3 ms·
He's doubting the intentions of the author, he's not attacking a straw man. I don't see a problem there.
by stavros 5y ago
He's doubting the intentions of the author, he's not attacking a straw man. I don't see a problem there.
- quickthrower2 5y agoThe problem is if we get a comment every time someone thinks someone else has a hidden agenda, thats a lot of noise on the forum (or indeed any forum in general). People really slog it out like that on Reddit and it is quite annoying when they do.
- beebeepka 5y agoI see what's going on here. You've had bad experience on a forum I've never been and projecting your frustrations onto me. Why can't you assume good faith on my part?
- quickthrower2 5y agoYou are off in guessing my state of mind. My point is making assumptions about intent leads to boring discussion. See the moderators (dang) post history and what he has to reply to, for examples. There is a guideline on HN about replying to the best possible interpretation. Doing so diffuses trolls and encourages people who didn’t explain well the first time to expand on their thinking. It is also super pleasant to read posts of this style.
- mdp2021 5y agoLike quickthrower2 wrote, plus, the matter of duly post quality. There are two drawbacks: dilution of qualitative posts like signal in noise, and that each post should have inherent value (not cheap). Safeguarding personal expression (of the person as it is), every member should do their homework. This also involves finding the «strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says». You seem to entail from the formulation of that guideline («...easier to criticize») that only strawman arguments are discriminated: too literal. For that matter, one could have mentioned «curious conversation», «shallow dismissals», «insinuations». You should take the guidelines as a whole - the intention - instead of just their formulated parts (which are not a lean complete formal logical corpus from which all consequences can be entailed through sheer syntactical deduction). Literally, a mandate is there against what «degrades discussion».