12 ms·
Tor Browser: a legacy of advancing private browsing innovation
- mayankkaizen 5y agoWhat are the chances somes org is tracking who is using Tor? I mean one can't see what I am browsing on Tor browser, but the fact I am using Tor or have downloaded Tor, is it also hidden information? Sorry, I know very little about it.
- foxfluff 5y agoIf you're using org-provided hardware and their network, assume they know everything you do.
- kreativ_py 5y agoThe issue I have with Tor Browser is the greater chance of 0day exploits for Tor Browser existing/being held onto, when compared to browsers like Chrome that have much greater resource for security. Remember, Zerodium revealed a 0day in all Tor Browser v7 and under once v8 had been released https://twitter.com/Zerodium/status/1039127214602641409 https://twitter.com/Zerodium/status/1039127214602641409
- noobermin 5y agoIgnoring of course, the blantant tracking that Google itself engages in.
- jokowueu 5y agoChromium then ?
- noobermin 5y agoThe entire point of tor is for very secure end-to-end encryption to the point that certain professionals (state actors and even criminals) use it for their purposes. Chromium is a general purpose browser that does not do that. You can't compare them because zero-days isn't the only relevant detail to compare here.
- beebeepka 5y agoRecommending chrome over tor browser due security concerns. What are the chances this very specific comment was made in good faith?
- Proven 5y ago
- tasha0663 5y ago> What are the chances this very specific comment was made in good faith? That's irrelevant, per the guidelines. > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
- beebeepka 5y agoWhat is your point? 1. I responded to the strongest possible interpretation based on what was said. 2. How is that irrelevant? If, for whatever reason, your goal is to conceal conflict or negatives in general, I suggest you pick on someone else.
- mdp2021 5y agoThe guidelines mandate you to assume good faith (you must observe them to participate here). This means (not exclusively) that you have to first answer yourself to that doubt you expressed vis-a-vis the post that originated it, and attempt finding an acceptable interpretation of the original post. Your reply shall reflect that. (If your «strongest possible interpretation» clashes with the assumption of good faith, you will have to think again, and longer. Surely, your reply will reflect that.) Contextually, for example: the poster did not recommend a non-identity concealing product over an identity concealing product /in general/ - the poster noted that the way the identity concealing product is developed/distributed, it is easier for exploitable bugs to be fixed comparatively later - the user must be aware of this. Also: > conceal conflict No. "Manage conflict productively", to achieve some result. «For whatever reason»: efficiency, efficacy, productivity, civilization, enthalpy (fighting entropy), "keeping the place in good order".
- dobin 5y agoTor Browser is just an old version of Firefox, with lots of known vulnerabilities. FBI is well known to take over Tor hidden services and exploit the visitors with a 0-day/1-day, which makes it easy to de-anonymize them. Privacy depends on security. Firefox is about 3-5 years behind security level of Chrome (Sandbox, Fuzzing efforts, hardening efforts, source code reviews, etc.).
- easrng 5y agoThat's not true, it's based on Firefox ESR which does get security patches, just not new features between major versions.
- chuckSu 5y ago
- southerntofu 5y agoThis is FUD. Neither Chrome nor Firefox are any good for *security*, as they both regularly get pwned at every hacking contest there is. Tor Browser is a different beast, because although it's based on Firefox, its attack surface is infinitely smaller than that of Firefox. When running in Safest mode, it's essentially just rendering HTML/CSS/images: anything that involves convoluted decoding (video, webfonts, scripts) is disabled. Treating your web browser as an environment for declarative pages is best practice for security: no matter how many layers of sandboxing you'll use, people will find holes. So apart from a few bypasses like the parent comment explained, TBB is decades ahead any other browser's security level out there (except for your favorite CLI browser over Tor which has roughly the same properties).
- commoner 5y agoThrough the Tor Uplift Project,[1] Tor Browser's Fingerprinting Protection feature is now available in Firefox on desktop and Android. The feature makes Firefox hide some pieces of identifying information from the sites you interact with, such as your timezone (which is set to UTC), some of your fonts, your keyboard layout/language, and parts of your user agent (for example, your browser version is set to the latest ESR version).[2] To enable Fingerprinting Protection in Firefox, go to about:config and set privacy.resistFingerprinting to true. Some Firefox forks enable Fingerprinting Protection by default, including LibreWolf[3] (desktop) and Mull[4] (Android). If you are on Android, the release version of Firefox does not include access to about:config, and you'll need to either switch to Firefox Beta/Nightly or use a fork like Mull, Fennec F-Droid, or Iceraven to take advantage of this feature. [1] https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Tor_Uplift https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Tor_Uplift [2] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-protection-against-fingerprinting https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-protection-agai... [3] https://librewolf.net https://librewolf.net [4] https://f-droid.org/en/packages/us.spotco.fennec_dos/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/us.spotco.fennec_dos/
- dwighttk 5y agoWith all the things that end up being surprising settings that fingerprint me, why is there not an “absolutely no auto-playing video” setting?
- 6LLvveMx2koXfwn 5y agoI just altered that setting and now Firefox resets my zoom level for every page I read to 100%. Makes HN unreadable as my default zoom for this site is 170% and having to set it every page I visit becomes old very quickly! Interesting side effect though.
- commoner 5y agoYes, disabling site-specific zoom is one of the things that Resist Fingerprinting does.[1] If you want to use site-specific zoom while keeping Resist Fingerprinting enabled, the Zoom Page WE add-on[2] should allow this. I've just tried it and it worked for me. [1] https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1369357 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1369357 [2] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/zoom-page-we https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/zoom-page-we
- webmobdev 5y ago
- account-5 5y agoGenuine question, what is Mozilla doing that's so bad? I know stuff like pocket etc but can't you turn this stuff off? Interested so I know what I'm missing and can make an informed decision.
- Ansil849 5y ago> what is Mozilla doing that's so bad? Automatically enabling Cloudflare to monitor DNS queries is my biggest current pet peeve. The whole reason I used to use Firefox was that it wasn't a corporate product. Allowing a corporation to monitor DNS resolutions is undesirable, as is having to trust their privacy policy, or that they will abide by Mozilla's policy (I don't, and more importantly, shouldn't have to trust Cloudflare). And yes, you can opt-out, but the fact that it is enabled by default in some regions is offensive.
- progval 5y agoTo be fair, there is almost always a corporation able to monitor your DNS resolutions. If not Cloudflare, then your ISP or proxy/VPN provider. It's a tradeoff based on the relative risks of leaking them to Cloudflare vs ISPs
- Ansil849 5y agoI would a thousand times over rather have my local ISP monitor DNS than Cloudflare. But the choice isn't ISP or Cloudflare. There are many options for secure DNS resolvers [1]. [1] https://dnscrypt.info/public-servers/ https://dnscrypt.info/public-servers/
- ShamelessC 5y agoIt's not like ISP's aren't shady af when it comes to this. I can appreciate your concern w.r.t. cloudflare but, at least in the US, ISP's are often more ostensibly dangerous than cloudflare. To suggest that Cloudflare is "thousand times" worse is a bit of a stretch, I guess.
- firefoxd 5y agoA few months ago i noticed an up tick on the number of people subscribing to my blog. It went from a single person Per day to dozens. Looking at my logs, I couldn't identify where these people are coming from. I've added a bunch of checks to make sure it's not an automated script, but they seem legit. Until I started i started looking at their ip addresses. Every single ip is from a tor exit node. I have no idea if these are fake users or real ones. I can't tell if I should be worried or excited.
- 3np 5y agoTor users are reading your blog, what’s to worry about? Unless your blog is about online privacy, it does sound sus, though. If it’s all from a single actor, I wonder what the end-game is. Is it on the level where it’s starting to cost more to maintain?
- asddubs 5y agocould just be one tor user, through different exit nodes
- culopatin 5y agoMaybe Brave browser users
- ohcomments 5y agoYeah... Can't really trust Tor these days can you? With unique members taking over multiple relays and exit points they can now relate where you're coming from and where you're exiting... Really doesn't matter anymore how extensive it is the browser fingerprinting protection feature or the access you do through Tor. I believe we need a new type of Tor...
- ravenstine 5y agohttps://geti2p.net https://geti2p.net https://yggdrasil-network.github.io/ https://yggdrasil-network.github.io/ Granted, neither of those are designed as proxies to the clearnet... and maybe that's one of the bad things about Tor besides its its history with DARPA.
- southerntofu 5y agoThis was always accounted for in Tor's threat model. That's why you take many different circuits depending on what location you're trying to reach. That's also why for the highest security needs VPN+Tor is a recommendation. Although to be fair i personally believe if an actor is powerful enough to perform traffic analysis across the Tor network, they're probably powerful enough to correlate your computer activity with the VPN<->tor link. Networks that resist metadata analysis are called mixnets and there's some interesting research about them. The downsides are you add latency (because each hop needs to randomize sleep) so bidirectional sessions like TCP is unthinkable. So nothing as usable as Tor Browser for checking your webmail or reading a blog.
- summm 5y agoOr, instead of TCP, content-based storage as in Freenet.
- southerntofu 5y agoYes P2P CAS (torrent/freenet/ipfs) sounds very interesting over mixnets. Do you have links to specific implementations?
- imhoguy 5y agoI am mild hoarder. I browse Web and write this comment using Tor Browser on Android. The thing I love about Tor Browser is such that when I end the session all tabs are gone. No more unlimited "interesting" tabs left opened for months. If I want to leave some information for later then I bookmark it in note app with a proper commentary why I would need it.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agobrowser.privatebrowsing.autostart=true used this for like a decade. this works like firefox focus on android.
- fsflover 5y agoAnd I'm using Qubes disposable virtual machines, which get destroyed after I close the browser. Helps too!
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agodid not know that. don't you need to use a new os for that? while this works on all desktop firefox machines, agreed not as secure and sandboxed but still
- fsflover 5y agoYes, Qubes OS is a special OS based on VMs.
- schleck8 5y agoEvery browser has this option. You can also set up the startpage to be blank with most.
- user3939382 5y agoYour ISP et al may not easily observe the contents of your Tor traffic, but if I’m not mistaken, the usage of Tor itself is easily detected and can have you flagged for further scrutiny. I’ve always seen this as a weakness of Tor. It would be nice if it had the bandwidth to be a default for e.g. Firefox which would solve this problem.
- mayankkaizen 5y agoI've never used Tor and practically know nothing about it. But I always wondered about something like this many time. I mean, while using Tor, sites can't track you or fingerprint you. But the fact you setup Tor in itself gives something to someone so that they can fingerprint you.
- HWR_14 5y agoSites can fingerprint you if you use Tor. Tor browser tries hard to keep them from fingerprinting you, but it's a different product built on Tor (although one by the same team, or at least the same organization).
- abdullahkhalids 5y agoThere are Obfsproxy bridges that make Tor traffic look like normal internet traffic. https://tb-manual.torproject.org/circumvention/ https://tb-manual.torproject.org/circumvention/
- noident 5y agoA more correct way to describe obfs4 is "makes Tor traffic look like unidentifiable traffic", which is in itself potentially a suspicious marker for people who want to watch Tor users. If Tor makes up the bulk of identifiable traffic, the value add of being unidentifiable is not very high. This is an active area of research for the Tor project. Pluggable transports are not perfect and can be profiled by a determined adversary, although it takes more resources and sophistication than identifying unbridged Tor traffic.
- ukfarmer 5y agoThis website was redesigned a little while back, and the replacement is still missing a lot of useful content that was on its predecessor. For example, although tor --help still sends users to https://www.torproject.org/ https://www.torproject.org/, as far as I know it's impossible to find the daemon documentation starting from there. The older website https://2019.www.torproject.org/ https://2019.www.torproject.org/ does have these docs, but it's surprisingly hard to turn up in a search. (You're much more likely to turn up old documentation on one of the man pages sites.) It's interesting to compare https://www.torproject.org/ https://www.torproject.org/ and https://2019.www.torproject.org/ https://2019.www.torproject.org/ more generally. To my eyes, the new site is uglier, less inviting and less useful, but I'm probably just getting old so my tastes don't align with fashion, if they ever did!
- ttybird2 5y agoThe new site loads much more slowly compared to the old one. Around 20 seconds difference for me.
- shroompasta 5y agoThis will be a contested opinion, but I believe full anonymity allows people to become the worst version of themselves. I've used Tor for a very brief period once in my life, and that was to purchase adderall off of either Silk Road or AlphaBay (I can't remember), and I'm unsure of what the Tor ecosystem is like today, but not even that long ago, the vast majority of the Tor network was used for crime - ranging from child pornography, to hitmen available for hire, banned weapons, and obviously, for drugs. I did not come across anything meaningful browsing the onion ecosystem, but left with a depressing insight of anonymity. On a higher level pov, anonymity allows some of the most toxic and damaging ideas to brew and fester. This is easily pointed out by the characteristics and behaviors between Twitter accounts that have an association with a real individual as opposed to ones that don't. The difference in what they tweet is staggering. Not to mention sites like 4chan and it's children. Don't get me wrong, I'm rather against Big Brother or ISPs tracking and selling off our data, but absolute full anonymity is just an invitation for some of the worst things to happen.
- foxfluff 5y agoAbsolute full anonymity is sometimes the only defense against tyranny.
- bbcabdalla 5y agoI think the Tor Network is similar to the clear web in that it can be used the way its users want it to be. Mind you, if you look to buy drugs on Instagram or Facebook you’ll find many outlets. Your experience is limited to the markets because that’s what you were after presumably. We created the BBC Tor site to help audiences access BBC News where they can’t and also to provide more secure access if they want. You probably don’t know how bad the internet in China or Iran is. Imagine you can’t access any news site other than the government’s own outlets, and forget about social media. We expected our Tor site to serve more users in Iran but interestingly we found more users coming to BBC Chinese, BBC Mundo and BBC Portuguese. We think we are getting more users from Hong Kong and Brazil who are doing it for the sake of privacy rather than circumvention (our clear web sites are still accessible in Hong Kong). At times when the news flares up, we get more users for BBC Russian, presumably because news consumers there want to have access to an independent source of news. BBC site on Tor: https://bbcnewsd73hkzno2ini43t4gblxvycyac5aw4gnv7t2rccijh7745uqd.onion https://bbcnewsd73hkzno2ini43t4gblxvycyac5aw4gnv7t2rccijh774...
- ugjka 5y agoTor Browser is great for checking sketch links or for making an anonymous complaint
- WallyFunk 5y agohttps://blog.torproject.org/tor-browser-advancing-privacy-innovation/survey.jpg https://blog.torproject.org/tor-browser-advancing-privacy-in... `Other reasons`. Would love to know other use-cases for Tor Browser Bundle besides the ones mentioned in the info-graphic. One other reason not mentioned is recon and intelligence gathering, or OSINT. I do little investigations on various topics, safe in the knowledge I'm anonymous doing so. Need to lookup about erectile dysfunction? (ED). Then Tor's perfect for that.
- twistedpair 5y agoWill we ever see a Tor Incognito tab in Chrome?