's lanes designed for general high speed connection use not just USB. There were upfront designs for how to run multiple protocols, not just USB, over the connector. With USB4 there's packet level sharing, so net bandwidth can be shared in more interesting mixes than 50/50 or to many destinations at once. USB-C can do just about anything. We can keep changing our uses of it to do whatever. It's almost hard to imagine what else we might possibly want. Intel's mobile chip's onboard thunderbolt/USB-C ports offer 40 Gbps system-to-system connectivity, while desktops are still slowly marching towards 2.5Gbit ethernet. 10Gbit connectivity is still semi exotic to anyone but hardcore compute enthusiasts, but this connector has proven itself capable of way way more already, at a clearly mass-market price point. If there's one innovation I would like to see from USB-C and USB in general, it'd be longer connections. I'd love to see a 10Gbit USB4.x mode that works over a 6m cable, for example. I don't think the connector has much to do with the range difficulties faced by modern, high speed USB. And similarly I don't see much push to create a higher-lane count connector, but that's another possible place where USB-C proves less-than-ideal long term.
- daurnimator 5y agoAll of those usb specs are quite young and none have really lasted. Compared to other connectors that people may know: - RJ45/8P8C was standardised in 1987 - the 3.5mm audio jack in 1979 - the PCI express slot from 2003 These are all still in use today. People expect to change connectors maybe twice in a lifetime, not every decade.
- samatman 5y agoThis is a brilliant illustration of survivor bias. I sometimes wish I hadn't thinned my cable collection in the late teens, I could show you fifteen connectors which haven't lasted as long as, say, Micro-B.
- rektide 5y agoI'd love to have something new & interesting to look forward to. It'd be so neat. I really want a fast, simple, low cost, decent power alternative, that isn't a huge jumble of old legacy specs. Even USB4, which I love, still has dedicated old USB2 wires running around, because it's just too pre-modern to encapsulate adequately. This fact is a shot across your bow: even though USB-C is from 2014, it subsumes the previous connector. It's backward connectively compatible. The RJ45 & TRS jacks you cite are so primitive, so simple, so single-minded that of course they had no competition. There was so little to compete over, to adapt to, to grow into. A different implementation would have been irrelevant. Except, oh, even TRS/3.5mm audio had to evolve & grow to become TRRS, to add a mic channel: a case where even your immutable forever connectors aren't. You're right that the time-scale isn't long enough to make USB-C the obvious forever connector, that the time-scales talked so far aren't that long. But digital connective technology isn't that old. We didn't have anything before, and Micro-B basically served & would keep serving, but we want more. I feel like there's an obvious huge colossal truth batting at you & you're ignoring the enormity of how clear, deliberate, & sequential this evolution has been. The fact that USB-C emerged out of the previous connector feels to me like further evidence that this is part of one continuum, that your greivance that connectors can only change once or twice is missing the clear upfront truth of the matter. And now we're here. We spent 30 years going from crap at consumer digital systems to great, and I have a hard time seeing this as anything but the semi-final destination for us. I don't see good change as likely or probable in quite a long long long time. Perhaps lifetimes. USB-C is the final destination of mainstream computing, as far as it looks, and I merely wish it wouldn't last as many lifetimes as it seems probable to.
- riedel 5y agoAs much as I like to see standardized connectors. USB-C in particular PD is really not robust. I have multiple devices that stopped charging on PD due to broken connectors. They still charge reliably with an USB-A to USB-C cable even with quick charge. On my ThinkPad the socket is too short for most plugs, I wonder how that can happen. It will most probably be the first thing to break on the device too. I already have shaky display port connection over the connector. And now for power tools, I call this planned obsolescence...
- foxfluff 5y agoI have to agree. It seems ok for small & lightweight devices (ahem, phones..), but I would like something bigger and more rugged for larger devices. Another issue is I can't seem to find good cables. Most of the cables I have seem too big and bulky with respect to the receptacle, working as strong long levers.. I feel like I have to be extra careful around connected USB-C cables to avoid damage by knocking something. Weirdly enough the best USB-C cable I have yet is the charging cable that came with Sennheiser Momentum (3?). It's actually quite thin, flexible, and doesn't have a ton of bulk around the connector. I've used it regularly for charging my phone, headphones, and also for soldering.
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoI think we're up for a revision because it needs some kind of breakaway feature. At work we keep seeing laptops with broken ports because someone tripped over the charging USB-C cable and instead of it popping out, the lateral force just breaks the port. Now I'm super paranoid about it and miss the magsafe connector. My Air just has USB-C and I think that decision may have been a step backwards in some ways. Otherwise its excellent and probably will last a long time, but for charging laptops, its a little concerning.
- bmicraft 5y agoFor what it's worth I've broken two usb-c connectors on my laptop, one on a charger and bent one on my phone, and it's always been the cable that's given out. The ports are still like new.
- a2tech 5y agoThe new Pro's bring back the MagSafe port btw and its SO much nicer than the USB-C charger. I've just gotten in a few so far and hadn't really realized how much I missed the MagSafe charging until I got it back
- mocheeze 5y agoFYI there are magsafe-like tips/plugs that interface with USB-C. I keep meaning to research those some more.
- ksec 5y agoMagSafe USB should really be a thing. But Apple hold the patent on it which first came with MacBook Pro 2006. It will be a few more years before they expire. I do wish USB starting working on that now though.
- floatboth 5y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/UsbCHardware/comments/motlhn/magnetic_usbc_cables_are_not_recommended/ https://old.reddit.com/r/UsbCHardware/comments/motlhn/magnet...