4 ms·
It’s funny what “bans” we get worked about and which ones we don’t: https://ncac.org/news/blog/images-of-muhammad-banned-from-book-by-yale-press https://ncac.or
by rayiner 5y ago
It’s funny what “bans” we get worked about and which ones we don’t: https://ncac.org/news/blog/images-of-muhammad-banned-from-book-by-yale-press https://ncac.org/news/blog/images-of-muhammad-banned-from-bo...
The next generation of leaders and elites will be educated at Yale. Meanwhile nobody can even find this town in Tennessee on a map.
- throwaway_4ever 5y agoYa last round of book controversy making the rounds was local progressive groups banning Huckleberry Finn.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- c0nducktr 5y agoIf you think it is important, please feel free to submit that as a post to news.ycombinator.com.
- tptacek 5y agoSeems... not at all really comparable?
- rayiner 5y agoIt’s not. People in rural America removing a book from the curriculum because of nudity and violence is innocuous. Yale censoring political speech is important.
- tptacek 5y agoA bunch of adults negotiating over a university press book --- one about the subject you're saying is being censored --- that nobody in the rest of the world will read seems pretty unimportant to me. I also don't think that the actions of a random rural K-8 district 45 minutes outside of Chattanooga is all that important, except to the extent that it got a whole bunch of new people to read Maus, and created more fodder for the obligatory bookstore "Banned Books" displays. Neither incident seems all that impactful, but the Maus incident seems clearly more ignorant and intolerant.
- rayiner 5y ago> Neither incident seems all that impactful, but the Maus incident seems clearly more ignorant and intolerant. Failing to realize you're kowtowing to political Islam is clearly more ignorant than having completely ordinary attitudes about nudity and profanity in a book meant for 8th graders.
- tptacek 5y agoI wouldn't want to have to defend either position, but if you put a gun to my head I'd much rather be the Yale Press person than the one earnestly saying that 13 year olds shouldn't read Maus because of "nudity and profanity". Maybe it's because I'm Catholic and grew up during the whole "Piss Christ" debacle, and recognize that there's nothing all that unusual about observant religious people being upset by art deliberately meant to provoke them, and thus --- like I said, I dont't think Maus and comic depictions of the Prophet Muhammed are all that comparable. You've read Maus, right?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The next generation of leaders and elites will be educated at Yale. But this isn't a decision about material that Yale will stock in libraries or allow in curriculum, but what Yale University Press will publish.
- pilotneko 5y agoI know it’s not the point you were making, but McMinnville is rather close to the Arnold Engineering Development Complex, which is a pretty large Air Force research facility (massive wind tunnels). There are likely a least a few bright kids at those schools that are being negatively affected by this ban.
- rayiner 5y agoNobody is being negatively affected by this ban. I learned plenty about the holocaust without having it delivered in graphic novel form.