3 ms·
As an American, even the poorest have other options besides working in fields. If you told an Amazon warehouse worker that they could make $36 an hour to work
by scarface74 5y ago
As an American, even the poorest have other options besides working in fields. If you told an Amazon warehouse worker that they could make $36 an hour to work in a field instead of $18/hour ho work in a warehouse, how many would take them up on the offer?
- naasking 5y agoNot sure, but it's not zero.
- scarface74 5y agoThey had plenty of stories where field owners couldn’t find Americans who would stick to the work for more than week. Would you work in the field for twice your current pay? If I had a choice between living by myself and making $36/hour working in a field and getting a roommate and working in a warehouse (or an Amazon delivery driver), guess which one I would choose?
- naasking 5y ago> They had plenty of stories where field owners couldn’t find Americans who would stick to the work for more than week. Sure, because the pay or other benefits weren't good enough. There are sometimes other considerations as well, like that some of this work is temporary/seasonal and people want something steady. > If I had a choice between living by myself and making $36/hour working in a field and getting a roommate and working in a warehouse (or an Amazon delivery driver), guess which one I would choose? That's a weird question. You could easily keep working in that field and still get a roommate and you'd get to keep even more money.
- scarface74 5y agoThat’s not the point. Once you have “enough” to meet your basic life needs - food, shelter, transportation - then you start making other choices. I am sure I could give up my big house in the burbs and my wife and I could stay with another couple. But do you think I would make that choice? On another related note, you saw the same thing with school bus drivers after Covid (my wife was one). No amount of money in the world was going to convince many bus drivers who didn’t really need the extra money to risk Covid to drive the bus. Many of them were just doing it for extra money. Anyone could have more money saved if they found a roommate. But at some point we decide it’s not worth the trade off.
- notch656a 5y agoA shit ton. I worked up in the Alaskan fishing industry for a short period. About half the people there were white citizens. It is much worse than the field. You are stuck in a ship, in the Bering Sea (one of the most dangerous and nastiest coastal areas in the US), working 16+ hours a day under the worst conditions imaginable. Imagine being deathly sea sick while holding a knife in your hand, rocking violently from side to side. You're literally trapped, stuck with horrible smell of fish, horribly ill and worked to the bone with no escape and the boss will probably kick your ass if you bail while out at sea. The upside of that 36/hr is many people were able to either take much of the year off or provide lavishly for their families when otherwise their children would have much fewer opportunities. It's not even a question whether many would take it, it's a certainty.
- scarface74 5y agoSo how many farmers could afford to pay enough to field laborers to provide “lavishly” for their family and still be competitive in the global market? And the fishing industry is highly subsidized https://www.lenfestocean.org/~/media/legacy/lenfest/pdfs/subsidies_rsr_final.pdf https://www.lenfestocean.org/~/media/legacy/lenfest/pdfs/sub...
- notch656a 5y ago$36/hr was your example, not mine. You gave the example and apparently now you are debating yourself. If your point is the industry (fishing) is subsidized, well farming also is highly subsidized.
- scarface74 5y agoYes farming is heavily subsidized and they still don’t have high margins. How will they afford to pay enough to compete with much easier year round warehouse jobs with benefits that are much easier. It’s not like people in Alaska have too many choices and the relatively few fisherman pales in comparison to the number of farm workers needed. Besides, Americans are already whining about inflation. Guess what would happen if food labor costs went up 5x?