4 ms·
Here in the US, there exists a Duopoly that collectively support each other in excluding any other views by focusing on a series of "wedge issues" that generate
by mikewarot 5y ago
Here in the US, there exists a Duopoly that collectively support each other in excluding any other views by focusing on a series of "wedge issues" that generate a lot of emotional heat, where reality demands thought and nuance and compromise, but the extremists can dissipate emotions and distract.
The RepubliCratic cancer needs to go, but I doubt it will.
Why? It actively votes against the will of the population, in service of the wealthy donors who fund their reelection campaigns.
- BobbyJo 5y agoWhat if this is reflective of common ideology? What if most people agree on most things somewhere near a center (with some fluctuation) and the wedge issues are the rare points of hard, uncompromising disagreement. Wouldn't that eventually lead to the duopoly we see? Wouldn't that be the best case scenario?
- mikewarot 5y agoNo, it's the worst possible outcome, it is totally obstructive to the will of the people, and appears to be exclusively in service to the donor class who fund their reelection efforts.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoSo then the problem is the existence of the donor class. Perhaps we ought to curtail their power. Or their existence, I’m open to either.
- acomar 5y agofrom where does the donor class derive their wealth? they pay you a wage or collect rent, profiting either way. in all cases, they derive their wealth because they own the things that allow us to produce value. perhaps those things should be commonly owned instead. then these class distinctions would evaporate.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt has been tried and has failed. Communism doesn't work on a scale larger than a few hundred people (top end)
- sudosysgen 5y agoCentrally planned economies (what is commonly called communism) is not the only solution that fits the above description. Cooperative market economics does the same, so would a partial land decommodification or a land value tax combined to a steep progressive tax rate combined to considering collaterilization as a partial realization of gain, etc...
- BobbyJo 5y agoAnyone who works in software can attest to the fact that 'common ownership' inevitably leads to 'zero ownership'.
- ss108 5y agoWhat? Wedge issues are what the people unfortunately want. It gets them jazzed up even though these are not the most impactful issues for most people's lives. While blame should be placed on politicians who use such issues to drive votes instead of tackling bigger, more boring challenges, we also have to fault the populace for being easily distracted, emotive, etc.
- mikewarot 5y agoWedge issues are not what people want... they want to live their lives Wedge issues are what make them angry, or scared enough to post on social media, etc. It collectively is a dark pattern that subverts our tendency to fix broken things by making us believe that everything is broken.
- ss108 5y ago? People really care about abortion, for example, but it's really just a wedge issue. Wedge issues are bad overall for society, but they are not anyone's "fault" except for society. What you're arguing connotes to me that people are victims of some kind, but the fact is the "dark pattern" works because people care about that stuff. I think they are logically incorrect for assigning these issues disproportionate weight, but like...they're free to lol, and it's not inherently invalid. But then, take something like abortion. Some people really feel strongly about that issue (on both sides of the political spectrum). There are people who do vote based on that single issue alone. They are free voters who have constructed their moral/political rubric or w/e, and have elected to accord that single issue decisive importance in their political decisions. That would seem to me to be a feature, not a bug, of democracy.
- BobbyJo 5y agoWhat will is it obstructing? The will of the far left? Yeah. The will of the far right? Yeah. The will of the 90% that just want to live their life in peace? No. If you think the government should protect people and infrastructure so that they can exchange goods and services according to a common understanding of private property, then today's government likely isn't too far from what you'd like, and, therefore, the tension holding things over center is a blessing.
- mikewarot 5y agoInfrastructure is one of the things that goes wanting for funding, while almost a trillion dollars/year goes into the Military Industrial Complex. The results of that diversion can be seen all over the country as things literally collapse, or fall apart. Programs that are popular with the people consistently go to die in Congress.
- rjbwork 5y agoNo. It will lead to a terrible Nash equilibrium as far towards the donor class's interests as possible while still giving the voters the illusion of choice and enough of a quorum to provide airs of legitimacy.
- BobbyJo 5y agoWhat's the alternative? Resources, in a very direct, physical, way afford one power. As soon as you allow unequal distribution of resources, you create unequal power. The fact that the 'donor class' are put on a leash to the degree that most demand be done means things are working well no?
- newbie789 5y ago
- pessimizer 5y agoIt does reflect the common ideology of the people who donate to parties. The wedge issues are the ones that donors don't care about, except that they boost support for both major parties by threatening doom as a result of defection. All this with the support of a media that almost exclusively covers wedge issues, and ignores bipartisan screwjobs.
- mistermann 5y ago> where reality demands thought and nuance and compromise, but the extremists can dissipate emotions and distract. Extremists do indeed do this, and surely do it more than others...but I think we should always be very careful of the mind's tendency to convert positions on a spectrum into a binary representation. A pattern that I propose can be observed on all social media including HN: if an article takes an abstract perspective upon politics (or any culture war topic), most people are pretty good at nuance and compromise....but if an article is discussing a specific, object level issue, it seems like the aggregate ability of commenters to discuss matters in a nuanced, non-biased manner massively decreases. If for the sake of discussion we assume this theory to have a non-trivial amount of truth to it, it seems to me that it would be useful to come up with some theories of how this phenomenon could be detected and managed, or perhaps even reversed through collective effort (leveraging the innately unique differing perspective of members, combined with our ability to be self-aware and highly logical if that state of mind can be achieved (which I believe could be achieved through an explicit process/reminders/etc)). Alternatively, humanity can continue doing exactly the same thing we are doing now, one aspect of which is using social media only for entertainment, suppressing discussion about using it to improve ourselves and the world, etc.
- scarface74 5y agoThe policies put in place aren’t there because of the “wealthy donors”. The “wealthy donors” don’t care about the “War on Crime”, “War on Drugs”, “Pro-Life”/“Pro-Choice” debates, the lack of accountability for the corrupt justice system, “voter integrity” [sic], “protecting the borders”, etc. All of those issues have one thing in common, it’s about keeping “them” in their place. Yes I’m aware that the “War on Crime” and the “War on Drugs” was perpetrated by the Democratic and Republican Administrations in the 90s.
- eanc 5y ago
- croon 5y agoOne party is responsible for the Citizens United vs FEC ruling. One party repeatedly blocks voting rights bills. One party closes poll locations, gerrymanders and makes it harder to register and get ID's. A two party duopoly is bad. But there's clearly a choice one could make between the two.