3 ms·
>It's not just that this assumption would be news to people like Galileo, Kepler or Descartes. some of the smartest people who ever lived learned Latin and Gre
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
>It's not just that this assumption would be news to people like Galileo, Kepler or Descartes.
some of the smartest people who ever lived learned Latin and Greek, so you can see how easy it must be.
I mean not to say that it isn't just as possible as learning any other language, but the reason why we don't is that it is not that important all things considered to read Cicero in the original for most people. If it is important they will learn the language, and if they do that will probably become a source of income for them as it is a rare skill.
- Beltalowda 5y ago> some of the smartest people who ever lived learned Latin and Greek, so you can see how easy it must be. Those are just the people we remember today; many more were fairly fluent, but we haven't heard of them.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoMy problem is not with the idea that people can learn the languages, but that the example chosen as to why it should not be too difficult is among the set of people whom, judging from brain power, would probably find it easier than the normal learner. In other words it is a rhetorically poor argument. on edit: changed set up to set of.
- dc-programmer 5y agoJohn Milton was famously fluent in both. Paradise Lost is written in the style, form, and diction of an ancient epic. It also biased towards words with classical roots
- pfortuny 5y agoIndeed. And they did bot use it in their daily speech, which is what makes a language “alive”. As I said in another comment, I can talk the language of schemes. It does not make that langauge any more “alive” as a tongue than Latin.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIs it much to ask to have people who are academics, specialists in a field to have an aptitude for it? Like, is it unfair to demand that a professor is smart?