5 ms·
This is an observation that goes back to at least Cicero.[1] Cicero on the primary goal of oratory: "As, therefore, the two principal qualities required in an
by Animats 5y ago
This is an observation that goes back to at least Cicero.[1]
Cicero on the primary goal of oratory:
"As, therefore, the two principal qualities required in an Orator, are to be neat and clear in stating the nature of his subject, and warm and forcible in moving the passions; and as he who fires and inflames his audience, will always effect more than he who can barely inform and amuse them..."
Cicero describes the problem the OP reports:
"But let us return to Calvus whom we have just mentioned,—an Orator who had received more literary improvements than Curio, and had a more accurate and delicate manner of speaking, which he conducted with great taste and elegance; but, (by being too minute and nice a critic upon himself,) while he was labouring to correct and refine his language, he suffered all the force and spirit of it to evaporate. In short, it was so exquisitely polished, as to charm the eye of every skilful observer; but it was little noticed by the common people in a crowded Forum, which is the proper theatre of Eloquence."
Nuanced communication not working at scale, 2100 years ago.
[1] https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/9776/pg9776-images.html https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/9776/pg9776-images.html
- quietbritishjim 5y agoThat's an interesting quotation, but it doesn't sound like the problem with Curio's was too much nuance. If anything, very plain (albeit clear) speech has a lack of nuance.
- Tronno 5y agoI think GP is trying to make the opposite point, that Calvus (not Curio) introduced too much nuance in his speech, making himself a less effective orator.
- def_true_false 5y agoI don't think I've seen an author's point demonstrated so neatly in the comments ever before.
- modernpink 5y agoYou've found yourself in the "95%"
- usefulcat 5y agoThat whole paragraph is almost exclusively about Calvus; Curio is only mentioned once, in passing.
- CRConrad 5y agoSo he's just a curio? (Hm, is that the etymology?)
- viksit 5y agoThis comment is truly on point and very meta — it takes a nuanced twitter thread and distills it down via the force of an authoritative source in a way that people immediately get the point.
- grafporno 5y ago> authoritative source 2000+ year old source, calling that _authoritative_ is a wild stretch
- dpeck 5y ago2000 years old and still speaking truth to our own lived experience makes it all the more authoritative.
- adolph 5y agoSurvivor bias | Authoritative
- IggleSniggle 5y agoIs that “survivor bias UNION Authoritative” or “Survivor bias PIPE Authoritative”? Even on HN, hard to know which way this comment intends to lean.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoCicero lived 2000 years ago and is still widely considered one of the greatest orators and writers of all time. For the art of rhetoric, it really doesn't get much more authoritative than that. I know the HN crowd is dismissive of old stuff, because fields like math and science advance fast enough that nobody calls (say) Pythagoras or Archimedes "authoritative", but the art of convincing other humans remains essentially the same.
- hitekker 5y agoI don't think it's HN; I think it's a few folks who never learned the value of history. Kind of like that kid in middle school who would say "all people in world history are dead, what do they matter?", "they didn't have iphones, so how smart could they be?", or "this wikipedia about logical fallacies disproves Plato".
- Vetch 5y agoI bet this objectively can't be helped. Nuance requires representing uncertainty and is higher complexity from accounting for multiple special cases. Placing more cognitive load and attentional demands on receiver. Human communication is lossy and decoding can be non-trivial inference. Given that everyone comes with differing priors, the more finer grained and complex details are required in reconstructing message intent, the more likely it is to be misconstruected. Failing to attend to a single core detail can rend meaning. At scale the chance for errors to propagate without correction increases. Getting rid of fine grained details and communicating a lower entropy message inline with a crowd's biases also ensures it's more likely to survive in a form close to original intent. A good manipulative orator focuses less on truth or content and more on minimizing mismatch between receiver mental states and orator's directional preferences.
- jychang 5y agoYou've put into text format, something which most extroverts already intuitively understand. Communicating with more than one person at a time requires dumbed down slogans and short bits of summarized information. Nuanced long form communication is a luxury that can rarely be afforded.
- pg_1234 5y agoMuch of Shakespeare's genius was to pitch his work simultaneously for multiple levels of sophistication ... social commentary, poetry and fart humour, all at the same time.
- mettamage 5y agoYou made quite a nuanced and elaborate point. I guess it scales on text with a specific crowd (HN).
- neilparikh 5y agoIt works here because their point about having differing priors. On HN, people largely have similar priors (at least on some axes).
- 5y ago
- scrubs 5y agoHN has been on fire this week -- in the good way! And this whole post and quote throws another log on it.
- throwawayarnty 5y agoThere is something wonderfully persuasive when someone can connect a modern topic to one that has already been addressed by the ancients. It feels as if the topic, once thought unwieldy and complicated, becomes tractable and clear. Perhaps the way to handle complicated nuances situations in life is to connect them to a classic problem. I feel this strategy also works in mathematical fields.
- marcellus777 5y agoThe reference book here is a collection of dialogs made by Cicero where he argues that there are two types of oratory: the short, "elegant", straight to the point one and the profuse, "appealing", heart touching one. Cicero himself says (in that book) he is in favor the latter. The book is not about nuance, but rather discourse style. In his (Cicero's) view, the better oratory style is the one that touches the audience as opposed to carefully chosen words. Based on the book, IMO, Cicero is more focused on arguing in favor of passionate speeches than nuance per se. PS. I believe the quotes used are a bit misleading because they are used as counterexamples in the original text.
- orbifold 5y agoOne of my favourite memories from school was translating parts of Cicero's words from latin. He is considered "easy" to read and translate precisely because he took great care of not using difficult or ambiguous language in his writing as well.