11 ms·
In quieter corners DAOs are forging a new ecosystem for digital startups
- mupuff1234 5y agoSounds like the main thing they're selling is exclusivity.
- vmception 5y agoExclusivity Entertainment Community And a fungible bearer asset that neither company shares or a PostGresQL spreadsheet could accomplish
- tough 5y agoI do believe DAO's are one of the best parts of crypto so far...
- arcticbull 5y agoConstitutionDAO was literally a kickstarter. They handed out tokens that gave you no rights, no ownership, no voting - no nothing. Just tokens of appreciation. The people who collected the crypto deposits would have been the sole beneficial owners the constitution. Just a donation. Any DAO that wants to do anything of any meaningful complexity ends up registering as a Wyoming entity which isn't really any different than an LLC. DAOs are an attempt to separate the crypto nouveau riche from their tokens. You can achieve anything you want to from a DAO with a corporation plus a twitter poll or SurveyMonkey thing - except the issuance of unregistered blue-sky securities. Anyways, what's going to get really interesting is when we inevitably have see some legal challenges around this. I strongly suspect we'll see some personal liability materialize and this is going to take a lot of the fun out of this new grift.
- halpert 5y ago> You can achieve anything you want to from a DAO with a corporation plus a twitter poll or SurveyMonkey thing. How would accept money from thousands of people without being public? How would those ownership stakes be easily transferred?
- arcticbull 5y agoDAO tokens do not convey ownership, so, a kickstarter campaign. If DAO tokens do convey some ownership interest, then they'd have to be registered as securities - which is why DAOs are very clear that you get nothing but their appreciation in exchange for the tokens. In which case you'd sell them the same way you sell any other securities. Reg A+ and Reg CF allow the sale of equity for crowdfunding contributions, btw. There are even some marketplaces that sprung up around them.
- berberous 5y agoYou are speaking categorically when that is not the case. If a DAO token is a security, it does need to be registered: it either needs to be registered or have available an exemption from registration. There are DAOs that try to fit within an exemption from registration. See the LAO, and it's offshoots, like Red DAO, Flamingo DAO, etc., which sell LLC interests to a limited number of accredited investors. [0] https://medium.com/openlawofficial/the-lao-a-for-profit-limited-liability-autonomous-organization-9eae89c9669c https://medium.com/openlawofficial/the-lao-a-for-profit-limi... [1] https://www.flamingodao.xyz/ https://www.flamingodao.xyz/
- arcticbull 5y ago> There are DAOs that try to fit within an exemption from registration. See the LAO, and it's offshoots, like Red DAO, Flamingo DAO, etc., which sell LLC interests to a limited number of accredited investors. Ok, but that's just an LLC with extra steps no? If you're only accepting accredited investors then you're required to validate that they are accredited meaning that you have to pierce the veil of anonymity. It imposes legal control over the transfer of these tokens which means there's no reason whatsoever for them to be decentralized, permissionless and on the blockchain? Accredited investors were always welcome to buy whatever toxic garbage they wanted.
- berberous 5y agoThis comment is no different than the following infamous comments 1. “No wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame”; from Slashdot, dismissing the new Apple iPod. 2. "For a Linux user, you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. From Windows or Mac, this FTP account could be accessed through built-in software"; from HN, on the launch of Dropbox. Yes, DAOs may be similar to corporations mixed with a SuveyMoney, and the above comments also have some truth to them. But all three entirely miss the forest for the trees, and miss that there are qualitative changes that make the impact of the new version much greater. DAOs allow a disparate group of people to raise capital and execute towards a shared idea far faster and greater than was previously possible. That is a qualitative difference worth paying attention to. And while you are correct that the legal frameworks backing DAOs currently have many problems, that is something that will change. And for the HN skeptics, over 1,000 YC founders disagree with you: https://techcrunch.com/2022/01/24/hundreds-of-y-combinator-alumni-join-crypto-collective-to-back-web3-startups/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/01/24/hundreds-of-y-combinator-a...
- arcticbull 5y agoSelling unregistered securities is not a new concept lol. It went unbelievably poorly last time we tried it which is why we stopped. It was a major contributor to the Great Depression. So my question to you is: what has changed since last time we tried this? Why am I to believe that "this time is different." [edit] Your suggestion that an idea cannot possibly be bad because 1000 startups are chasing it holds no water, it's an appeal to authority. Worse than appeal to authority: it's an appeal to the wisdom of crowds. Crowds of course are notorious for making great decisions. Hundreds of thousands of individual investors thought that sub-prime mortgage backed securities were a brilliant plan.
- berberous 5y agoI don't see this conversation going anywhere productive, but do you not think anything has changed since the Great Depression? Your arguments can (and have been) those that applied to Uber or AirBnB; namely, that the only value they had was in skirting regulations, and that eventually the regulations catch up such that Uber or AirBnB is no better than the predecessor taxi and hotel industries. And I think there is certainly a lot of truth to that, but I also think this is normal human progress. As times change, we try something slightly different, and where old pain points arise again, we re-regulate accordingly. You are left with something that is indeed quite similar to the older industry, but with a fresh coat of pain and some improvements. You can dismiss that as entirely worthless, but I see it as normal and part of progress: two steps forward, one step back. Similarly, I think having financial regulations that were created in 1933 be static forever is a mistake. As technology progresses, there can be room for changes. So I see DAOs and crypto in a similar light: yes, certain actors violate existing laws, but there is a freedom to explore a new design space, and then the regulators will catch up and reign it back to something more reasonable. As for my link to OrangeDAO, it is not about 1,000 YC founders with Web3 startups, but 1,000 YC founders that are members of a DAO that seeks to invest and help other Web3 startups. As for what's different, my answer would be scale. DAOs make it easier to coordinate large groups of people. Take a look at what OrangeDAO seeks to fund: https://orangedao.notion.site/0516999b88534575bf759323f5e9fe81?v=89f6de7f9d3c4b7f97859da4890adfa3 https://orangedao.notion.site/0516999b88534575bf759323f5e9fe... Many of them are targeted towards corporate infrastructure; replacing traditional processes with software-first functions, which allow a lot of disparate people to function together more easily, and reduces the friction of "a group of people working together towards a common goal" from that of an existing corporation.
- ShamelessC 5y agoApparently many ConstitutionDAO participants have been screwed because in order to get their money back they've had to pay transaction fees which exceed 200$. Quite the racket.
- leppr 5y agoThese transaction fees are determined dynamically by the Ethereum network depending on network usage, and given to Ethereum miners, not the particular dApp with which one interacts or their developers. Anyone using ETH would presumably have been aware about the enormous fees involved.
- ShamelessC 5y agoThat doesn't make it any less absurd/off-putting.
- gjs278 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smorgusofborg 5y agoI think this potential conflict of interest for miners to push DAOs and then maybe for raised beurocracy in a DAO for more gas money and questions of whether a seller in some of these auctions realizes they should become a large holder in DAOs that might bid 100X the valuation of their asset are the kinds of conflicting interests that make this kind of system less practical than a legacy system where the structure for regulators to subpoena whatever they need is part of the licensing, etc.
- leppr 5y agoA racket implies intentional malicious activity, which is the accusation I'm clearing up here.
- mountainriver 5y agoYeah I agree, overall I’m bearish on crypto, but DOAs are a really interesting idea. Transparency is the next fight for the workers and ideas like this could prove very valuable
- cuteboy19 5y agoMost DAOs are indeed DOA
- dang 5y agoAll: if commenting here, please respond to specific information in the article and avoid the generic yay and boo comments that have appeared here countless times already. They are boring. Curiosity withers under repetition: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=%22curiosity%20withers%20under%20repetition%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... Diffs are what's interesting: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=curiosity%20diffs%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Animats 5y ago
- notpachet 5y agoFor people with skin in the game (read: all of us) -- it pays to be students of history. There is a rich tapestry of prior art available for us to study that can help us define the appropriate relationship between the public, with the government as our agent, and aggregations of capital as expressed through crypto. In particular I recommend reading about the early federal efforts to safeguard the public interest from rampant capitalistic excesses in the form of the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887, and its immediate fruits (the Sherman Act, etc). Those efforts were largely focused on antitrust regulation, which is a different problem than the sorts of blue-sky securities problems that are more common in today's crypto space. But the reason I'm recommending reading about the earlier antitrust stuff, as opposed to the securities regulations that began to emerge a few decades later (which is more superficially topical), is that it marked the beginning of a phase transition in how the American public viewed the relationship between government and business. I think we're in the early part of another such phase transition today. Without the antitrust regulations that preceded them, subsequent securities regulations would likely have had a much steeper hill to climb in the court of public opinion. Obviously we aren't going to be able to just copy+paste yesterday's regulations onto every newly emerging trend. But I think we can definitely draw lessons from how earlier types of regulations emerged and the ways that the government's relationship with capital interests was adjusted over time. There were also downsides to the new regulations (like the coopting of the definition of "trust" to include unions as a means of curtailing the power of labor). Those are valuable lessons, too. I say this as someone who is relatively pessimistic about the value that these new crypto constructs are going to be able to provide over the long term, but I'd make the same argument to crypto optimists, as well. Apologies to the non-US folks; other countries have their own regulatory histories, some of which were well ahead of the times compared to America. But I'm less familiar with those.
- toolz 5y agoThese kinds of recommendations and thoughts are extremely important moving forward. I do not believe the agency of government will be able to keep up with the speed of progress and it will become increasingly important for us to take lessons learned throughout history and apply them at an individual level. I'm very biased towards crypto as I see the increasing failures of government action leading to massive wealth inequality. If you have any specific resources you'd recommend on reading up on the commerce clause I'd be interested in reading up on them. My bias is unlikely to reveal anything favorable of the for that act, as I'm already quite averse to the overreach the government has taken with that policy used as its launching point.
- freemint 5y agoDAOs are unable to perform any interesting calculation due to excessive cost of computation. It can't even solve a Linear Program to distribute resources effectiently (let alone actual scheduling which requires mixed integer problems which often take many core hours on actual CPUs). Any function a DAO can perform a notary can perform cheaper, including running votes.
- bsedlm 5y ago> Any function a DAO can perform a notary can perform cheaper, including running votes. However the DAO can the notary's job more transparently and without corruption (real oversight of their activities is cheaper... heck, it's possible)
- rmbyrro 5y agoA notary can be bribed. You can theoretically corrupt a blockchain, but it's harder than one notary. Aside, notaries where I come from are extremely expensive and inefficient. I'd choose a blockchain in a split second if I could, for anything requiring human notaries now.
- bsedlm 5y agoI agree with this statement, people downvoting parent are almost certainly living in not-very corrupt countries.
- danvayn 5y agoNot to mention that the blockchain we're talking about is supposed to get a lot more performant very soon.
- FridgeSeal 5y ago“It’ll be better soon! Just as soon as <x> gets implemented! Just you wait and see!” We’ve been hearing this for basically as long as cryptocurrencies have been around. I suspect we will see a currency that can do decent throughput, but I think it will require advances in the underlying theory for that to happen and that’s a few years away.
- qeternity 5y ago
- tedunangst 5y agoUh, well, the ... that you elided provides the context for the slips of paper analogy. The article is not literally calling them slips of paper. > The community holds internal discussions and then votes on decisions using the token, on apps such as Snapshot, the way one might slip a piece of paper into a cardboard box to elect a class president.
- qeternity 5y agoThis is literally what shareholders do. It doesn’t make the analogy any less stupid. I don’t care what they call them. That’s not my issue. My issue is pretending like this mechanism is new and hasn’t existed for centuries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seibelj 5y agoA lot of friction, paperwork, time, lawyers involved. You can use a boilerplate DAO and raise millions because of a meme that takes off, and the shareholders are liquid immediately. For good or bad you must admit this is novel.
- thawaya3113 5y agoYou can do exactly the same thing without regulation. Regulation exists because the alternative is what’s happening. More than half of these are scams where people are running with the money. And the majority of the rest are people buying a copy of Dune thinking they now own the rights to it.
- seibelj 5y agoDo you have any statistics to back up your claims of “more than half”? It just sounds like baseless attacks and dang said to be productive in this convo.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thawaya3113 5y ago
- dang 5y agoPlease avoid generic comments like this. We've had the generic flamewar about this stuff countless times already.
- orzig 5y agoI read the article twice: what are the quieter corners the headline promises? Almost all the examples were still pooling money to buy a thing, with two of those things being a single piece of real estate. And Friends with Benefits seems like a nice social group. Both great for those involved, but hardly a revolution I am very interested in alternative coordination mechanisms, so I was really looking forward to the practical applications of the DAO mechanism outside of crypto-for-crypto, but still am not really seeing it. What am I missing?
- magicjosh 5y agohaha now that you pointed it out, "quiet corners" are in the sub-headline and opening but...not the article itself. Most of the examples are loud -- like SPICE and Constitution. I too am interested in alternative coordination mechanisms. I recommend hopping on the discord channels for these different projects and seeing what you can find. I've personally looked at Constitution, SPICE, and ENS. I would recommend diving into ENS, it's credible and they're working to manage development and budget. Journalists simply don't have the tools or support to dig into the level of detail that you probably want. There's also some group in Colorado I forget the name of, they weren't in the article though. They bought up an acre of land and are trying to manage it as a group? Let me know what you find!
- dmitriid 5y ago>I recommend hopping on the discord channels for these different projects Yup. "Just do your reasearch". "Just hop onto the literally thousands of Discord channels inundated by random talk and you will definitely see the light!" You'd think that by this time there would be something coherent coming out of these Discords, but no. > Let me know what you find! You're the one suggesting to dive in and finding something. You've also said you've already dived in. Apparently, you've found nothing.
- magicjosh 5y agoWow who peed in your coffee? The parent said they were interested in alternative coordination mechanisms. I pointed them to where to find more and how to approach it. This is how curiosity works. I'm not selling any "light". There's little glimmers spread across lots of projects, even the ones that completely fail or grapple with seemingly small issues. ENS just turned the management of 300,000+ name service records over to a DAO. Now they are grappling with how to update registration prices when domains expire. They have a delegate and voting system for decision making. Registration on expiry prices for ENS itself is pretty boring so reading more about this is likely only interesting to someone curious about alternative coordination mechanisms.
- 01acheru 5y agoI wanted to build a joke NFT project with some friends, just to take a closer look at crypto since I never developed on it. I need to say that there is some solid tech in that space but there are still some fundamental problems to be solved, structural problems, and I'm not seeing a solution. But we are not here to talk about it... Reading about DAOs is funny because I really understand them now, after talking with those friends of mine who know nothing about tech and should have handled other parts of the project. I understand their meaning: 99% of the time they are a clever way of fooling people. There is a lot of enthusiasm around crypto lately and some smart people, overhearing a lot of stuff (and fluff) they don't understand simply try to jump into the bandwagon. They are smart people in their lives but without tech knowledge they become the bigger fools when entering the crypto sphere. But when you fool a smart person he will try to fall on his feet, he will never admit he got fooled so now he needs to fool someone else so to exit the game with lesser losses, or even gains if he's really smart... it's a weird variant of a Ponzi scheme and also an incredible social experiment. My two cents. edit: some language errors
- tata71 5y agoReplace "DAOs" with "companies", and "crypto" with "startups".
- ytpete 5y agoOne big difference is that your random uncle or sister-in-law can't just read about some trending startup and then semi-blindly invest a chunk of their life savings into it. Financial regulations prevent the average nonexpert from making those kinds of risky investments in relatively unregulated companies - you have to qualify as an "accredited investor" (i.e. either someone with deep pockets or expertise in financial markets). Publicly traded companies and investment funds are open to anyone, but in exchange they're subject to all sorts of regulations about transparency and accounting rules to make it "safer" for the average Joe to invest in. DAOs feel like they are really hoping to create an end run around all those financial protection laws.
- 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoThe best thing about these are the rapid iterations towards something better for all participants. Many of these DAOs have components to them that people now understand werent good to participate in, and people are more discerning towards certain behaviors and features. For example, rebasing with high APYs should be for entertainment purposes only. But DAOs dont need that, and many just advertising liquidity bootstrapping events, without the rebasing component now. While the protocol-owned-liquidity desire and implementation stays. People find it much better to trade liquidity for discounted tokens, than to risk having an illiquid asset, or find it better than renting liquidity with farming. These evolutions occur in weeks and are immediately applicable each time.
- iskander 5y agoDAOs are a bit fluid, even evasive, in definition but there are plenty out there (e.g. VitaDAO) which essentially function as an alternative organizational structure to traditional corporations. To function outside the crypto space (or really legally at all), they have to at least create shell LLCs which are governed by DAO decisions. Very few DAOs seem to get that far and instead choose to operate in the greyzone. As the space matures, I think we'll start to see a few large corporations which use on-chain voting in place of shareholding meetings. Whether this will otherwise cause any meaningful differences in how companies operate remains to be seen.
- magicjosh 5y agoThanks that's helpful context. So what you're saying is ultimately DAOs are about governance of traditional entities. So if there isn't a traditional entity at the top yet, it needs to be on the roadmap or the whole thing is a bunch of puffery. I've seen a bunch of DAO concepts that are fundamentally "hey let's make currencies and securities". It's like "uh, remember all the ICO stuff? that didn't work". Excited to see examples of DAOs that do connect to augment traditional governance structures.
- iskander 5y agoI think a few DAOs are so divorced from physical concerns that they can remain on the internet and direct resources there without needing a corporate shell. But, as soon as money flows into the real world, they will need to figure out how to create and interface with traditional entities, or...like you said, it's very ICO-like.
- brightstep 5y agoWhy would a large corporation replace a shareholder meeting with a public on-chain vote? What is the incentive, what is the benefit to them?
- iskander 5y agoIt's not just the voting mechanism, it's also the crowd-raised treasury and culture of dev-centric leadership and internet community governance. People seem to like pooling money in this way, even if it seems silly you probably can't stop them from wedding this model to LLCs and stepping more solidly into the legal framework of corporations.
- magicjosh 5y agoI'm hungry for more analysis of DAOs. This article covers a nice set of ones including a few I hadn't heard of. For anyone who gets interested in one of these concepts, I recommend finding the group's Discord and popping in to ask a few questions yourself. However the depth of the article wasn't satisfying. Regarding SPICE DAO: > "The group’s plan was to produce its own version of the film, with creative decisions voted on by the token’s holders." From having dug into the SPICE DAO's Discord, I'm surprised this is what the journalist led with. It's an intellectually dishonest take on what the group was trying to do. Having poked around a bit, the people leading the DAO clearly understand intellectual property and were buying the book as something of a parallel project to getting licenses. But there seems to be a big push to paint them as complete idiots. Not sure why though. Maybe they are complete idiots, but not from what I've seen. From my limited experiences with DAOs, they're not a magical solution to anything, and it will take time to figure out exactly what they're useful for. Nonprofits, hackerspaces, and corporations are all entities that work on mass coordination of incentives, resources, and labor. It's all hard work. DAOs may offer a new toolkit for this type of coordination, but they're unlikely to be a panacea. I am deeply curious to learn which problems this toolkit turns out to solve. Edit: oh check out Orange DAO, mentioned elsewhere in this thread
- dmitriid 5y ago> For anyone who gets interested in one of these concepts, I recommend finding the group's Discord and popping in to ask a few questions yourself. Yup. "Just join the thousands of Discord channels". How about: these scams and borderline scams actually produce some coherent information and put it up on their sites, and not expect every person to seek out their Discord channels and ask them questions? > But there seems to be a big push to paint them as complete idiots. Not sure why though. Because of what they actually do and say outside the Discords. If they weren't idiots, they would actually have a proper explanation of what it is they are trying to do, and actual roadmap on how to get there, and why they needed to blow 3 million dollars on a book if they want to "produce an original series". > oh check out Orange DAO, mentioned elsewhere in this thread And how exactly do you propose we check it out? You mean "Orange Protocol" which is a centralised aggregation service that pinky swears it will run a DAO at some unspecified point in the future?
- Brajeshwar 5y agoWell, I stumbled and saw a few social impact DAO. I like them and so invested very tiny amounts to just be part of them. Then, I introduced the story to my team for an initiative that we were planning. We want it to be a DAO to get others involved, and make it socially viable. We are pretty technical but not DAO technical. Unfortunately, no one came, including those who came to me and I invested in them. Now, I’m not sure if it makes sense to try to bridge the physical world happening to a digital heavy concept of DAO. We just wanted to plant trees, lots of trees (not guns) - https://treeslotsoftrees.org https://treeslotsoftrees.org
- dmitriid 5y agoYou need neither a DAO nor a blockchain to "crowdfund planting of trees with accountability and trust" It's also incredibly funny how you pretend to care about trees and ecology ... and using the single most ecology unfriendly tech on earth.
- 01acheru 5y agoThat's a beautiful initiative and you seem a nice person, could you explain why it needs to be a DAO? I read all your site twice and I cannot find anything that make it necessary for your org to be a DAO. What technical aspects of a DAO are necessary and why couldn't it simply be a non profit with a "donate here" and a "subscribe for a fee" and whatever else? Are you running all your logic on chain o it is mostly off chain? Thanks :)
- Brajeshwar 5y agoWe have a broader idea brewing. So, the answer below will touch that and I’m sorry for not just focusing on just the tree planting part. This is a draft and please treat it as such. The final will make it to the site’s FAQ soon. Here is the list of reasons we are doing a DAO as opposed to a traditional donation model: - Easier data sharing among organizations. - Secure and auditable transactions enabling verifiable and trusted logs of transaction (monetary, carbon credits, monitoring events, donations). - Decreased inefficiency for currency exchange rate and cross border transaction costs. - Support for NFT and automatic calculation of carbon dividend. - Easier reporting and analysis. - Transparency in operations (which portion is going to what organization and for what reason). - Platform of choice for next generation of climate change advocates and supporters. - Smart contracts enabling decentralized calculation of carbon offset for many daily activities (offset your emissions by planting and monitoring trees. - Crypto mining is a great source of emissions, its way easier to plug our DAO into the existing networks to calculate and offset transaction emissions in a user friendly way. - Blockchain allows for more secure anonymous donations which can be essential for some contributors.
- woleium 5y agohttps://archive.fo/qQLrj https://archive.fo/qQLrj
- hi5eyes 5y agodaos: under the table trading of whitelist, presale allocations for their governance token/raise friesdao team make up: a coinbase employee, fast food franchise operators, registering in wyoming and reviewed by the dev of vfattools