3 ms·
>You're suggesting that in order to study the history of something, you also need to be a practitioner of it? So for example, a professor of military history ne
by coldtea 5y ago
>You're suggesting that in order to study the history of something, you also need to be a practitioner of it? So for example, a professor of military history needs to have combat experience? An art history teacher needs to be an artist?
I don't know if the parent is suggesting it, but I surely am. You can do it without being a practitioner, but worse (everything else, like your knowledge of the subject or writing skills, being equal).
- Ansil849 5y agoSo....an arson investigator should have a sizable arrest record for arson?
- coldtea 5y agoNo - they should know their way around matches and fires, and seen many in action. Including setting up fires themselves, just not illegally. Duh! Practitioner doesn't mean "illegal practictioner". Arson investigators' training (and even practice) includes setting up controlled fires to study how arsonists works or how a specific arson case played out... Does anyone seriously has to put this lame "so to be a professor/investigator of X, one must do X?" (illegal or impossible) question, when the answer is not only obvious ("no, but they should be aquainted with X to the best possible and legal degree") but has been clarified again and again in this thread?