11 ms·
Treasury reconsiders IRS’s use of ID.me face recognition for web
- Klonoar 5y agoHere's a novel idea: don't remove the existing email/password/secure-image combo. It works fine. You can search for something more secure, sure - but don't break the damn system for the millions of people who need it and refuse to deal with ID.me.
- throwawaysea 5y agoAbsolutely. Email, password, secure image, 2FA seems more than good enough. It already is for everyone else in my online life like banks, medical services, and so on. Why wouldn’t it be for government services? Given that ID.me is located in the DC area, it seems a lot like this was forced through due to shady dealing.
- tims33 5y agoTotally agree. Makes me wonder what sort of back room dealing went on to select ID.me.
- SN76477 5y agoThis sounds good to me. So much of this sounds like another overengineered solution to a problem that shouldn't exist.
- hanniabu 5y agoSounds more like data mining and getting friendly companies nice contracts to me
- genewitch 5y agoSounds like another cut of the >$1,800,000,000 IT budget of the IRS. They couldn't store more than 500MB of emails per employee, which was ~45TB uncompressed in 2014. Because of budgetary constraints. Because they paid some dude rosemaro a half billion for an IT contract, among other things
- somenewaccount1 5y agoThis has nothing to do with securing your data. It's about denying citizens their right to privacy under the disguise of preventing fraud. I 1000% guarantee the use of ID.me cost the government more than they save in fraud. It's just the Patriot act in different sheep's clothing.
- Spooky23 5y agoHuh? The government lost tens of hundreds of billions in unemployment fraud during COVID, and tax refund fraud is huge.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoHow much of that fraud would id.me prevent?
- Spooky23 5y agoid.me claims to be able to validate identities at a level equivalent to NIST identity assurance level 2. (Not sure if IRS implemented that) If you look at the fraud activity reported in the media in places like California, most of that was using breach data. Validating at IAL2 would probably eliminate 90% of that. Tax return fraud is a huge business too, especially for people with large refunds due to EIC.
- somenewaccount1 5y agoTens of hundreds of billions is called "trillions", and no, what you just said is false.
- Spooky23 5y agoIt’s a typo, and should have been “or”. If you don’t believe that, I’m afraid that you are misinformed.
- jimkleiber 5y agoWhat information do you believe the US government should be allowed to maintain on its citizens? Anything?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ourmandave 5y agoMaybe the hackers have already figured out how to compromise that at scale, so they have to go to 3fa. Like a few years back when they were stealing tax refunds by filing before you or filing for people who'd passed away that tax year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomjonesey 5y ago
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agoAustralian government uses voice recognition to identify callers for calls to Services Australia, is this the same kind of thing?
- PopAlongKid 5y agoI already had a photo-verified-in-person account with ID.me as part of obtaining my California REAL ID driver's license. This involved a passport, proof of residence address, and in person validation. Why was that not good enough for IRS?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hanniabu 5y agoHow else are you able to data mine and milk the government for juicy contracts?
- jimmaswell 5y agoYou had to do the whole verification over again? At least it seems like the IRS registration is good enough to log into SSA.
- djoldman 5y agoid.me blog post: https://insights.id.me/featured-viewpoint/stopping-massive-fraud-and-identity-theft-with-equitable-facial-recognition/ https://insights.id.me/featured-viewpoint/stopping-massive-f... One interesting quote is: > Does ID.me maintain a database of faces that map back to original photos and who has access to the database? > ID.me retains the selfie that was used during the identity verification process. ID.me is the only entity with access to this database. The only time biometric information is shared with a government agency is when there is apparent fraud and identity theft tied to the account associated with the agency. I wonder if id.me keeps a copy of the photo of the government ID.
- monksy 5y agoI would be more surprised if they allowed for frequent believable audits that they don't.
- chrismeller 5y agoID.me was one of the most ridiculous experiences I’ve ever gone through. I’m used to shitty service, particularly when dealing with the government, but waiting in the queue for the web chat for four hours, only to have it crash and make me re-join every day for two weeks is insane.
- jimmaswell 5y agoWorked right away for me, besides the upload form being broken on desktop.
- hanniabu 5y agoSounds like the perfect government service experience!
- brnaftr360 5y agoWhy does the IRS even think they need this? I feel like this was developed from an incident at a stripclub after a ritzy dinner, which was then proceeded by hookers - and less to do with practical scrupulous enforcement of the tax code.
- pupdogg 5y ago> Why does the IRS even think they need this? It is very common for the government to use its various arms to institute large data collection efforts in the name of national security. A selfie video of yourself on a modern day phone provides for the government a high definition facial recognition vector for identification purposes. I'm sure you can imagine all of the use cases of having this critical data. Personal Story: My wife and I travelled abroad right before COVID in early 2020. On the way back, we didn't interface with any customs agents at the airport. Instead, there was a portable robot that took our pictures and advised us to proceed to exit. I can only imagine which image database it referenced for a perfect match to allow entry (passport, driver's license, social media?, etc). From a security standpoint, I would assume that the matching capability/requirement of such system had to have been best of the best.
- mortehu 5y agoIsn't the bigger story here that you were able to enter a country without a photo ID? Or did you not make the connection that it could simply compare you to the photo on your passport, like a person would do?
- wmf 5y agoThe IRS is facing massive online fraud and their budget probably doesn't allow internal development of... anything.
- somenewaccount1 5y agoI would love to see how much this system actually costs taxpayers and how much it saves in fraud. Knowing a bit about both of these, I suspect it's lopsided in a bad way.
- hakfoo 5y agoI'm mostly offended that they're using a third-party private service. We need a reliable link-to-meatspace authentication provider for the consumption of government services. That's obvious. But why are we outsourcing it to an external company, which may not be subject to the same purview as the government itself, particularly in terms of legally-mandated transparency, accountability, and universal service? I suspect half of this is anchored in the "mark of the beast" crowd who is terrified at the thought of any sort of coherent national identity document system. After all, if we had a central "Department of Identity" already, adding some sort of account system linked to the pre-authenticated passports and driver's licenses you already have would be trivial and within their wheelhouse.
- chrisin2d 5y agoI recommend the curious to check out DigiD. It's a relatively well-designed SSO for many (if not all?) national and local government services in the Netherlands: personal taxes, business taxes, municipal taxes, trash and water bills, health insurance (trusted private), social benefits, police services, and more.
- landemva 5y agoWondering why centralized department of identity is needed. Could it be decentralized?
- hakfoo 5y agoDecentralization doesn't add value because it's not really a consensus/disagreement problem. If you look at it a certain way, we're not considering the general problem of identity, just "association with government accounts". We already have an established set of roots-of-trust and dispute resolution protocols for figuring out which accounts you're attached to. All we need is a tech-friendly set of credentials to supplement the paper passport/driver's license/social security card. If anything, decentralization would be difficult for the legal system to work with. How do you force everyone else to accept an update from the courts, especially if they're politically opposed to, or disincentived to, accept the update? You could try to tie legal acceptability to staying up to date, but then you'd create a huge liability for software bugs.
- throwawaysea 5y agoIt is completely inappropriate for the government to force people to give up their privacy and share so much with a third party. And it is completely unethical for this company, Id.me, to pursue it. I already am able to use banks and other devices successfully without this service, and I used the IRS website fine as well. Why do this? It smells a lot like corruption.
- landemva 5y agoID.me gets paid via taxpayer funds. Each taxpayer can't line-item-veto the spend. Treasury has the budget to spend. Treasury gets to tell Congress 'security, good'. The spend cycle can slow if we radically reduce federal spending/income. Move truly necessary services to the States. That won't happen, so opt out. Structure your life to avoid qualifying as a person who files a return.
- chrisan 5y ago> Structure your life to avoid qualifying as a person who files a return Say what? > Move truly necessary services to the States The way some states behave, this is exactly what I don't want for America
- landemva 5y agoSlaves do as they are told or they get punished by their owners who own the fruits of the labor of the slaves. Free people have the right to choose. Are you free or a slave? No choice, no freedom.
- grammarnazzzi 5y agoA lot of government agencies aren't too concerned with the quality of their services. Things that discourage people from using thier system just makes their life easier. Theres's no consequence to the department and it's not their problem.
- monksy 5y ago> LaManna noted that any taxpayer who does not want to use ID.me can opt against filing his or her taxes online. Do this or you can't use a government service online. Ok terrorist. > “We believe in the importance of protecting the privacy of taxpayers, while also ensuring criminals are not able to gain access to taxpayer accounts,” LaManna added, arguing that it’s been “impossible” for the IRS to develop its own cutting-edge identification program because of “the lack of funding for IRS modernization.” Yea, sure trust a private org on data storage. Data breaches never happen..(Drizly I'm talking about you)
- laurencerowe 5y ago>> LaManna noted that any taxpayer who does not want to use ID.me can opt against filing his or her taxes online. This statement seems absurd. The IRS website doesn't support filing taxes online like a normal country because the tax preparation companies have lobbied to prevent it.
- treeman79 5y agoLast time I tried mailing in return I ended up sending it 3 times. They never got it. And I started getting scam calls where they had clearly gotten ahold of the missing returns.
- monksy 5y agoThis is worse... they have accepted electronic returns. Now they're blocking that from happening with this third party service.
- judge2020 5y agossa.gov supports id.me and login.gov[0] so I don't see why IRS couldn't rely on login.gov, which also does identity verification[1]. 0: https://secure.ssa.gov/RIL/ https://secure.ssa.gov/RIL/ (gonna have to wait till tomorrow morning to see it, as it has hours of operation for some reason) 1: https://www.login.gov/help/verify-your-identity/how-to-verify-your-identity/ https://www.login.gov/help/verify-your-identity/how-to-verif...
- monksy 5y agoI ended up contacting all of the senators on the finance committee (they're responsible for the IRS's ongoigns) I hope they took in heart my concerns about IDme being a piece in this data proxying/storage etc. Unfortunately: There were some senators who contact form was broken. (One in texas and I think one in wyomey was another.. other than that I got responses of "we don't give responses to non-constituents)
- greenyoda 5y ago> I ended up contacting all of the senators on the finance committee... "we don't give responses to non-constituents" That's a bit disturbing. Senators' work on committees affects everyone in the country, not just residents of the senator's home state, and one's own senators may not have a seat on that committee.
- monksy 5y agoSenator Cantwell (Was), Tim Scott (SC) were the ones that responded back with: Thank you for sharing your thoughts with me. As a matter of professional courtesy to my U.S. Senate colleagues, I defer to them and encourage you to contact your U.S. Senator with this issue. In addition, I deeply value my correspondence with South Carolinians; because of the high volume of mail I receive on a daily basis, I will give preference to responding to my constituents. Contact information for your U.S. Senator can be found at www.senate.gov. Thank you for your time and have a great day.
- diebeforei485 5y agoYou can contact the committee directly, by phone or fax. Numbers are on this page[1]. You can usually leave a voicemail if nobody picks up. For written communication, yeah most of us don't have a fax machine, but there are services online that let you upload a PDF to be faxed. They also accept snail mail, but it is very slow. 1. https://www.finance.senate.gov/about/faq https://www.finance.senate.gov/about/faq
- wolfgang42 5y ago
- gnabgib 5y agohttps://archive.fo/ySBCY https://archive.fo/ySBCY
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- golem14 5y agoDespite all the negativity on this thread, I'm pretty happy to hear they are reconsidering. Quite different than when the FCC was ignoring comments on net neutrality. Just saying. It's important to speak up.
- jimmaswell 5y agoI'll be pretty annoyed if I have to go through a whole other registration after I already dealt with their old login and now id.me.
- greenyoda 5y agoRelated article, where the IRS's use of face recognition was first discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29996614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29996614
- thrwawy283 5y agoNew conspiracy theory: Do all authentication through a private, 3rd party company that isn't beholden to the same restrictions of a government agency. Things like creating a video for facial recognition. Create databases that shouldn't exist for government entity, that the government can then freely tap into with things like the Patriot Act. There would be less restrictions and oversight on who this company can share data with, compared to an agency.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis conspiracy theory doesn't have great explanatory power: the USG has ample legitimate sources of photographs for individual citizens, via licenses, passports, and records collected in the courts. There are no meaningful restrictions on what the USG can do with those photos, because they're not private information. The USG has also openly applied facial recognition already, for things like border control. They're not really hurting for data sources.
- thrwawy283 5y agoNavigate to id.me's homepage, scroll all the way down, click on: "Do Not Sell My Personal Information (CA Residents Only)" Here's the link target: https://account.id.me/ccpa https://account.id.me/ccpa ID.me doesn't even have to be loyal to our government. There's no requirement for that.
- woodruffw 5y agoI don't live in CA, so this doesn't apply to me. I'm also not defending the government's decision to use ID.me; I'm not happy about it. But I think the reason behind it isn't some shadowy data harvesting plan by the USG; it's probably something between "we didn't want to do the paperwork to authorize, fund, and build this internally" and "someone's nephew works at ID.me."
- landemva 5y agoI can see Palantir buying id.me for the giant confirmed datastore.
- vsskanth 5y agoSometime last year I wanted to stop these early child tax credit cheques being mailed to me. I was shocked that I had to use ID.me to even do this one thing. OK fine, whatever. But then even after filling up all kinds of info, uploading pictures of my driver's licence and having literally scanned my face, it wouldn't let me login, because it can't "verify" me. I've been filing taxes online for many years without issue. I can't believe a private company gets to decide whether I can access IRS services.
- throwhauser 5y agoI've been wondering just how mandatory id.me is. Out of curiosity I tried to find if there was a way to address the problem you mentioned without using id.me. Buried very deeply in the Q & A via a link called "alternative options" it says If you can’t verify your identity online, you can call the telephone number on the letter you received from the IRS telling you that you may be eligible to receive advance Child Tax Credit payments (Letter 6416) But... the link to Letter 6416 goes to a PDF that has no phone numbers on it at all. So although id.me might not be strictly speaking mandatory, in this case it seems impossible to avoid, since the "alternative option" isn't really there. It's a Kafkaesque nightmare.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> the letter you received from the IRS this is presumably not the same as "the link to Letter 6416"
- throwhauser 5y agoI don't know about that, see section Q K5 here: https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/2021-child-tax-credit-and-advance-child-tax-credit-payments-topic-k-verifying-your-identity-to-view-your-payments https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/2021-child-tax-credit... To me it reads like Letter 6416 is meant to add specificity to "the letter" in the previous sentence. EDIT: I've found other examples of Letter 6416 online on non-IRS websites that do have a phone number at the upper right. I'm not sure if the phone number's absence from the sample PDF on the IRS website means it has been removed, or if non-sample copies would have a phone number.
- dismalpedigree 5y agoHow about login.gov? Govt run. Very well done. Already used bu multiple federal agencies. Seems like a shoe in. Throw out ID.me and return their lobbying dollars for good measure.
- cypherpunks01 5y agoTotally agree! I was just going to write this. Login.gov supports and encourages security keys (yubikey etc) as 2FA. I hope it does see wider adoption soon by more agencies, esp IRS.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt is the primary identity provider for the Social Security Administration as of September 2021, and provides identity services for ~211 federal agency applications. IRS is one of the last holdouts.
- throwhauser 5y agoI've been wondering why login.gov wasn't the choice in the first place, and the only thing I can think of is that id.me seems to portray itself as a fraud-busting identity service, whereas login.gov is simply a sign-in service. So presumably anyone contracting with id.me is convinced that they can help prevent being defrauded. What I don't understand is why any customer of id.me believes id.me's characterization of how much fraud there is, and how effective they are. How many of id.me's claims have been independently verified?
- jimmaswell 5y agoMassive amounts of online IRS fraud was a motivator, I believe.
- stephenhuey 5y agoAre the same legislators bringing in a private company to rectify also the ones who keep the IRS underfunded? Pretty sketchy.
- theknocker 5y ago
- stjohnswarts 5y agoDang the federal government is really trying on those “1984” clichés like a nice pair of well-worn blue jeans. Jesus Christ when will they ever stop?
- trembonator 5y ago