3 ms·
"The production intent Gemini battery will be LFP (Lithium Iron Phosphate)" But the demo battery is not. It's something else. What? Why do these people think
by Animats 5y ago
"The production intent Gemini battery will be LFP (Lithium Iron Phosphate)"
But the demo battery is not. It's something else. What?
Why do these people think they can get that kind of energy density from lithium iron phosphate when nobody else can? BYD, which really likes that technology, has pushed the energy density per unit volume up by about 2X, but the resulting battery is denser and thus heavier. No problem for fixed installations, but mediocre for vehicle range.
There's a lot to be said for using lithium iron phosphate chemistry. The batteries don't blow up. They don't have the negative temperature coefficient which causes thermal runaway. They survive the "nail test". As electric cars go mainstream, and we have tens of millions of under-maintained cars on the road, we need all that.
So, is this for real, or a demo only?
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, that was exactly what I thought. If they have twice the energy density that applies to much more than just vehicles. For now I'm chalking this up to a fake, let's see if they get their 'production sample' up and running. I would not put money on it.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Why do these people think they can get that kind of energy density from lithium iron phosphate when nobody else can? Other people can, but not within the same safety, regulatory, longevity, cooling, weight, and manufacturability constraints. Which is why this demo is useless. It's easy to make one-off prototypes that accomplish something impressive as long as it only has to work a couple times, doesn't have to comply with safety regulations, and you have a massive budget to hand-build a couple of them. It's a different story entirely to try to ship it.
- jacquesm 5y agoEven that isn't all that easy. The energy density constraints are fairly hard on these. I suspect that they are doing something a lot more directly nasty than that: not rechargeable, or, entirely different chemistry.
- fwipsy 5y agoLooking at the marketing materials, it seems like it's just poorly explained, not a scam attempt. It's actually two batteries. The first is LFP which has poor energy density but wears slowly and so is used for daily trips, providing about 150 miles of capacity. The rest of the range is made up by the second "range extender" battery, which seems to contain their secret-sauce chemistry. The range extender only needs to survive relatively few cycles because most people aren't driving 700 miles very frequently.
- bcrl 5y agoThere have been demonstrations of using non-rechargeable aluminium-air batteries for that purpose which would have to be returned to a smelter to be "recharged". Sadly, only prototypes.