3 ms·
> For message/call integrity and confidentiality: Wire and Signal are basically the same, because they use the same base protocol. This statement is surprising
by wolverine876 5y ago
> For message/call integrity and confidentiality: Wire and Signal are basically the same, because they use the same base protocol.
This statement is surprising to read. The protocol is only necessary; the implementation is the critical piece. Many apps use the protocol developed by Signal, including WhatsApp afaik. Insecurely implemented protocols are the most common threat.
> All of the measures they implemented can be broken if they wanted to (SGX vulns, traffic analysis, ...)
Also a bit hard to understand from a professional perspective. All measures implemented by anyone can be broken with enough resources, or at least that must be assumed.
> SGX vulns
As I understand it: SGX (on Signal's servers) is only used if you use certain features (i.e., you can choose not to use it), and the key stored there only adds to the security of your own password. If you use a secure enough password, the key in SGX won't matter. It's for users who choose weak local passwords; Signal adds a key locally that strengthens the local password, but needs to make it available to users who lose their old phone and want to recover their data (and similar scenarios).
https://signal.org/blog/secure-value-recovery/ https://signal.org/blog/secure-value-recovery/